Did you notice 'this subtle detail' in HARRY POTTER?? #harrypotter

preview_player
Показать описание
Did you notice "this subtle detail" in HARRY POTTER?? #harrypotter
Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

Why was Ron sitting in the Hospital Wing with a still broken leg and Muggle cast if Madame Pomfrey can heal broken bones in a second??

Half-BloodUniversity_
Автор

That's not a broken bone. It's deeply bitten. The flesh is completely ruined there as well.

Atrulion
Автор

Ron didn’t only suffer from a broken leg. He also suffered sever emotional trauma. Pomfrey was giving him time to work through it. She knows probably as well as Dumbledore what goes on in that school. Trust

zacharywheeler
Автор

It was simply more than just a broken bone. In the PoA (book), Sirius (Dog) badly mangles Ron's Leg and Prof Lupin simply conjures bandages with "Ferula". It is possible that Ron's injured Leg was a lot more Serious than it looked. Also, just bcoz madam Pomfrey says that she can heal broken bones in a second doesn't mean that she can actually do it that fast.

ruturajshiralkar
Автор

Madame Pomfrey probably got early vacation time because it’s rare or anything to be more than like a scrape or cut at the end of the year.

rebeccawilliams
Автор

Yeah they were all just teaming up on lockhart so she lied

No_name
Автор

Nahh, she just despises red-haired rats.

JubulusPrime
Автор

I just love the bit where dumbledore goes over and hits Ron's leg XD

Ar_Tank
Автор

I turned it from 3.1K likes to 3.2K likes, I feel chosen.

WalterTheMushroom
Автор

Madame Pomfrey believes that emotional Traumas take a lot of time to heal.

In the OOTP (book), during the OWL exam preparation, many students became overwhelmed and anxious as a result of a gruelling study schedule and therefore visited the Hospital Wing, where they all received a dose of Calming Draught. After receiving their respective doses, Madame Pomfrey had them rest in the Hospital Wing for some time before discharging them.

This is also evident in the Goblet of Fire (book). After the Care of Magical Creatures Class goes awry thanks to the Blast-ended Skewts, many students are rushed to the Hospital Wing for Burn-related injuries. After administering the required potions, Madame Pomfrey had the students rest in the Hospital Wing for some time before discharging them.

Also, in the Prisoner of Azkaban (book), when Harry suffers a nasty fall due to an encounter with a Dementor, he is admitted to the Hospital Wing wherein Madame Pomfrey makes him rest there for quite some time before discharging him.

ruturajshiralkar
Автор

It's a deep cut not a broken bone also she's told to leave for dumbledore so she might have had to leave before she could do anything
Ron also had lots of emotional trauma he needed to work through so she could have just been giving him time to heal mentally before physical healing it was also probably infected so like Cedric's burn took longer than a second in book/movie 4 it proba my was the infection aswell 😊

crochet_Christiana
Автор

Wasn’t that a figure of speech, she was just saying she can heal bones WAY faster than growing them

XxCJOxX
Автор

I'd say that was reverse plot armor!

karlhnedkovsky
Автор

She wasn’t lying, as in the first book when neville breaks his wrist, he says ‘madame pomfrey mended it in about a second’

tobysavory
Автор

I think she was told by dumbledor that Ron had been depressed by the loss of scabbers so she kept a Muggle cast on the leg so he gets time to cope with the tragedy

sushmakulkarni
Автор

But the thing is Ron's leg wasn't broken. It was bitten by Sirius while he was a dog, which meant that he probably had torn tendons or ligaments, and the cast is there to immobilize that's why he has a cast on. She's never mentioned how fast she can heal ligaments and tendons.

joshboris
Автор

Because it was more than a broken bone. Read the books not just the movie.

garrettrussell
Автор

dude stop basing this on the movie read the books they have more details also madame pomfrey is over protective and will keep ron in a cast till she see fit wich takes a while

yeatsmadgamer
Автор

It probably needs to be treated non magically due to infection seeing how Sirius could have accidentally broken the skin

matthewpeffer
Автор

Bro her healing potion might be finished

CrnkMaster