Sedevacantism Debate

A debate on the issue of sedevacantism recently took place. It’s about whether the Vatican II claimants to the Papacy (John XXIII through Francis) are true popes. We feel that it’s an important debate that many will find interesting.

[lucasbartholo]

It is a joy to be able to see the face of a true defender of the Sacred Doctrine, Brother Peter. May God continue to enlighten the Monastery and may more souls convert to the Traditional Catholic Faith. God bless you.

[watrewks]

Br. Peter was very strong in this debate as always. Glory to God. God bless you guys

[NG-weuu]

Matt Fradd said Br. Peter won the debate.

[tknoman]

finally some Catholics i can get behind, glad to find your channel and site.

[guyw]

Brother Peter, is a great debater, the best that I have heard on the internet!
why? because he actually believes in the Infallible Ex Cathedra Degrees, which all his arguments flow from, hence he always wins the debate!

Sincerely Guy.

[anthonypadua]

God bless MHFM for defending the true Faith against conniving, bad-willed heretics.

[ipsofacto]

Brother Dimond hammered it home whilst Jeff kept repeating his rederick like an Energizer Bunny! Take out the batteries, he falls motionless and quiet.
Brother Dimond won this debate hands down!

[arunjoseph]

Awesome debate brother. Jeff got serious Delusions sadly

[haydendude]

Thanks brothers. Your teachings kept me away from novus ordo. When I was ready to come back to the church.

[joserexatinan]

Historical Debate! Praises and thanks to God for the successful debate. Thank you Bro Peter Dimond and MHFM for doing God's will. We hope and pray for more debates for the sake of the Truth and for the salvation of many. God Bless Brothers Peter and Michael Dimond and all the Traditional Catholics around the World. We continue praying the Rosary everyday and always include MHFM in our prayers that they may continue and persevere in preaching and defending the One True Faith, the Catholic Faith, without which there is no Salvation.

[ChristofferCatholic]

Bro. Peter did a great job winning the debate. Sedevacantism was shown to be the true position.

[suzannelove]

I watched the entire debate…it was very informative and definitely worth your time. 😊

[julianj]

Incredible debate Brother Peter! (although it was more of a complete takedown of the heretic as well as V2). I have seen many comments as well as twitter posts saying they will be looking into sedevacantism because of how well Brother Peter performed! God Bless MHFM!

[Counterpoint_Apologetics]

This was a beat down of Jeff Cassman. Simply diverting answering to an appeal of authority was avoiding the anwer he knew he could not give. The fallacy of appealing to the majority along with appeal to authority are strong with him.