Nano Texture iPad vs Paperlike and Alternatives

Use the Code: Ipad2024 at checkout

Join this channel to get access to perks:

-----------------------------------------------------

Twitter:

Instagram:

Drawing Tech Top 10 lists:

My Drawing and video gear:

[tayjn]

The reason for the nano-texture only covering the screen and not the bezels is because there are sensors (Face ID, camera, ambient light sensors) in the bezel that require full transparency to function. Rather than just cut out a safe area like most screen protectors do, Apple went for a more uniform look

[Ivan-upny]

Nano Texture iPad:
Advantages:
1. The matte surface provided by Nano Texture provides a little extra friction when drawing with the Apple Pencil.
2. Designed for outdoor use with high screen brightness.
3. The use of Nano Texture does not affect the visual quality of the iPad screen when in use.
4. Does not leave fingerprints like regular glass screens.
5. Designed for good resistance to scratches and wear.

Disadvantages:
1. An additional $100 cost for the Nano Texture feature makes it an expensive option.
2. Does not provide a significant improvement in drawing experience compared to the standard iPad screen.
3. Not suitable for users seeking optimal visual quality as the matte texture can dampen screen brightness and color richness.
4. Requires special maintenance using the cleaning cloth provided by Apple to clean the screen safely.

==

Paperlike:
Advantages:
1. Provides a paper-like texture when used for drawing, providing a more natural experience.
2. Protects the iPad screen from scratches, fingerprints, and dirt.
3. Adds a slight friction to the screen surface, enhancing control when drawing with the Apple Pencil.
4. Available in various sizes and models suitable for different types of iPads.
5. Relatively affordable compared to Nano Texture iPad.

Disadvantages:
1. Reduces the visual quality of the iPad screen by dimming brightness and reducing color clarity.
2. Installation can be difficult and prone to forming air bubbles underneath.
3. Requires periodic replacement as it is prone to scratches and collects marks.
4. Not recommended for users seeking accurate color reproduction or those wanting optimal visual quality on the iPad screen.

[AdamDuffArt]

Well, this was perfectly timed - I just ordered the nano version- shoutout to Tech Gear Talk for lending you his iPad - thank you!

[Tea-ghcu]

I think it was nice from tech gear talk to borrow you the ipad for a review focused on artist, thing that many reviewers can't do, tysm for doing this

[MythicPalette]

A good tip for the screen protector installation issue. Go into your bathroom and turn your shower on max hot water. Let the bathroom get a bit steamy, then install the screen protector while in your bathroom. The steam helps pull floating particles out of the air by making them heavier with condensation.

[HaroldsMind]

I've used a few different matte screen protectors in the past, and have stuck with Paper Like for the last two times I applied to my iPad Pro 11".
I updated to the 13" Pro M4, and got a chance to get Rock Paper Pencil from Astro Pad. Their newer version that uses static cling, instead of magnets. I gotta say I really like how the Rock Paper Pencil works and feels. Provides the right amount of texture I need, and as Brad mentioned I can remove it whenever I want. Their newer version that uses static cling (or as they call it NanoCling) works much better than the magnet versions, it sticks closer to the screen and much more secure. I've tried using it with their ball-point tips, however I prefer using it with the normal Apple Pencil tips. Definitely would recommend the Rock Paper Scissor as an option, the ability to remove it is something I didn't know I needed in my life :-)

[VIN]

You should review the rock paper pencil v2. No longer has the magnets so the protector sits on there much better without a gap (but it is still removable). I've really been enjoying it. Thanks for all your insights on the nano-texture of the new iPad!

[will__w]

Great review! I find it fascinating how divisive and subjective this nano-texture seems to be!

With a brief hands on with it in the apple store I was REALLY impressed, it felt just like a dekstop style drawing tablet texture. Not toothy like a matte screen protector or a paperlike, I actually preferred it big time, as a long time desktop digital artist, it was literally exactly what I wanted!

I'm really surprised that you weren't a fan, I found it incredibly similar to a cintiq/huion display, which (to me) is the gold standard for digital art feel! My only concern is longevity with the cloth situation, but I'll hold off a few months/years to see how they hold up (fingers crossed they're more durable than the studio display coatings!)

