Barstool Pizza Review - Nellie's Place (Waldwick, NJ) Bonus Wing Review

After doing their local rival Kinchley's Tavern over 4 years ago, Dave finally tries Nellie's Place.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[brahimrejeb]

Watching every episode while I'm living thousands of miles away. Everybody knows I will never taste these pizzas

[riceball]

the score change was so magical, like a Christmas miracle

[freakinschweeet]

Dave needs to be on Hot Ones. Would love to see his face just melt.

[inspiredx]

Only dave can change the score..cause he knows the rules

[ImRobbieRage]

I'm a local who grew up on this pizza. Having my hometown spot get a score that good is one heck of a Christmas gift. Thanks Pres!

[bobscousinbob]

The sound of that first wing bite made me drool. 8.8 wing is top notch. let's go Pres

[resatchel]

The fact that Dave ate TWO pieces of pie despite being 8 pizzas deep is such a selfless act. He is the GOAT.

[orcaidhne]

this episode feels like an instant classic

[Ameesh]

The crisp of the wing gave me a half chub. Wow 😳

[nabeelsiddiqui]

The dedication that Dave displays with these pizza reviews is admirable.

[MrKeithkerr]

Dave just rammed a chicken wing through Kinchley's heart...this is a fact

[Dios]

He changed the score! “Human sacrifice, dogs and cats living together… mass hysteria!”

[miacervantes]

Whenever I get some pizza, I now gotta do my own reviews after every bite. Lol

[smokinnplatez]

Dave acting like eating pizza is digging deep in the 12th round 🤣🤣🤣

[RetailRipper]

man was right. tried to order those wings at wingstop, and was told "you cant get those here".

[dougefresh]

Can’t tell you how happy this review makes me. Messaged you years ago about this place! I grew up going here, damn

[Publiclighthouse]

For all the pizza Dave has eaten and the traveling he’s done between Nellie’s and Kinchley’s in those 5 years, he looks the same. Good work, Dave.

[shainazion]

Nellies makes it all from scratch, the sauce, the dough, the wings, sauce, I worked across the street from them for 20+ years.

[chinqlinq]

That edit into the 8.1 was very fairy-like. Just like Dave's decision to change the score.

[NEONGR]

I remember coming here as a kid. It brings back so many memories I miss living near there!