Film Theory: Spiderman vs Spiderman Battle Royale!

There have been so many versions of our friendly, neighborhood Spider-Man now that the time has come for a CHALLENGE! A Spider-Man battle royale! Theorists, we are going to figure out who is the STRONGEST Spider-Man of all who have donned the mask and web shooters. Will it be Tobey Maguire? Andrew Garfield? Tom Holland? OR will a new challenger approach? Let's find out!

#SpiderMan #Spiderverse #PeterParker #MilesMorales #Marvel #Avengers #MarvelTheory #BattleRoyale #FilmTheory #Matpat

Need Royalty Free Music for your Content? Try Epidemic Sound.

MORE FILM THEORIES

Credits:
Writer: Matthew Patrick and Luke Barats
Editors: Dan "Cybert" Seibert, BanditRants, and Koen Verhagen
Assistant Editor: AlyssaBeCrazy
Sound Editor: Yosi Berman

Sources:

[FilmTheory]

Since a lot of people are asking about the Far From Home finale, two things we factored in but didn't expressly write into the episode:

1. Across BOTH MCU movies, Peter's use of the Spider Sense is inconsistent, just like the other Spidermen. Writers tend to "forget" that it exists when they need to put Spider-Man in danger, and so sure, Tom Holland ends the movie having "mastered" the sense, but we have no evidence that he'll be able to continue using it from this point forward (and we guessed he probably won't, because it'll make him too OP if he can predict EVERY move headed his way). We have to go by what we've seen...and his sense up until the end of FFH hasn't been great.
2. Yes, he "masters" the Spider Sense at the end, but is it giving him faster reactions times? He's able to SEE THROUGH THE ILLUSIONS of Mysterio...which helps him avoid bullets and avoid the gun...but his REACTION TIME is still on par with the other Spidermen (at least when it comes to avoiding LOTS of bullets, which they all can do). It gave him better intuition. So again, largely a wash when compared to the other portrayals of the character.


Don't get me wrong...Tom Holland is my FAVORITE Spider-Man. But FFH didn't give us the confidence that the Spider Sense was that much better than anyone else's. As such, when it comes to power set, in our estimation, Miles in Spiderverse still wins.


But like I said, it's a theory. There are TONS of ways to analyze the question. I'm really enjoying reading everyone's thoughts on the issue -- keep 'em coming!

[maddenb]

Top 2 Marvel snaps
1) Thanos’ snap
2) Gwen Staci’s spine

[lanap]

Me watching this quietly.
Matpat: I'm sensing you screaming at your screens right now.

[genesissupernova]

I just realized something, the Peter B. Parker in "into the spider verse" has mechanical web shooters and not organic. So its not technically the same guy

[lordchonito]

Miles has an electro shock, so Andrews electric proof webs would be kinda useful there

[kingbaaz]

Thumbnail: who will survive?

Me: Everyone, Spider-Man just doesn't kill

[Kjack]

Matpat: pretends video doesn't include Spiderverse for 15 minutes
Also Matpat: puts Miles on thumbnail
🤪

[renxybaluyot]

After seeing Miles go head to head with Miguel O'hara, and even escaping from the Spider Society.

This theory is almost a canon event.

[therealelem]

In No way Home Tom Holand really shows how powerful his spidey sense is, he literally moves while his soul is out of his body

[sunnyp]

Matpat: Tom holland has taser webs etc

Also Matpat: I can't really see electricity coming up in a fight

[araddadi]

“Just because i have spider sense doesn’t mean i have common sense” peter parker

[jedi_cat_l]

Mat: "I don't think having shock-proof webbing would be that important in a spider man battle"

Tom Peter: I have a shock webbing type

Miles: I literally have a shock ability

[Elmo_The_Frog]

After watching across the spider verse I can safely say that Lego Spider-Man is the real victor

[Pmfk]

Electricity will probably not happen in the fight
Miles: hold my spray can

[saoirse]

I don't know if Mattpat forgot or anything, but MILES ALSO USES ELECTRICITY

[angryscottishman]

For some strange reason, nobody ever acknowledges the scene from the end of Spider-Man 2, where Peter holds up the giant metal wall, then proceeds to THROW IT over his head. I feel like that is a considerable feat of strength that just get's flat out ignored by everyone

[Traivons_World]

It wasn't Peter B. Parker that had the same experiences. It was Peter Parker from Miles' universe.

[dannymartial]

Unironically, Spider Ham would win. He can pull a Thanos and drop a moon on his enemies, better yet, he’d pull the moon out of his pocket mid battle.

[dr.little]

Who would win?
“Karen, activate Instant Kill.”

[TimeBloxOffical]

Even though this theory is good in some parts there are errors.
1. With the web shooters Tom only used his normal web-slinging and gliding. Even with more options he does not use them. (Also, Tom's gliding did not look to be much faster than regular swinging, though correct me if I am wrong.)
2. With Tobey's train scene the train kept on accelerating past 80, with top speeds between a transportation train being 125-150mph most likely the train was going at least 100+. Also, the train was not just at one speed and was pulled to be slowed down, it was trying to also speed up. (Proof: We only got to see it at 80 but the bar clearly was rising past it toward the last frames.)
3. With Andrew saving the people from Electro you forgot to include the distance and reaction between him saving the people and dealing with the car.
4. Tom can fight with his eyes closed (proven from FFH final fight scene.) That makes Miles Morale's invisibility useless against him.
Otherwise, I am pretty sure everything else can be backed up by what you said.