The Virgin Mary Was NOT a Virgin Forever

The Roman Catholic Church and the Orthodox Church believes that Mary was a virgin her entire life. They also believe that she was born without original sin and that she never sinned her entire life. None of this is true. Its a complete load of rubbish. Mary was a virgin but she did not always stay a virgin. But this is a good topic to bring up with a Roman Catholic or with someone in the Orthodox church because if you can show them that the teaching of their church is wrong then you can get them to start questioning the other things their church is teaching. This could be the crack that breaches the dam can causes them to completely question and maybe even leave the Roman catholic Church or the Orthodox Church. Mary was a virgin when she gave birth to Jesus but she did not remain a virgin.

[bobbuley]

dead saints or mary canot hear prayers .Only Jesus

[samuelflores]

When a church says that there is no salvation outside of them, RED FLAG!

[fdavidharrisson]

I used to be a catholic. The way I get through to catholics about this issue is this... either Mary wasn't a virgin until death, or she sinned against her husband (this is huge because catholics believe she is the "queen of heaven). Because not yielding your body to your husband (or visa versa) is sin and causes your spouse to be tempted.

[albionblue]

You should do a video on infant baptism v adult baptism a hotly debated topic.

[raphaelfeneje]

God bless you immensely for your work✝️❤️🙏

[piotrjozwiak]

The Apostles would like to speak a word with you
If what you are saying was a thing, there would be more sources about it. Yet the Apostolic Tradition says Jesus was Mary's only son since the very beginning

[patrickbrowne]

It’s SOO CRAZY that the “Catholic church” teaches this, when The Bible clearly says that The Lord had siblings. Also, the scripture “Joseph did not know her UNTIL she gave birth to her first born Son” also shows that she and Joseph did eventually have marital relations.

[michaelnewzealand]

The only reason that Mary needed to be a virgin was so that she could fulfill the prophecy in Isaiah 7:14 and also so that Jesus was coming from the Holy Spirit not from the seed of her husband Joseph. After Jesus was born it says they consummated the marriage (Mat 1:25) and also it was not necessary for Mary to be a virgin any longer. The prophecy was fulfilled the messiah was born. So Joseph could have a normal marital relationship with his wife and vice versa

[christclinger]

The Roman Catholic Church always argues that sola scriptura was fabricated way later. Insisting that the author of scripture alone is not a traditional/historical Christian teaching. But for one it was recorded, in scripture, that the apostles used scripture to make the case that Jesus is the Christ to the unbelievers of their day. Jesus himself used scripture to argue with the Pharisees and show them their errors.
A true sign of a cult is that they claim authority and that their extra biblical writings are as important as God’s word.
If you read the Bible, the gospel is extremely clear. Don’t be deceived by cults who claim they are the only way. There is only one way to heaven and that’s repentant faith in Christ Jesus. The Roman Catholic Church will have their day in God’s court and it wont go well.

[lindseywalker]

There are no queens in heaven. Only One King

[Remoniq]

Starting to feel like you're the one of few that I can trust if I ever have questions.

[ninajones]

key words here "HER FIRSTBORN SON". Jesus was her firstborn. Not only son.

[benjaminofperrin]

Yes very good video. The Catholics unfortunately get a lot wrong.

[anthonypetrozzelli]

First of all, Catholics do not worship Mary! We honor and venerate as the Holy Mother of God, Queen of Heaven and the Holy Church! There is only one mediator between God and man, that is Jesus Christ! As Catholics we believe in the communion of saints, the great cloud of witness. See Heb 12:1 The Virgin Mary intercedes for us because she is the Mother of God, Queen of Heaven and the Church! All the church fathers believed this, even the father of Protestantism! The Virgin Mary is a stumbling block to Protestants and a gateway invitation to muslims! I pray for you and all Protestants to at least not hate the Virgin Mary, but honor and venerate her! She stated in the gospel of St Luke that all generations will call me blessed! Why are you demaning and cursing her?

[Dross-sn]

The whole point of the virgin birth of Jesus is that his soul came from God the Father so that he didn't have a sin nature. If Mary was born without sin then she should have also been born from God without a physical father. Yet we are told she had an earthly father. She also stated God was her saviour. The Roman Catholic church did not even come out with Mary being sinless and a perpetual virgin until the 12th century, which is around 800 years after the council of Nicaea when the canon of the Bible was finally established in 325 AD. In other words, even the apostles of the 12 apostles and their apostles the Church Fathers knew nothing of this perpetual virginity of Mary. Why do you think all the so called verified apparitions of Mary that have occurred around the world has her saying Non-Biblical rubbish which can easily be established to be demonic phenomena?

[heroevulgar]

James appears as the brother of Jesus, and brother of Judas, Joseph, and Simon.
The letter to the Galatians mentions a James, the brother of the Lord (1:18). Since it speaks of Jerusalem, it must be James the Bishop. This one, called the lesser, as Mark says (6:3), was at the same time an apostle of Christ. Since Jesus only had two called James; and we know that one is the son of Zebedee, and died by Herod; this other must be the son of Alphaeus.


Luke (16:6) shows us that James, the son of Alphaeus, is the brother of Judas Thaddeus. And we know that this Judas was the author of the Letter of Jude, which says: "Jude, servant of Jesus Christ, and brother of James" (Jude 1:1). We see that Judas presents himself as the brother of James. In Matthew 13, a Judas and a James appear as brothers of Jesus. But in his letter, Judas proclaims himself the brother of James BUT NOT of Jesus, whom he calls servant.


From the above, we conclude that the Judas who appears in Matthew 13 is the author of the letter, and he does not proclaim himself as the brother of Jesus, while he does of James, who also appears as the brother of Jesus, and is the one Paul saw in Jerusalem, author of the Letter of James. The name of Alphaeus, his father, is in Aramaic the translation of Cleopas in Greek. This demonstrates that:

The Mary who appears on the cross as the mother of James and Joseph is the same one who appears as the wife of Cleopas.
Cleopas is the same as Thaddeus, therefore Judas is also the brother of James and Joseph, who appear in Matthew. And it is corroborated in the letter of Judas, where he mentions his brother James, but it is not said the same of Jesus. Additionally, the Simon mentioned appears in (Mt 10:3) and (Acts 1:13).
Since the mother of these names is the sister of the Virgin Mary, they are relatives of Jesus, but not direct blood brothers.
Understanding that among the Jews there were no words for relatives, it is not wrong to call these cousins of Jesus brothers.

[raphaelfeneje]

Psalm 69 happens to be a messianic passage. Here is what it says about the Messiah

Ps.69.8 I am become a stranger unto my brethren, and an alien unto my mother's children.

Ps.69.9 For the zeal of thine house hath eaten me up; and the reproaches of them that reproached thee are fallen upon me.

We all know the Messiah was truly an alien to his mother's children!✝️❤️

[grizzly]

I am baffled how you think you're biblical. Oh my good Lord, I will pray for your lost soul.

[philiphultgren]

I really appreciate your videos! Bless you and your household in the name of our Lord

[GoodPicture-pgqm]

This guy has no credentials concerning the Bible. He doesn't think they're important. Listen to him at your own risk.