Best Amish Potato Salad Recipe! Traditional & Creamy (2023)

Amish potato salad is a delicious and traditional dish that is perfect for gatherings and picnics. With its creamy dressing, tender potatoes, and flavorful seasonings, it's sure to be a crowd-pleaser. The Amish take pride in their simple yet hearty recipes, and this potato salad is no exception. Whether served as a side dish or enjoyed on its own, Amish potato salad is a classic favorite that never goes out of style.

#PamperedChefAThon2023 #pamperedchef #potatosaladrecipe

In this video, I will share the best Amish Potato Salad recipe that I have found. Amish are know for a cooked salad dressing recipe. I am sharing with you how to make this Potato salad from scratch. I use serval pampered chef tools to prep the salad. Check out the coolest picnic cooler for your sides dishes at a outdoor event.

Click here to find the Pampered Chef-A-THon Playlist

Pampered Chef-A-Thon. Our intention is to share our favorite Pampered Chef tools, recipes, tips/tricks. Whatever you want to share in a fun and positive way is great! We all have unique styles, and Michelle, Ginger, and Tiffany are all excited to see what you have to share. Please note that a recent change of scenery has brought Tiffany from MuddNMascara Homestead to this team of co-hosts!
Monday, June 26, 2023 is the finale, to be hosted at 2:00 p.m. Pacific/5:00 p.m. Eastern. Viewers need to comment on each video to be eligible for prizes in the random drawing! They do not need to present to win. Unfortunately, only US residents in the lower 48 will be eligible for prizes. Encourage them to add a thoughtful comment and something that they like about Pampered Chef, if they wish.

Buying via my links will earn me a small commission from Amazon and this does not impact the price at all. Buying like this is a great way to support this channel and the costs involved in making content.
Thanks for your support!

✅ Subscribe & Never miss a video!

🛎 Hit the Bell to receive a notification when I upload new videos!

👍🏼 Thumbs UP my video if you enjoy watching, please!

Contact Information

Mennonite Farmhouse
P.O. Box 194
Needmore, PA 17238

00:00 Introduction
01:30 Ingrendients
02:15 Cooking potatoes
03:10 Food Safety Handling Message
03:39 Cooking Hardboiled Eggs
04:27 Peeling Farm Fresh Eggs with Instant Pot
04:53 Chopping Hard Boiled Eggs
05:26 Prep Work
06:26 Cooking the Salad Dressing
08:58 Assembling the Salad
11:12 Pampered Chef Cool & Serve
11:53 Howard's Test Taste

[BigValleyLiving]

Wow! This looks like an excellent recipe! I never thought to use the pastry blender for chopping eggs. Thank you SO much for participating in this collaboration! I learned the carrot peeling trick just now!

[ksmill]

You really did throw it in. Hahaha. You’re so funny.

[janetstryczek]

Thank you.
Absolutely enjoy you showing everything laid out to put together ! Also, showing simple techniques that some think everyone knows & we don't.

[carolyntuszynski]

Howards smile says it all and wow that man sized sandwich. He loves it!!!❤

[mary-catherine]

“This is your best one yet!” Lol. Howard is a character. Does he know how fortunate he is to have a good woman cook for him? I am definitely going to try this. Thanks and God Bless!

[YogiHollowFarm]

Interesting recipe to include carrots. Never did that before. And the dressing…very interesting. Will have to try it! Yum!

[lindapetersen]

LeAnn You can tell by the smile on Howard's face it is GREAT Like Tony the Tiger says !!! Howard has a smile in his eyes also !!!

[The_Purringlady]

We like a wet potato salad. Thanks LeAnn for your authentic Amish potato salad ❤😊

[MichaelsHomeCooking]

I tried you recipe and it was awesome! I cooked the salad dressing according to your recipe and added the mayo, so very nice! It reminds me of what my mother made. I never paid attention to how my mother made it, but possibly she did it much ... your way. Thank you for your videos as I have watched a few of them. Really love your cooking!!!

[reasbey]

This a very old-fashioned potato salad recipe. This is how my grandmother made it.

[WillowsGarden]

Oh LeAnn, that looks delicious and Howard really liked it.
Have a blessed night!

[Onedayatatimefarmstead]

The "LIVE" was so much fun!🎉🎉❤

[helenamorozov]

Salad looks so good
Thanks for sharing this recipe with us
God bless

[annettehachey]

I like this recipe! I like our potato salad smooth, creamy and it has to have pickles 😊.

[jacoleneiu]

I like mine wet and a little dill.
I've never seen this recipe before. I can't wait to try it. 😊

[boohoo]

hi im from germany and i have no clue how i ended up here but your videos are very well made and the recipe is pretty similar to how we do potatoe salad in my family. your whole style is refreshingly different and on point. the "ads" are a bit weird but overall i really enyoed watching this.

[ja_Iam]

Can’t wait to fix this. I’ve never used a cooked dressing on my potato salad. It looks absolutely decadent. Well done 👍👍👍👍👍

[ednamyers]

I love pampered chef... and all of your videos.. you do a awesome job and make it fun.. thanks for sharing

[jannie]

This potato salad looks very tasty, will definitely be trying your recipe...we have loved all your recipes we have tried❤

[abbiebarnes]

is this the recipe that wallmart sells in their delis? I rarely eat someone else's potato salad but the Amish potato salad they sell here is so good!