Responding to Eastern Orthodox Objections to the Papacy

Erick Ybarra responds to Eastern Orthodox Objections to the Papacy.

Timestamp of all the questions:

00:00 Introduction
02:50 Do the Eastern Orthodox have an official teaching on primacy?
18:38 Is the Pope a one man show in Catholicism?
23:24 Does the pope just expect bishops to rubber stamp his decisions?
33:10 Is the pope the patriarch of the world?
50:07 Did the Council of Sardica grant privileges to Rome that it lacked before?
1:01:35 Did Cardinal Ratzinger say the East doesn't have to accept 2nd millennium dogmas?
1:07:33 Did St. Cyprian teach every bishop is a successor of St. Peter?
1:14:39 Were the apostles equal in power according to St. Isidore?
1:21:51 Were the church fathers united on Matthew 16:18-19?
1:34:10 What was St. Augustine's view on the papacy?
1:42:15 Is there a difference between a pope and another bishop excommunicating someone?
1:54:01 Did Pope St. Leo believe his tome was definitive before Chalcedon?

___________________________________________________________________
Disclaimer: Any view expressed by a host, contributor or guest is not necessarily reflective of the views of other hosts, contributors or guests.

🔴PLEASE HELP THIS CHANNEL GROW🔴

Disclaimer: Any view expressed by a host, contributor or guest is not necessarily reflective of the views of other hosts, contributors or guests.

🔴SUPPORT

🔴VISIT

🔴LISTEN

🔴VERBUM DISCOUNT
As a fan of R&T, you can get 5 free books and 10% off packages if you use the following link:

🔴SAINTMAKER DISCOUNT
A Catholic Life Planner Based on the Lives of the Saints
Use this coupon code to get 10% off: REASONANDTHEOLOGY

🔴PILGRIMAGE

[elijahyasi]

Timestamp of all the questions:

1. 2:50
2. 18:38
3. 23:24
4. 33:10
5. 50:07
6. 1:01:35
7. 1:07:33
8. 1:14:39
9. 1:21:51
10. 1:34:10
11. 1:42:15
12. 1:54:01

[lionheart]

Erik is a beast, ive never seen anyone with such a knowledge of Church history

[enerjiCS]

the more I research about the EO church and the RC church, the more arguments I find to refute both sides. this is going to be a painstakingly long journey for me to find the true Church that Christ founded, as someone who was originally Protestant. please pray that God shows me mercy in finding the One True Church, regardless of what I end up making a decision on.

[thebrainina]

Eastern Orthodox bought into the Catholic doctrine of the papacy historically. I’m not a Catholic btw.

[franciscovasquez]

Y’all should invite the “Church of the Eternal Logos” he is a catechumen in the Orthodox Church but his knowledge in philosophy is solid.

[romancatholicii]

GREAT JOB GUYS, YOU ARE VERY KNOWLEDGABLE.
ERRICK IM A BIG FAN. ONLY RECENTLY DISCOVERED YOU

[peter_hobbs]

Thanks so much for the discussion so far. I’m learning lots. Is it possible to get a link to the blog post mentioned at 23:30?

[jesusloveyou]

this sounds so lawyery. do I need to go to law school to be a christian???

[stavros]

This was a complete waste of time. Just like “the papacy of Rome.” The Roman Catholic guy talked up his point just to shoot it down himself when he mentions that Rome only has “primacy” not supernatural primacy. And when he says the Roman Catholic Church only has “primacy when it holds to Orthodox doctrine.” This is an essential metaphysical understanding of the relationship between Rome and the The Church.

[blazeontheright]

Pope never had power outside of Idaly, muh pentarchy.