Ranking Every Mario Game

I ranked 80 Super Mario games because I've actually gone crazy

Video Edited by: @TotallyNotJon_

Chapters:
0:00 Intro
0:33 Donkey Kong
1:21 Super Mario Bros: The Lost Levels
2:33 Mario Clash
3:13 Mario Party 10
4:31 Mario Party: The Top 100
5:17 Mario Party 9
6:06 Mario Bros.
6:55 Mario Party: Island Tour
7:34 Mario Party: Star Rush
8:28 Paper Mario: Sticker Star
9:23 Mario Party Advance
10:17 Mario Kart Tour
11:57 Super Mario Maker for 3DS
12:31 Super Mario Kart
13:00 Super Mario Run
13:38 Mario Kart Live: Home Circuit
14:26 Mario Kart: Super Circuit
15:08 Paper Mario: Color Splash
16:11 Super Mario Bros
16:48 Super Mario Bros. Deluxe
17:52 Super Mario Party
18:51 Mario Party 7
19:57 Mario Party 8
21:11 Super Mario Land
22:05 New Super Mario Bros. Wii
23:10 Mario Party 4
24:05 Mario Party 5
25:04 New Super Mario Bros. 2
26:19 New Super Mario Bros. U + New Super Luigi U
27:27 New Super Mario Bros U. Deluxe
27:56 Mario Kart 64
28:56 Super Mario Bros. 35
30:02 Super Mario Land 2: 6 Golden Coins
31:06 Super Mario 64 DS
32:32 Super Mario 3D Land
33:43 New Super Mario Bros.
34:56 Mario Kart 7
36:39 Super Paper Mario
38:09 Super Mario 3D All-Stars
39:35 Paper Mario: The Origami King
41:39 Mario Party 6
42:25 Mario and Luigi: Dream Team
43:55 Mario and Luigi: Paper Jam
45:28 Mario Party Superstars
47:20 Mario Party DS
48:15 Super Mario Maker
49:57 Super Mario Maker 2
51:44 Mario Party 3
52:42 Super Mario Advance
53:18 Super Mario Bros. 2
54:05 Mario Party
54:53 Mario Party 2
55:40 Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time
56:54 Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga + Bowser's Minions
57:43 Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga
58:52 Mario Kart: Double Dash!!
1:00:17 Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2
1:00:37 Super Mario World
1:01:52 Paper Mario
1:03:10 Mario Kart Wii
1:04:20 Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3
1:04:38 Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island
1:06:06 Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story + Bowser Jr.'s Journey
1:06:58 Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story
1:08:43 Super Mario Sunshine
1:10:55 Mario Kart 8
1:12:27 Super Mario 3D World
1:13:18 Super Mario All-Stars (Limited Edition)
1:14:07 Super Mario All-Stars + Super Mario World
1:14:20 Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
1:15:14 Super Mario Bros. 3: Super Mario Advance 4
1:15:51 Mario Kart DS
1:17:15 Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
1:18:44 Super Mario Odyssey
1:20:25 Super Mario 3D World + Bowser's Fury
1:22:04 Super Mario Galaxy
1:22:53 Super Mario Galaxy 2
1:23:57 Super Mario Bros. 3
1:25:10 Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door
1:26:58 Super Mario 64
1:28:09 Outro

[NathanielBandy]

If you enjoyed the video, please share it around! We spent over 2 months on this one :D

[MaruMarouan]

