Barstool Pizza Review - One Night Only Pizza (Toronto, ON)

Dave stops by the under the radar pizza place One Night Only, and may have accidentally handed out an unlucky score.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[cncntrd]

He’s given 8.1’s to far lesser pizza’s than this. This deserved a better score.

[theeeves]

The amount of times he went back to bite that slice, thats easily a low 8. Pizza looks amazing and sounds amazing.

[ChirpyMike]

Eats half a pizza, blames mom for "shrinking" his clothes, everybody knows the rules.

[DimitrisAr]

You slaughtered this Dave, judging by the looks and the crispiness, this should have been between the 8.4-8.6. Not even overcooked...

[FriendsVsWild]

Poor guy just wanted to eat lunch in peace and loud ass Dave appears 🤣

[domainpark]

Love that Portnoy is getting ratio'ed here. ONO is in the mid to high 8's. Their crust is incredible.

[tmmb]

That pizza looked and sounded so much better than a 7.9. Judging by his reaction, he knew he lowballed it too.

[mrjoelsmith]

Multi millionaire new media entrepreneur refuses to change a local pizza review from a 7.9 to an 8.1 to benefit a new small business. Keep up the great work Dave!

[NaptownClassic]

That was one of the best SOUNDING pizzas I've seen on this channel. Every bite had that soft crisp I like. I know Dave prefers pizza on a burnt cracker... but this looks perfect for me.

[lekmusic]

Love how the owner was chill, no complaints, just smoothly went on.

[reslve]

Judging by the sound of this pizza, you did this guy dirty.

[davidvolle]

Should have been a 8.4, everybody knows the rules. Seeing how last pizza review you gave a nasty looking pizza a 7 you should have given this a high 8. Very disappointed. Everybody knows the rules.

[fantasyEXX]

That looked like a well cooked pie. Perfect crust. I don't care what Dave rates it, that looks like an amazing pie

[jrex]

One Pres who gets coked up and accidentally buys a boy's medium size jacket and then blames his mom who still does his laundry, everybody knows the rules

[dee]

Dave is ABSOLUTELY low balling all these Canadian pizzas. This is the opposite of when he was giving 7s out like candy mid Covid.

What a joke

[stratmagic]

Dave is in charge and should have given this guy a mulligan to get him into the 8's.

[jg]

Now everyone will have to try it for themselves. Dave's accidental low-ball is a blessing in disguise.

[kaptkronik]

"I wish I could change it"- Guy who made the show (and the rules)

[bolo]

"got a little flop" while holding the pizza arrow strait and has a crisp sound he would use to promote his frozen pizza

[bimjim]

7.9 means it’s at least a real slice. If he woulda picked any other slice it’s probably an 8.5. The owner’s real. Definitely the best Toronto slice so far. He’ll do well.