How To Make Amish Deli Style POTATO SALAD Recipe with Cooked Dressing

This is the best recipe I have found for making a good Amish deli style potato salad. The potato salad dressing is cooked and makes a delicious creamy dressing. Just in time for the summer time and Holiday get togethers. This Amish deli style potato salad is a great cold side dish for any sandwich or meal. Everyone will love it. Enjoy.

#potatosalad #delipotatosalad #amishpotatosalad #bbqsidedish #amishcooking #recipe #recipes #tesscooks4u

*****************************************

*****************************************

OTHER RECIPE VIDEOS YOU MAY LIKE TO SEE

How To Make BBQ Baked Beans Recipe ~ Summertime BBQ Side Dish

Classic AMISH Macaroni Salad Recipe ~ Easy Macaroni Pasta Side Dish

How To Make Marinated Mushrooms ~ Easy Mushroom Appetizer Recipe

The Best Burger Relish ~ Hamburger Relish Recipe

Pickled Beet Eggs ~ Pennsylvania Dutch Pickled Egg Recipe

Side Dishes ~ Recipes by Tess Cooks4u

*****************************************

The BEST Amish Deli Style Potato Salad Recipe

INGREDIENTS:
3-4 pounds of diced cooked potatoes - I used Russet
1/4 to 1/2 cup finely diced onion
1/2 to 1 cup finely diced celery
3-4 chopped hard boiled eggs
2 tbsp. chopped dill pickle or sweet relish
1 cup mayonnaise
salt and black pepper

Dressing:
2 eggs
3/4 cup white sugar
1 tsp. cornstarch
1/2 tsp. salt
1/3 cup apple cider vinegar
1/2 cup milk
1 tsp. dry mustard
3 tbsp. butter
*Place above ingredients in medium saucepan and whisk together.
Bring to a boil on medium heat stirring constantly. This will take about 10-15 minutes.
Once thickened, remove from heat, cool to room temp then refrigerate until cold.

Once cold, add mayonnaise and stir and add to potato salad.

Stir all ingredients together and refrigerate for at least 4-6 hours, overnight is better!

Enjoy.

*****************************************

PRODUCTS I AM USING ------ AFFILIATE LINK

Tess Cooks4u Amazon Store

Stainless steel nesting bowls. A must for the kitchen.

Corningware French White 10 Piece Bakeware Set

Corningware Pyroceram Blue Cornflower 4 pc. Glass Ceramic Cookware Set
Corningware Blue Cornflower Set

*****************************************

Follow TESS COOKS4U on Social Media:

Please SUBSCRIBE to Tess Cooks4u:

*****************************************

[aneeter]

Made it! Love it! Reminds me of the potato salad my grandmother would make. She always used a cooked dressing for her potato salad. Thanks for sharing.

[daveevangelist]

I was wondering why my sauce wasn’t coming out right, Great video 👏 👏

[saltycrow]

I make it the same way with the exception of adding sweet pickles instead of dill and I also like about a 1/2 tsp of celery seed added too.
After watching a lot of your videos I'm finding we cook very similar and use almost identical ingredients. It must be a Pennsylvania thing. I grew up eating a lot of Pa Dutch and German foods and all the women on both sides of the family were all great cooks. The men were great hunters and brought home the meats, the women cooked it up and it was always delicious.

[Seashells]

OMG this recipe is exactly what I was looking for. I love this potato salad from walmart. So happy I can make it at home now =)

[OnMyMind]

Would love a printed version of this recipe and others. Can’t copy & print directly from YouTube. This looks exactly like a potato salad a friend (from PA) made years ago. You’re baked beans are a must try. Tku!

[susanryman]

Wow. Never in my long life gave I ever made a cooked dressing for potato salad. I DO love russet dice they break down slightly. Again I am going to try this!!!

[QueenGoddessYume]

Thank you for sharing this with us. This is exactly what I've been looking for 😃

[tomstestkitchen]

Looks really good Tess, I would cut back on the sugar for my taste.

[tangojoe]

Yes please!
Wonderful recipe Tess, perfect for every summer get together!

[alisonhamblin]

Tess I’ve been binge watching all these videos! Got three new meals planned on the menu for next week. Can’t wait to see how tasty your recipes are!!

[fernandothiedig]

Thank you very much for the great recipe, such potato salad I never hat before, so will try this one. Best regards from Germany

[mariannking]

Thank you so much for this recipe... that's the way I like potato salad...will add some chopped green pepper...🥣🌹💚🌸

[caroled]

Doing this for Memorial Day! I'll let you know how it goes! Love your step by step directions ❤

[prdiner]

Yum yum yum. I so love potato salad ! The dressing was all new to me and didn't look complicated at all. We didn't make no potato salad last year so hopefully this summer we'll whip up some and this recipe should be one to make. Thanks Tess. I'm drooling now 👌👍😃

[caroljulian]

That’s how my grandmother made her’s. But she put her mayonnaise in a separate bowl and she would add pickle juice her spices and a little bit of sugar then her very secret ingredient yellow food coloring. My grandmother hated mustard so she used yellow food coloring in that bowl instead of mustard. Everybody in the family thought she had the best mustard potato salad there was and there was not one drop of mustard in it LOL

[thelarkandthewren]

Making this today! Potatoes are boiling now!

[missyr]

I’ve been trying to replicate the potato salad I buy from a Mennonite deli/bakery near me. This sounds like this might be the recipe I was looking for! Silly question... what type of mayo do you use? Store bought or home made? I don’t think I’ve seen a mayo which was so white in color. 😃 I’m definitely trying this recipe on the weekend!

[overandfantabulous]

Looks and I know is delicious sister Tess!
💖 Please leave a thumbs up of support just like I did. Thank y'all so much for doing so. :) 💖

[stjohnbaby]

I really like the cooked dressing, however too sweet for me.Great concept, I will modify to my taste.

[ompaloompa]

Quit lying...you know you ate some.. lol 😋