Barstool Pizza Review - Papa's Tomato Pies (Robbinsville, NJ)

Dave finally gets to Robbinsville, NJ to review Papa's Tomato Pies, a bucket list pizza place and we get a lesson from the pizza maker in the back on what makes it a "Tomato Pie"

Follow Barstool Sports here:

[gordtron]

the crunch in the crust on the second go almost gave me tingles.

[patlynch]

That's pretty cool that Mike only works there, but he goes above and beyond to try to make the place look as good as he can. That's a hell of an employee! Great job Mike!

[BeachJedi]

For a pie not his style, 8.3 is an insane score. 👏

[jayb]

One baby sip of Pepsi, everyone knows he's a Coke guy

[wapierce]

One Bite, sponsored by Pepsi:

“Would you guys like something to drink?”
“A water would be great”

[Courtneyemily]

Coming from someone who has gone to Papa's with my family and has been served by Nick personally for decades, it is truly the best pizza I've ever eaten and the taste has remained consistent to this day. It opened in Chambersburg, Trenton or the "Burg", which is where Robbinsburg comes from, and it is definitely a bucket list place for any pizza lover. You can tell they have such pride and passion for their pizza and it shows.

[henryishere]

3 different scores. Everybody knows Pres breaks his own rules.

[polak]

Sign: Oldest tomato pie in the USA
Prez: Yea this is oldest tomato pie in the world
Looks at sign: yea

[AustinHopkins]

One below freezing day, everyone knows it’s only a matter of time until pres wears th woman’s jacket.

[stephencox]

This is one of the first pizzas that makes me wanna take a trip to try it. Checked every box I could tell just by looking at it

[ML-mqzq]

Never closed more than one day in 107 years. Until rona. Everybody knows the Covid.

[unwelcomemotivation]

he's legit disgusted with big mikes extreme talent and unlimited knowledge of pizza.

[kevinkirk]

“So hot and fresh out of the oven R.Kelly we don’t want to talk about him” 🤣🤣🤣

[PatrickGoddard]

There is an undeniable sense of well being I get from watching these reviews. I hope I can get out to the east coast sometime to try a few of these places.

[DirtyJohn]

Really wanted to see Big Mike’s reaction to the news

[bigbrytunney]

i live about an hour from this place, but just tried it today because i had a job not too far from it in Trenton. It's definitely different than what i'm used to, the tomatoes are the star of the show of course, but the pie was exactly like he described, light and crispy and when u bite into it, it stays together and doesn't fall apart. I was a pig and ate it right in the parking lot like he does. It's delicious and i would recommend it strongly. Need to try DiLorenzo's too!

[Buzazu]

That crunch on Big Mike's pie sounded like it was made by a professional sound engineer in a studio, not by biting into food out on the streets.
7:45

[buckjohnson]

If you folks ever get a chance to go to Papa's I highly recommend trying their mustard pie too. Sounds weird but it's amazing. Plus their red cream soda on tap is great.

[NoeticInsight]

9.1 is the real score, everybody knows the rules.

[jakeforce]

Dave, thanks for donating to veterans with PTSD. This veteran appreciates what you did.