0:34 donkey kong
1:23 mario bros lost levels
2:34 Mario clash
3:13 mario party 10
4:31 mario party top 100
5:17 mario party 9
6:06 mario bros
6:57 mario party island tour
7:36 mario party star rush
8:29 paper mario sticker star
9:23 mario party advance
10:18 mario kart tour
12:01 mario maker 3ds
12:32 mario kart
13:04 super mario run
13:39 mario kart live home circut
14:28 mario kart super circut
15:10 paper mario color splash
16:13 super mario bros
16:50 super mario bros deluxe
17:54 super mario party
18:55 mario party 7
19:59 mario party 8
21:12 super mario land
22:05 New super mario bros wii
23:15 mario party 4
24:08 mario party 5
25:05 new super mario bros 2
26:22 new super mario bros U + New super luigi U
27:29 new super mario brus U Deluxe
27:57 Mario kart 64
28:57 Mario bros .35
30:03 Super mario land 2; 6 golden coins
31:07 Super mario bros 64 DS
32:32 Super mario bros 3D LAND (3ds)
34:44 new super mario bros (DS)
34:58 Mario kart 7
36:40 super paper Mario (Wii)
38:14 Super mario 3d all stars (switch)
39:36 Paper mario the origami king
41:39 mario party 6
42:26 Mario & luigi dream team
43:58 Mario & Luigi paper jam bros
45:28 Mario party superstars (switch)
47:23 Mario party DS
48:18 Mario maker Wii U
49:59 Mario maker 2
51:46 mario party 3
52:43 Super mario Advance
53:20 Super mario bros 2
53:08 mario party 1
54:57 Mario party 2
55:41 Mario & luigi partners in time
56:58 mario & luigi superstar saga + bowsers minions
57:47 mario & luigi superstar saga
58:56 mario kart double dash
1:00:17 Super mario Advance 2
1:00:39 Super mario world
1:01:53 Paper mario (n64)
1:03:13 mario kart wii
1:04:20 Super mario advance 3
1:04:39 Super mario world 2 Yoshi's island
1:06:08 Mario & luigi bowsers inside story + bowser jr journey
1:07:00 Mario luigi bowsers inside story
1:08:45 Super mario sunshine
1:10:57 mario kart 8
1:12:28 Mario 3d world (wii U )
1:13:23 Mario allstars [limited edition] (wii)
1:14:12 Super mario world + mario allstars (snes)
1:14:21 Mario kart 8 Deluxe
1:15:15 Super mario Advance 4
1:15:55 Mario kart DS
1:17:16 Super mario RPG Legend of seven stars
1:18:45 Super mario odyssey
1:20:25 super mario 3d world + bowsers fury
1:22:08 mario galaxy
1:22:55 Mario galaxy 2
1:24:00 Super mario bros 3
1:25:14 Paper mario and the thousand year door
1:27:02 SUPER MARIO 64

[jmaster]

The true ending: “*number 1, Mario teaches typing*”

[billcipher]

As a tryhard completionist, Super Mario Odyssey was a dream come true. There is always something new everywhere you go, and it feels rewarding to actually complete. And the Darker Side ending is absolutely the best ending in any mario game ever. Super Mario Odyssey feels like a improvement in every way possible with gameplay, endings and uniqueness.

[draculaschild]

I’ll be honest, even though I mad disagree with most of this list, I appreciate and respect the insane amount of effort this must have taken to make this. Kudos.

[RainbowDemon]

The fact that reaching roughly around the number 60 mark and we were already seeing games that Nathaniel was barely trashing and had mostly to all good things to say, is a testament to how good most mario games are

[sirbabybee]

This video was fantastic from start to finish, the pacing of each section, the bold rankings, and the self awareness of the Super Mario Bros 2 doki doki backstory that every YouTube feels the need to explain. It’s ALMOST perfect, personally I think Mario Galaxy, Mario Galaxy 2, or Super Mario Odyssey is the best, but that’s just my opinion. Great work as always.

[ThatOneMarioGuy]

1:17:19 "The game where Geno originated from *and was never really seen again"*
Mario RPG remake laughing in the background:

[Arob]

In the original Paper Mario, it was great how the world being paper wasn’t the premise. The world just happened to be paper. It was a feature, not the focus. It was charming to be a pop up book come to life

[JohnRiggs]

Donkey Kong is #80?! <JohnRiggs has left the chat>

[voidlazar]

22:23 I have a critique here. I think the koopalings being the bosses is pretty cool considering this was the first mario in a while with them.

[ReusCS]

Super Mario galaxy 1&2 is a masterpiece of a game. Not just in the Mario franchise, but literally a masterpiece of a game and experience

[mattbabineau]

64DS being so low on the list is baffling. Especially considering 64’s spot on the list. It’s one thing to prefer the original, but I don’t think the DS controls are so much worse to warrant putting way, way down the list in comparison.

[laredotxspidey]

Bro really said "and the bosses are the koopalings once again" for New Super Mario Bros Wii despite being the first modern Mario game featuring the koopalings.

[Nintenguin]

I’m so happy to see Paper Mario TTYD so high on the list is SO GOOD. It’s so complete, fulfilling, and just gives you those emotions from which I never feel. GameCube really did have some absolute bangers.

