Barstool Pizza Review - Marcello's Coal Fired Pizza (Bordentown, NJ)

Dave visits Marcello's for another Tomato Pie, and has quite the pressure crowd watching him.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[charlesdemichele]

I’ve been watching Dave for the last four years. He ordered a margarita pie which simply isn’t his style. I remade a pizza based on style not on quality. And we weren’t all standing outside to put pressure on Dave. We all believe in our product and we were excited to be in a One Bite review. The score was awesome but the experience alone was once in a lifetime. I’m just a pizza guy from a small town in Jersey and I am committed to making the same quality pizza for anyone who comes to Marcellos. Ask for Chuck. Love you all.

[kaladinsinclair]

The pizza was an 8.5 at least, Dave was just feeling the pressure from the crowd of cooks, everyone knows the rules

[elwyndude]

That looked like at least an 8.6 from how he wolfed down a slice in 30 seconds...

[jaywood]

Dave won't ever say it, but the manager and staff stepping outside and watching will almost always get some points deducted.

[dylanpaluzzi]

That pizza looked worthy of an 8.5, great looking pie

[shawn-zxxt]

"Integrity" is now apart of Dave's vocabulary.

[Therocksteadycrew]

8.2 but he couldn’t stop eating that slice! You know he loved it!

[slash.]

That's what they get for standing outside the joint whilst Dave is trying to review the pie. Good on Prez for unconsciously punishing this type of behaviour.

[Fashda]

Dave has been consistently underrating these Jersey joints

[Eskareon]

Dave is virtually speechless and then rolls that lowball score.

[Courtneyemily]

I LOOOOVE Marcello's. Pizza aside, everything else is also delicious; just an all-around great restaurant. Bordentown city is a go-to spot for awesome food. So many great places to eat on one street!

[rickolson-]

Never heard Dave say 'Yum' before... the Pizza fills every one of his criteria but gives it an 8.2. humm

[TheMillennialGardener]

The less details we get about the pizza, the higher the score. If Dave gives a taste description, it isn’t going to go well. If Dave goes quiet, high score coming up 🍕

[ebitdareadthebook]

That pie actually looks perfect! It's wild Dave has given high scores to ones that remind me of little ceasars...

[DzekoVelez]

Dave's going to look back in 10 years time and realize he underrated these places, new pizza spots simply don't make pies like this anymore. Coal fired tomato pies you just can't recreate it.

[themadhatter]

Man the staff/owners really kill reviews when they hang around. I wonder if it cost them some points.

[mustardpikachu]

That old lady has more charisma than Dave when he's not on coke

[liamgamer]

Bloke with bleach tips getting an 8.2?! Incredible stuff! If you aint a short, overweight, Italian American with a family tree of pizza grand masters dating back since the Independence War, then you should be proud of that 8+!

[ChrisXMetal]

8.2 is a good score on Dave’s scale but you could tell they wanted high 8’s at least lol.

[GEAE_Denny_L]

When I heard Dave say ‘Yum’ knew it was a winner.