The WHY TREES Mystery Every Players Missed In RDR2 Finally SOLVED! | Red Dead Redemption 2

In today’s video, we are trying something a little bit different! I’m very excited to present my first official “Red Dead Mystery” video. This is a formula very similar to one of my favorite Red Dead Redemption Content Creators, Strange Man. I’m very impressed with his video presentation and style. I aspire to be on the same level as him and other greats, such as Fizhy. I was tired of being categorized as a “repetitive” clips channel, which I never was, and I was disgusted by the community I had that at one time encourage me to make more videos of secrets in a clips inspired layout and then betrayed a year later to hear everyone complain about it. But I can see why. I was one of the first RDR2 YouTube channels that had MASSIVE success in such a short amount of time which led to absolutely LAZY channels such as Brother Foller to steal almost every video and video title I had, word for word, to harvest his own greed and hypocrisy. I’ve had people commend me on their own channels, just for months later to resent me for the same thing they congratulated me for. The one thing I can say about these channels is for the “Baited” channels such as the one’s mentioned above, I can’t understand how they still receive a massive amount of views occasionally for lazy, washed-out, fake, deceptive, repetitive, and stolen from each other, utter NONSENSE, while channels like me, Filbee gaming, and other great YouTube channels dedicated to LEGIT and insightful Red Dead Redemption videos, no longer receive the amount of views we once had for the amount of work we put in. I mean we are uploading on the same caliber as Strange Man, and other great channels, with never before seen content and original ideas! However, YouTube itself has the audacity to promote these 15-30 second clips of garbage and leave us behind and in the dark. I’m disgusted and ashamed to be apart of such a company that literally has no respect for smaller channels or support. But for the bigger channels that post suggestive and demeaning content, is promoted and encouraged to literally thousands, if not MILLIONS, of people and only go higher from there. But I will not be discouraged. Even though my videos don’t get near the same amount of views, it’s disheartening. Considering the amount of time and effort I put myself through to bring the content I do now. Literally days of my life go into making these videos, and these dumb clip channels that I mentioned post 20 fifteen second clips a day and earn ridiculous views from this laziness. But I do it for the loyal fan base I now have and for my subscribers, and new viewers, who actually take time out of their day to watch my videos and appreciate them. I know they are the ones who will lead the charge to boosting my channels success back to the rate that it once had. And I am much happier with them now, as the previous viewership was fake and unreliable. There one day and saying things against me the next. I have so many blocked accounts, it’s unbelievable. Truly. All, mostly people who were once so nice and supportive and in a matter of months, turned on me and forgot their kindness. But now, with the viewers I currently have, have supported me since I made the new changes to my channel and have stuck with me every day since. Sorry for the rant, but I am tired of being purposefully outed and suppressed by YouTube’s CORRUPTION, the disloyalty of viewers, and the unfair advantage undeserving channels get. They all can stick it where the sun don’t shine. But anyway, here is a new video about the WHY TREES Mystery that a lot of players have not noticed still in Red Dead Redemption 2. It is not a confirmed explanation of the WHY TREES, but it is my best hypothesis as to explaining them and I believe it’s truly plausible. I would strongly suggest looking into the mystery yourselves and seeing what you can come up with! I’d love to hear it in the comments what your thoughts are on this subject and if you have ever noticed it before! Thanks everyone! #rdr2 #reddeadredemption #arthurmorgan

[truthhurts]

27 is probably the number of years before we get another Red Dead 😂

[clarkkent]

How have I never noticed the bull wagon connection before. Very thorough investigation, very well presented case as well. I think Strange Man would like this.

[lucianosteinbach]

My theory is that Francis traveled back in time to the year of his birth to leave that map as a guide for himself, in order to become a time traveler.
This would explain the confusion that Francis shows the first time we meet him, as it is a paradox, in which he becomes a time traveler only because he himself traveled to the year of his own birth, and left to himself the guidelines on how to become a time traveler.
And as he goes back to the year of his birth, he does not speak to himself, but to his own mother, as she does not show any surprise at all those notes on the wall of her own house, or at the fact that a stranger, we, know and are looking for her son, who is still a baby at this point.
She knows that her son will become a time traveler, and is probably the person who gave him the instructions for this to happen. That's why Francis needs our help to find the rock carvings, because he received the map information indirectly, through his mother; he knows he needs to build this map for himself, but he doesn't know how the map should be.
Now, if he already knows what is represented in the carvings, why would he need to know the locations, I don't know, unless he is also the author of the engravings, at a future moment in his own timeline.
That would make everything a big spider web, where Francis Sinclair becomes a time traveler, because he himself, after becoming a time traveler, went back in time and left the map to himself, and after that he came back further back in time and left the engravings to guide himself in the construction of that same map.
Its very confusing, but makes a lot of sense to me.

