Police Officer Sues Motorist for Defamation | Part 2

Peter says Officer Gibson was rude to him when he pulled him over for speeding, so he wrote a letter of complaint!

The Original! There’s only ONE Judge Judy. Visit our website for where to watch, weekdays.

#JudgeJudy

[sarahsmiles]

What a fool. Did he expect the cop to give him a kiss on the cheek and tell him he’s special?

[Koohiisan]

I guess he expected the police officer to hand him a cupcake, shake his hand, and bow to him too?

[Bujji]

I think he is going to sue Judge Judy for not thanking him for losing the case

[mattespoart]

The defendant’s face dropped the second he realized the plaintiff had a tape

[lolamaude]

The defendant is outrageous, what did he want his butt powdered, big baby? He deliberately tried to damage the plaintiff's career.

[MarvinForte]

But how else can I share my feelings? Go see a therapist. [savage] How do you "sugarcoat" a tape recording? LOL

[maravzla]

You cannot see the police demeanour but surely if he was agitated, snatching things from the car, pounding on the window you will definitely notice the changes in his voice. I believe JJ ruled correctly

[joecrawford]

He got a ticket and he wanted to get back at the cop by making up a story about how rude he was. He had no clue the whole thing was recorded. The defendant is a bad human being.

[jeffrowisdabest]

2023 Judge Judy would've ripped this guy a new one. He got off easy.

[jbw]

The defendant just reeks of entitlement and privilege.

[lightandsymbols]

Imagine if the plaintiff had no tape! There would be a big question mark over his character and a smear on his career with everyone side eyeing him not knowing if he had a rage/misconduct issue. All a big fat lie. He was professional, calm and efficient! The narcissist defendant has a problem with authority, refuses to take responsibility and didn’t like being told he was in the wrong.

[jenn_x.]

The entitlement is strong with this one 🙄
He must've authored the Karen Handbook!

[Conjuria]

The defendant was just angry he got stopped, and he probably didn't expect the plaintiff to have a tape.

[newsflash]

"You hear him being professional, but what you don't know is that, at the same time he was calmly saying those things, he was flipping me a double bird, you just can't see it on the tape!" What an doofus.

[ruthcalfee]

Unbelievable!!! The defendant was CLEARLY off his rocker and a total liar to boot!

[sarcasticgrunt]

Is this dude serious? 😂 He sued the cop for not coddling him? BFFR!!

[brt]

This is exactly the interaction I would want with a police officer, precise, quick and to the point. It's when they are all smiles but the conversation is about where you're coming from, where you're going, whether you have any drugs/firearms/bombs in the car, step out of the vehicle, I'm going to pat you down for my safety, do you mind if I search your vehicle, etc...I'm glad the officer won the judgement in this case.

[marfialennox]

I’ve never met this man, but I know his story. Wanna hear it? Here it goes:
When he was a little boy and a teacher told him NO, his mommy, Karen, went to the school and screamed, “stop saying NO to my baby, or I’m pulling him out of this kindergarten and have you all fired.“
When he got a little older his Boy Scout leader told him NO, so mommy confronted the Boy Scouts of America and said, “your counselor said NO to my baby, and I want him fired.“
At 19 he joined the military. The Drill instructor yelled at him and he immediately called mommy, who wrote a letter to the president and it said, “that mean man in the military yelled at my baby and I want him fired.”
You guys know I ain’t lyin’🤣😂

[Kaymarie]

The defendant’s feelings recalled a distorted version of the police interaction. The tape shows the “mistreatment “ to be a lie.

[damnnerves]

The defendant was acting like a teenager 🤦🏾‍♀️