What If Anakin Skywalker Refused to Fight Obi Wan on Mustafar

Anakin Skywalker had a madness before his duel with his former teacher on Mustafar. What would happen if that madness subsided before Kenobi's arrival? Would they become friends again? Would Obi Wan be able to forgive Anakin? What would cause this lapse in madness for Anakin?

Support My Other Channels!

Support This Video's Musicians!

#StarWars #starwarswhatif #anakinskywalker #obiwankenobi #clonewars #ppsw #skywalker #ahsoka

[kingkrby]

Obi Wan:“Only a Sith deals in absolutes…I will do what I must.”

Anakin: “Nope”

Obi: “Fuck you mean no?”

[venator-yvgw]

What if literally everyone in the clone wars went to therapy

[leonardowilson]

What if Obi Wan had nightmares of Anakin burning in Mustafar. So instead of Anakin having nightmares, it was Obi Wan

[birdquest]

I'm surprised Obi Wan didn't die again. So many what if scenarios end having Obi Wan die at Palptine's hand and I'm just happy to see someone not do that for once.

[TheBigCarp]

"Obiwan was here to give 1 final lesson." Man, that hits.

[Maik_Privat]

What if Dooku made sure the Battle-droids never targeted Civilians?

[CMGRL]

Honestly I don't thnk Anakin would be scared. I'd more expect like "What if Anakin had the time to calm down and reflect on Mustafar?" Or "What if Obi wan actually let Padme talk Anakin down instead of walking out"

Him walking out escalated the situation and I feel like she could've broken through and pointed out how little sense "Kill all the Jedi for me, your new Sith buddy, and I'll save Padme from dying even though you never told me so it makes no sense I already knew unless I was doing it"

Or even "What if Obi wan got through to him on the lava lake?"

[ChristopherGonzalez]

Padme was extremely forgiving to her husband especially after the purge.

[dr.veronica]

Anakin would *never* consider sitting on a beach, *surrounded by sand* on all sides, to be relaxing.

[aidanhelfrich]

Alternative title if anakin used even 5 percent of his intelligence in this scene

[Imaginationall]

What if Boba Fett was hired by the Rebellion and they kept him on their payroll for all of the original trilogy as a commissioned officer?

[CBarrett]

This was a really good take.

I recently went through a similar (not murderous) situation with my wife. I had anger and aggression issues that were unresolved through my childhood. So much so that I was thrown out. When I went to therapy I was truly able to heal. Now I’m back with my wife and my daughter. We’re more in love than we’ve ever been.

This what if gives me perspective on how effective therapy and self improvement can truly be for all men. Thank you for doing this story and narration.

[Fordo]

What if Order 66 and 65 are issued at the same time by Palpatine and the Senate Security Council causing a Clone Civil War?

[philardo]

If there's one thing I got from this video, its that star wars what ifs really grew up with me.
If this was a video made by star wars theory in 2016, we'd probably have Obi Wan forgiving Anakin in a heartbeat and them killing the emperor, but life isn't that simple, neither in the real world, nor theirs and your video really brings that across.
Tbf, them fighting Sidious IS what happens here, but the scenes in between matter a whole lot.
The stories you write have a lot of maturity, at least when they're not completely off the rails and I appreciate that a lot

Also Anakin being straight up ignored by Obi is weirdly nostalgic to me, funny enough. Reminds me of back when I was young. I'd do sw rps and sometimes everyone would just overlook my character lol

[patrickd]

What if as Mace fell he threw his lightsaber up through Anakin or Sidious.

[tainoman]

What if the Force Ghosts of Satele Shan & Darth Marr trained Anakin?

Got one of the greatest GrandMasters & one of the most open minded Sith Lords working together here

[dakotalange]

What if Shaak Ti survived and led a clone rebellion when the stormtrooper project decommissioned them, maybe join the rebellion or it’s created faster with their help?

[benjaminparker]

What If Thrawn joined the Republic
What If Vader joined the Rebels
What If Shaak Ti trained Asajj Ventress
What If Yaddle trained Asajj Ventress

[sbatou]

What if Anakin Got (Emotional/Psychological) Therapy?

Seriously, are there no therapists within or without for Jedi, or even Force users?

[dakotalange]

What if Shaak Ti and the other Torgruta left with Ahsoka due to how poorly the council treated her.
(This would be a huge wrench in Palpatines plan as a large force of force users would be active and not seen as Jedi as they had left the order, the Torgruta made up a good percentage of the order)