[bymarizen]

Thanks for the review. I do like paperlike but I am very intrigued about the nano texture maintenance in the long run. Like you said about the cloth. What makes me doubt is that I already had an incident with magnetic fibres that got somehow stuck to the tip of my pencil and I ended up scratching the paperlike screen protector. I am so grateful it was on the protector and not the screen... I cannot imagine that happening to the nano texture, specially because I do not pay apple care.

[nannuartworks]

I bought both the nano and regular glass. I took my paper like screen protector off my old one and put it on the standard glass iPad. I preferred the nano to draw on and for its better glare protection so the standard glass iPad went back

[rayman]

Thank you for this review - you pretty much hit the nail on the head!

A new iPad owner’s $.02:

I went for the standard glass and will pick up a paperlike protector for it as soon as it’s available.

As a massive, unapologetic Apple fanboy, I almost never go for aftermarket accessories if Apple makes something in-house - even cases, etc.. With this though, I just didn’t see any true upside to getting a permanent version of a protector I can remove later that ALSO covers the entire screen + bezels. Not to mention if I try to sell it later, I figure the impermanence could help cast a wider net when looking for buyers. 🤷‍♂️

[Sam-pmvy]

I’ve used a cheap magnet rough surface protector for 3 years now, the same one, no replacements. Never had an issue with it getting dirty despite using it daily both with fingers and pen (not so much drawing in general, more games/general browsing) and not bothering to take it off most of the time. It does have one small scratch and certainly you can see the reduced colour quality and feel the gap between the glass, plus it wears down pencil tips faster, but I love it

[tbray]

I'm going to change my tune - i initially thought that those magnetic/removeable screen protectors were a bad idea, but now that i've had mine for a while, i think they're the best option - when you're not using it for art, you can take it off, put it in it's envelope, and enjoy the good screen for video/social/editing etc.

[shinomiya]

I also use a Magnetic Screen Sheet. It is called "ESR Paper Fell", and yes, it gets a bit dirty, but other than that, I have no problems with it. I am someone who cleans screens often, so I don't mind cleaning it. I prefer it, because I can actually wash it. Something you can do with the foil. I also use a no name cover for the iPad, which covers and protects the whole thing, unlike the magic whatever thing. Because of this, I don't feel the need to use a foil to actually protect my screen, because the cover is already doing it. But I also never draw outside, I am afraid to bring that thing around with me, because thiefs and apple products... For the nibs, I use the one which came with the pen. I wanted to try others but I always reed in the reviews that there are some gaps and such, and I don't want that :/

[shingobingo]

I went back and forth on it but in the end I returned my glossy and switched to the nano-texture. The feel of the pencil on the glass wasnt very different, but the way the part of your hand that's resting on the screen glides around and not stick to the glass as much made for a much better drawing experience. Also the pencil doesnt have the issue of going over the smudgy part of the glass and suddenly sticking and slowing down either. I thought about just putting a matte screen protector on the glossy one like I normally do, but the nano texture actually looks better, contrast and clarity wise while also doing a better job of getting rid of the glare than using a matter screen protector.

[exmedium]

These are stick on but are far better,
and easier to apply.
Esanik Like Paper Glass Screen Protector for iPad Pro 12.9
I use a fine line metal nib, so they do scratch over time, but they come in a 2 pack, and are cheap/easy to replace after a couple of months.

[michaeljurwin]

Everyone has the nano texture not covering the bezels completely wrong.
It has nothing to do with the sensors. The studio display has nano texture class and it goes all the way to the edge and underneath the true tone and ambient light sensors. The only part of it that’s not covered is the camera.
The reason the bezel of the iPad is not nano texture is because the glossy edge provides more grip against your fingers and you are going to be holding the iPad by those bezels.

[TheConstruct_VR]

I’m currently LOVING the rock paper pencil protector. Minus clarity and all that stuff the writing/drawing feeling is fantastic

[joachimb]

I draw on an iPad as well but sometimes I look at the thing from a distance and I wonder how strange it is. So much thought goes into how to create a drawing experience that resembles the experience you get from a 1 dollar pencil on a 1 cent paper — just on a device that costs thousands of dollars.

[Charles_Bro-son]

That was exactly the info I was looking for, great take as usual!