Barstool Pizza Review - Nancy's Pizza (Chicago, IL)

Dave gets into an argument about who sings "Time After Time" and meets a man who knows his pizza.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[thankfish]

that old fella really knew his stuff! seemed like a genuinely good guy who just happened to see you and couldn't contain his excitement, not to mention his knowledge!! the kind of friend we love to see. enjoy your pizza sir, even though you'd only give it a 6.2

[mrip]

The local guy was the best part of the video.

[michaeldallen]

Most polite area of Chicago by far. Even the employee faked gratitude after being slapped in the face with a 6.8.

[AlessandroSestito]

The Police Boys.
Every bite you take, I'll be rating you.

[AimFix-ypxk]

If Sting was lead singer for the Beach Boys. We would have the Police Boys.

[SecondStreetMustang]

“This pizza is terrible….l’ll take it off your hands!” 😂😂😂

[yuvgotubekidding]

The Pizza Boys.
Dave just wants to have fun.

[cks]

Young guy "I don't want to take too much of your time" old guy "back in 'nam I had a Chicago deep dish...". Everybody knows the rules.

[lunchbox]

So every pizza is around 6.5 to 8.3 now? He’s given like 2 scores outside that range in the past 2 years

[LaKriSby]

shoutout to the police boys, whoever they are

[skip]

100 Chicago style pizza's later and Dave still can open the box.

[coldcrush]

One bite. Dave and his dad reminiscing of how a slice should be

[ge]

I like The Policeboys. But I think The Rolling Toddlers or Blue Floyd are pretty good too.

[wilfordbrimleypranks]

We have a nancy's location in the st louis area, in o'fallon. It's one of the only places around here to get a good chicago deep dish. I really think it stands up to the chicago deep dish chains, and deserves a better score. Dave should have tried the deep dish

[kaynesheldon]

That guy was so genuine. It’s really nice meeting people like that in a time like this where shits just going crazy to be honest

[ScubaOz]

6.8 the new 4.8 everyone knows the new rules

[creditguy]

That Chicago box gets him every time. You can see it on his face as soon as he saw the pizza he frown. No ny cut into triangles.

[tt]

Chicago IS deep dish. Born and raised 15 min south of the city, I ain’t no tourist. Tavern is good but secondary.

[BB]

Love Dave when it comes to the 'Chicago' box opening, always a struggle. Opening it with "Dance Monkey" playing in the background. Classic!

[MarioFromMario]

As a Chicagoan I really hate the whole deep dish vs. tavern thing. Saying deep dish is "tourist pizza" is just straight up bullshit. They're both great.