Dimond/Cassman Sedevacantism Debate; Trent Horn Refuted #AntipopeFrancis

Sedevacantism Debate: Are John XXIII Through Francis True Popes? Jeff Cassman Vs Br. Peter Dimond
Why I'm NOT taking down the Sedevacantism debate
Peter Dimond’s Sedevacantism (REBUTTED)
Trent Horn Refuted By Bro. Peter Dimond On The Catholic Church
Trent Horn and His Critique of Sedevacantism

And see:

Why Do Traditionalists Fear Sedevacantism?
Stuck in a Rut: Anti-Sedevacantism in the Age of Bergoglio
‘Anything but Sedevacantism!’ Analysis of a Curious Phenomenon
“Rethinking” the Papacy? A New Narrative for the Semi-Trads
Eclipse of the Church: The Case for Sedevacantism - Fatima Conference 2021

[JeremiahAlphonsus]

Sedevacantism Debate: Are John XXIII Through Francis True Popes? Jeff Cassman Vs Br. Peter Dimond
Why I'm NOT taking down the Sedevacantism debate
Peter Dimond’s Sedevacantism (REBUTTED)
Trent Horn Refuted By Bro. Peter Dimond On The Catholic Church
Trent Horn and His Critique of Sedevacantism

And see:

Why Do Traditionalists Fear Sedevacantism?
Stuck in a Rut: Anti-Sedevacantism in the Age of Bergoglio
‘Anything but Sedevacantism!’ Analysis of a Curious Phenomenon
“Rethinking” the Papacy? A New Narrative for the Semi-Trads
Eclipse of the Church: The Case for Sedevacantism - Fatima Conference 2021

[mjl.-]

Thank you for more commentary on Sedevacantivism. Much needed as in my area, nothing but N.O. 
I'm newly returned to Catholicism after leaving in 1960. As far away from the Church I had gotten, delved in many Christian and Eastern faiths, there's nothing as satisfying as core Catholicism.
I was 10 then, but have strong memories of having many Catholic neighbors, being an altar boy in early youth, as well as Catholic elementary schooling.

[asintonic]

No one dare debate the truth from Bro Dimond

[ben-ben]

What you call "Feenyism" is the traditional catholic belief that there is only one Baptism and it is celebrated in water.
Council of Trent: "If anyone shall say that real and natural water is not necessary for baptism and, on that account, should distort those words of our Lord Jesus Christ, 'Unless a man be born again of water and the Holy Spirit' (John 3:5) into some metaphor, let him be anathema."

Sadly some Sedevacantists like you still believe in some modernist heresies, you should humble yourself and recongize the truth.

[agrevstegvsgbytngyunm]

He did won the debate and I'm glad he did because sedevacantism is the true position. But beware of feeneyism.

[kenmcrae]

Watched the entire debate but none of the retort videos yet. I too think Peter Dimond clearly won the debate.

[TommyGunzzz]

new to this topic, but i dont understand your position at the beginning, you said Francis cant possibly be a true pope because he's not Catholic. So wouldn't that be a defeater for the papacy / RC in general then if your apostolic succession has ceased or that the Pope cannot defect according to V1? Wouldnt that mean he did and contradict the system? Genuine question out of good faith, genuinely don't understand the position.

[saqttra]

You can win a debate, that doesn't necessarily mean you're right. It just means you're a good rhetorician.

[dylanschweitzer]

Why do you sound like an old timey bat man villain

[kenmcrae]

So, I'm just curious why Brother Dimond hasn't submitted himself to a prelate, or priest descending from Archbishop Lefebvre? Are there no valid priests or prelates in the SSPX, who claim to be sedevacantists, that he could submit to?

[JacksonD]

Brothers, I won’t pretend I know the full ins-and-outs of the reasonings behind sedevacantism, and the rebuttals against it. I won’t. However, I just want to charitably offer a concern of mine to you, completely for your benefit. Let’s assume, for the sake of the argument, that sedevacantism is not true. This would mean that the devil would be successful in keeping a group of pious believers in Christ from His Sacraments. I want you all to be regularly nourished by the Holy Eucharist, cleansed by Confession, etc.; they’re such gifts. Christ wants to touch your hearts and sanctify you through His Church. For your sake, brothers, please reconsider.