[Nicola_Bailey]

The "baby is a doll" theory is one of Stange Man's most outlandish and I personally think complete nonsense theories. I just don't think they wanted to animate a baby for a two second skit, so did a sleeping one instead, wrap in a blanket so no fingers and toes to model and boom, job done. However, is it my imagination or does his mother also bare the facial mark?? Pause the vid and look closely, I'm sure she does.

[paperbucks]

Little interesting note! One of the newspaper boys (cant rember the town, mabey strawberry) has Francis's birthmark and is a red head! So that might help.

[partlycloudy]

Im on my 3rd play through, and I keep finding new things on each play through that has me scratching my head.
RDR2, the game that keeps on giving.
Great video 👍

[onii-chandaisuki]

Imagine if the secret is you can time travel and kill Micah.

[DJFrankeeTNT]

I’m probably mistaken by this, but the 27 could be referring to the 27th piece of paper nailed up along the map of Francis and his time travels. Maybe there are more hidden numbers nearby each time travel. Just a thought. GREAT video !!

[chillmushroom]

You should make a collab with strange man. Would be cool to see you two doing something together

[Bazingam]

I think Francis wanted to travel to the year he was born but he got stuck and needed to get the rock carvings so he can no longer be trapped in the year he was born in.

[_brunocavalcante]

2:34 Since the first time I saw this cutscene, I had the impression that this supposed mother of Francis is actually acting, playing a role, and in a very poorly done way... A terrible actress. Perhaps Rockstar intentionally included this element of bad acting, which, combined with the fact that the baby is fake and actually a doll... This could be a clue for many interpretations.

[lesmortz]

You have Nuke’s Top 5 levels of observation with that 27 reveal yo! Keep these coming 😎👍

[zerdeaths]

If you wear the Viking helmet, hold the Viking axe on hand and have the Viking beard comb in your inventory and go to that spot you will get struck by lightning.

[Guardian]

What if the cattle driver was his father, and because he accidentally miscalculated a small variable, he ended his fathers life before he was born

[Dan-Kart]

This is very thorough investigation, props to you man! Based on this I have a theory that in 2027 Francis will come back in GTA 6 (which I hope is out by then) online as some special event. That or he's gonna be a prominent part of one of the story missions, that's why it's taking so long to release it lol! Then maybe we'll get some answers to some of these mysteries, that or we'll just be left with more questions.

[FilbeeGaming]

Excellent video, you've put a LOT of research into this. Well done!

[lwhtehrsel]

The level of detail and story writing in this game is incredible. Also, notice the references on the left and right of the map. The one skyscraper looks like Empire State Building. All the other little scenes, the meteorite, the star, the Viking longship, The pyramids, the Sphinx and Francis facing the opposite direction, as if comparing himself to Pharaoh Khafre as he compared himself to the God Horus. Three images of him stepping in and stepping out of the portal suggests maybe he has leapt multiple times and has visited these locations. The wagon site being the 27th and he carved it on the tree as a notation. The burned area reminds me of the Terminator movies where he arrives in the ball with the lightning around him and everything is incinerated.

[nunyanunya]

ALRIGHT! one ov those videos where we have to read! like a book! so much like a video!

[lord_egg]

I think the 27 is a coordinate of some kind. My guess is that Francis accidentally time travelled after researching the carvings that’s why he’s ‘a little lost’. So his plan is to find the carvings again and figure out if there’s any way to return home. One of the things that needs to be is certain numbers or icons being present during major timeline events or fixed points or any other weird or major moments in history. One of them is the lightning strike which makes the trees fall and break in a certain way to create that why shape. Once those coordinates are in place within time he is then able to open up a gateway either mechanical or magical and return home…or maybe he continues down the rabbit hole of time (I’ll leave that to personal preference).

[hidatti]

That actually makes a lot of sense. Except the theory of the baby being a doll...