Real Amish Church Lunch! | Peanut Butter Spread | Amish/Mennonite Style Food

*Thanks to Walnut Creek Cheese for sponsoring today's video
Today I’m sharing what the Amish eat after their church services! Peanut Butter Spread . #amishmennonitestylefood

Amish Peanut Butter:
1/2 cup Peanut Butter
1/4 cup Marshmallow Cream
1 cup light corn syrup
a little bit of maple syrup (optional)
In mixing bowl, combine the ingredients. I find using a butter knife is the easiest and least messy way to mix it! Enjoy!
You can store it in the fridge for a while, but bring to room temperature before eating. Makes 1 1/2 cups

"Buppli" Soup
3 T Butter
Bread
about 1 1/2 cups of milk? Add more or less if you want.
Melt butter until browned. Add milk and heat until almost boiling.
add Bread until it seems like the right consistency.

Chocolate Revel Bars:

All Info that you may be interested in:
📫 Mailing Address :
5824 Bee Ridge Rd
PMB 288
Sarasota, FL 34233

Connect with Me:

* As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.

❤️ Source List:;
Boy's Room:
Living Room:
✔️My Coffee Table: Custom made by My Uncle
✔️ Ikea Vittsjo Black shelf:
✔️ Shelf : We made it
Family Room:
✔️ Our Dark wall color: Cracked Pepper by Behr:

Dining Room:
✔️ Dining Table: Not available anymore
✔️ Hanging Plant holder : Hobby Lobby
✔️ Macrame Table Runner:

Master Bedroom:
✔️ Duvet : Target ( not sold anymore )

Videos You may find interesting:

[Vindi]

I'm not Amish, but my gramma used to make your "Baby Soup" for us when we were sick, we called it "Milk Toast". It's not exactly the same, but it's VERY VERY similar. She cooked the milk with a LOT of butter (scalded it), then toasted bread and cut it into squares. She placed it in a mug and added the milk mixture and I mean to tell you it was the best thing EVER! I am so glad to know that others are using it still. Thank you for sharing this!

[lindaswoveland]

I was activity director at a large nursing home in Florida. Work have me the opportunity to visit a Mennonite nursing home in a neighboring town. I was invited to join them for an absolutely delicious Amish/Mennonite meal. I was very impressed the cleanliness was impeccable and the food was unforgettable.

[YackBackatcha]

Bread lightly toasted and soaked overnight in milk with a bit of sugar and cardamom in fridge make a glorious bread pudding! From India! Top with pistachio!

[LisaR]

Love your sister!! You should have her as a guest more often!!

[melissaandrews]

First of all, y’all look like twins 👯!

[allysonsmith]

Oh my! You and your sister could be twins! What a sweetie pie you baby girl is! Love your videos, great recipe ideas!

[backyardbreeze]

When you hate peanut butter, but feel compelled to make the peanut butter

[jill]

I love these videos because I know nothing about your community and I love to hear how you do things and learn about your recipes!

[simply-allie]

This was such a fun video!! Keep the Amish recipes and backstories coming! Loved seeing Kara too!

[margareti]

I love the family and community vibe in your videos and also how you all enjoy the simple but important things in life. Thanks and keep them coming! We love ❤️ them.💕

[joycewilliams]

Made my Monday just to watch you all having such fun together. Love hearing about your Amish culture and way of life. It is such joy to see happy families. Love Kara too. She is always so cheerful. And of course we love your husband . He is so kind and good and a wonderful family man. Thanks for sharing your happy family.

[bellaleu]

It’s not too out of the ordinary, kids have been eating cheddar cheese & peanut butter crackers for years 😊

[shelbylynnwilliams]

My husband’s grandmother had Amish relatives & my husband spent summers with her in Indiana. He grew up eating similar sandwiches but he puts peanut butter spread recipe on 1 slice of bread & on other slice of bread he puts butter then filled in the middle with ham, cheese, pickles & onions. I admit when he first prepared it I was a little shocked. Nice to heR about yours & Kara’s childhood recipes & way of life.

[CampHorton]

Your sister is a hoot! It was so fun to see you two together!

[Mejiaelis]

Emmy showed your video today and I could not have been happier for you 👍🏼

[carolberubee]

Haha, Kaden's description of the baby soup was spot on. So good to see Nic and Kara. Oaklynn is getting so big.

[angrymuppet]

We lived near Holmes County OH and always would buy the "fluffer-nutter" at the local shops. In absolutely delicious!!!

[gailrussell]

My mom made a delicious soggy bread recipe she called " breaded tomoatoes."
15 oz Canned whole tomatoes, chopped
1/2 stick Melted butter
Salt and Pepper
Torn white bread, two slices

Heat together. So yummy!

[sarahplainmom]

How fun! You & your sister are a hoot together!
Also, I know I’m pregnant when I want a peanut butter, honey, pepper jack cheese & pepperoni sandwich.

[jenniferandrews]

I am German ....So I love listening to people speak Pennsylvania -dutch...I love how much of the German language stayed intact in it over all the years. I love Pennsylvania Dutch ....It sounds amazing <3 Also love this video! I am intrigued by the sandwich