All 11 DLC Tools/Damaging Consumables Ranked! Elden Ring: Shadow of the Erdtree

PVE ONLY. NO SPOILERS. All Tools and damaging consumables ranked worst to best. Consumable tier list. Patch 1.12

INTRO 0:00
(D TIER) 11 SURGING FRENZIED FLAME 0:34
10 INNARD MEAT 1:15
9 FIRE SPRITESTONE 1:46
8 HORNED BAIRN 2:29
(C TIER) 7 GLINTING NAIL 3:14
6 BONDSTONE/SPRITESTONE 3:55
5 CHARMING BRANCH 5:05
(B TIER) 4 CALL OF TIBIA 5:43
3 FIRE COIL 6:24
2 DRAGON COMMUNION HARPOON 7:09
(A TIER) 1 PERFUMED OIL OF RANAH 8:05
NEXT VIDEO? 9:10

[AnastasiaThemis]

Honestly it seems to me that Fromsoft really wants to make like, viable ways to use consumables in combat in their games but (maybe with sekiro as an exception) it seems they're also terrified of making them anywhere near good because they're worried about how to balance them. Bows felt very similar in the base game too, as well as pots etc.

[denisruskin]

Now we need someone to mod a Mario model into the game and do a fire spritesone only run.

[MelonKing]

The harpoons made an excellent addition to my sailor build

[EricIsntSmart]

Im still upset that the dragon communion harpoon is a consumable and not a throwable weapon

[liqqidsurgegaming]

Using innard meat on an opponent, makes dogs and other beast attack that enemy that you threw the meat at

[aryamerigold]

Personally i love Mohgs shackle from the base game and i have it constantly slotted.
1. You can find illusory walls in a good range.
2. You can activate/deactivate the flame throwing pillars in the base game dungeons.
3. The thing where you can change mohg (probably? i never used the item for the intende way)
4. New in the dlc for the sealed spirit springs i just go where the jump point is and use it and it unlocks it (for some reason in a huge area)
5. Also new in the dlc if you are near one of the pots with the bell bearings instead of shooting them down you can use the shackle and the bell bearing will drop. so no aim and shooting needed!
6. ???

[numerouno]

I've been loving the harpoons in the colosseum! With a strength build they do excellent damage and come out pretty fast. They headshot very frequently, especially against casters during certain casting animations. Great for safely punishing large AOE attacks like Messmer's Orb and Golden Crux.

[chancetherappersburner]

The Harpoons+Communion Grease is a must against Bayle.

[imykel]

Horned Bairn one shot me with only 2 projectiles when I was fighting against the npc.

[willchase]

The spritestone is actually CRAZY in pvp. Youll shoot it at a guy and after a few seconds they just tend to… forget it? And with good leveling it does a considerable amount of damage. What i do is throw it, do a little bit of damage to them, and when their guard is down, boom

[paincakes]

i think that these highlight a sort of fundamental flaw with the ER consumables that will never allow them out of meme tier in regards to damage or utility. the best possible use case i can think of for a craftable magic item is a ranged / elemental damage option for str or dex builds without access to spellcasting, basically the same niche as grease or pots. but linking the scaling to the relevant elemental stat means tying their most effective builds to characters that already have access to those abilities. they should either be flat damage or scale with the melee stats.

[Grimsly]

Call of Tibia is so fun to mess around with, still wish we got to summon that giant death laser skeleton but spinny skele is also good

[icetide]

The dragon communion harpoons would actually be one of the first genuinely viable consumable attacks if we could just hold a few more at a time. Even just 10, then they would hold a solid place as a great ranged option for when you're too busy two-handed your bonk stick to carry a seal. As is they're usable, but the limit of 5 just really hinders their use

[Eo-mskw]

I was so surprised and happy when I tested the ranah perfume because I really didn't expect it to actually do decent damage.

[gerdybird]

In my opinion the Fire Coil should take the top spot purely due to the Fire Coil Tech which is monstrous in PvP duels.

[tezereth]

I'd argue fire coil is easily above the harpoon. S scaling in one stat, much easier to craft and not finite, great damage and tracking, can have 10 of them instead of the 5 harpoon, and you can use it on something other than dragoon without feeling like you're wasting.

[chef]

The Dragon Communion Harpoon is really cool. Shame it's not a throwing spear with the Dragon Grease buff.

[cadenm]

Video was not filler, you were the only person who had a video like this and I’ve seen your other videos too, so thank you

[Subgenrelol]

Youwy: “sorry if this felt like a useless/filler type video”

Also Youwy: makes a tier list on the best bushes/grass

[danielrobinson]

The spritestone is really good in pvp. Slow, long lasting spells are nice for keeping up the pressure. That and this item has a strong knockback and large radius upon detonation.