[EllieMiller]

I never thought of the Mario games as a whole. Like literally every mainline game and spinoff

[tazinboor]

Spoilers for The Whole list, don’t press read more unless you want spoilers




0:33 80: DONKEY KONG
1:20 79: Super Bros: The Lost Levels
2:32 78: Mario Clash
3:12 77: Mario Party 10
4:30 76 Mario Party: The Top 100
5:16 75 Mario Party 9
6:05 74 Mario Bros.
6:54 73 Mario Party: Island Tour
7:33 72 Mario Party: Star Rush
8:27 71 Paper Mario: Sticker Star
9:22 70: Mario Party Advance
10:16 69: Mario Kart Tour
11:56 68: Super Mario Maker: 3DS
12:29 67 Super Mario Kart
12:59 66: Super Mario Run
13:37 65: Mario Kart Live: Home Circuit
14:25 64: Mario Kart: Super Circuit
15:07 63: Paper Mario: Color Splash
16:10 62: Super Mario Bros.
16:47 61: Super Mario Bros. Deluxe
17:51 60: Super Mario Party
18:50 59: Mario Party 7
19:56 58: Mario Party 8
21:10 57: Super Mario Land
22:04 56: New Super Mario Bros. Wii
23:08 55: Mario Party 4
24:04 54: Mario Party 5
25:02 53: New Super Mario Bros. 2
26:18 52: New Super Mario Bros. U + New Super Luigi U
27:26 51: New Super Mario Bros U. Deluxe
27:55 50: Mario Kart 64
28:55 49: Super Mario Bros. 35
30:01 48: Super Mario Land: 6 Golden Coins
31:05 47: Super Mario 64 DS
32:31 46: Super Mario 3D land
33:41 45: New Super Mario Bros.
34:55 44: Mario Kart 7
36:38 43: Super Paper Mario
38:08 42: Super Mario 3D All-Stars
39:34 41: Paper Mario: The Origami King
41:38 40: Mario Party 6
42:25 39: Mario and Luigi: Dream Team
43:54 38: Mario and Luigi: Paper Jam
45:26 37: Mario Party Superstars
47:19 36: Mario Party DS
48:13 35 Super Mario Maker
49:56 34 Super Mario Maker 2
51:43 33 Mario Party 3
52:40 32: Super Mario Advance
53:18 31: Super Mario Bros. 2
54:04 30: Mario Party
54:53 29: Mario Party 2
55:39 28: Mario & Luigi: Partners in Time
56:53 27: Mario & Luigi: Superstar Saga + Bowser's Minions
57:41 26: Mario & Luigi Superstar saga
58:51 25: Mario Kart: Double Dash
1:00:16 24: Super Mario World: Super Mario Advance 2
1:00:36 23: Super Mario World
1:01:51 22: Paper Mario
1:03:11 21: Mario Kart: Wii
1:04:19 20: Yoshi's Island: Super Mario Advance 3
1:04:37 19 Super Mario World 2: Yoshi's Island
1:06:05 18: Mario & Luigi: Bowser's Inside Story + Bowser Jr's Journey
1:06:57: 17 Mario & Luigi Bowser's Inside Story
1:08:42 16 Super Mario Sunshine
1:10:54 15: Mario Kart 8
1:12:25 14: Super Mario 3D World
1:13: 17 13: Super Mario All-Stars [Limited Edition]
1:14:06 12: Super Mario All-Stars + Super Mario World
1:14:19 11: Mario Kart 8 Deluxe
1:15:13 10: Super Mario Bros. 3: Super Mario Advance 4
1:15:49 9: Mario Kart DS
1:17:14 8: Super Mario RPG: Legend of the Seven Stars
1:18:42 7: Super Mario Odyssey
1:20:24 6: Super Mario "3D" World + Bowser's Fury
1:22:03 5: Super Mario Galaxy
1:22:52 4: Super Mario Galaxy 2
1:23:56 3: Super Mario Bros. 3
1:25:09 2: Paper Mario: The Thousand Year Door
1:26:57 1 Super Mario 64

[CoolGorillaGoAnimate]

This is weird to say for me personally. But
Nathaniel Bandy's informative videos are some of the best background noise to fall asleep to. It's super relaxing.

[SuperVegitoIsTheBestCharacter]

I remember in 6th grade, my science teacher was looking forward to Bowser's Fury when it was announced. At the end of every school day, we would look at more news about it until it inevitably released. He's such a nice guy. Good times, good times.

[Zitsanrael]

Not surprising to see SM64 at the top but I've always believed it hasn't aged all that well, specifically the controls and movement physics. I'm nostalgic as hell for it, I got it for Xmas in '96 when I was just shy of 6 years old, but even so, it's tough for me to go back to it when I can just play Odyssey or Galaxy. I pretty much have to readjust to the controls again every time I turn SM64 on, which I just personally find kind of frustrating. Whereas the release of SM3DAS was the first time I had played Galaxy in a few years and I still felt right at home.

For as much love as I have for SM64 itself, it's a game I really have to talk myself into replaying nowadays.