We Tried 9 Lofthouse Cookie Copycat Recipes | The Pancake Princess

Показать описание

In this bake off, I baked 9 different copycat Lofthouse cookie recipes and tasted them alongside the original Lofthouse cookie to find the most similar version!

The full breakdown, including the data analysis and my top picks, will be live on my blog. Thank you to our sponsor Imperial Sugar for providing the high-quality granulated and powdered sugar that went into this bake off!

Recipes (in order shown):
00:00 Intro to the Lofthouse Cookie Bake Off
1:25 Original Lofthouse: find these at most American grocery stores!
12:03: Wrap up!

In case you're new here, here's how a bake off works:
- I bake 9-12 different recipes in one day
- Samples of each recipe get distributed to a team of 20-40 tasters
- Tasters rank each sample for flavor, texture and overall appeal
- We analyze the data and rank each recipe according to the scores!

Рекомендации по теме

Комментарии

I watched almost all of your videos on the channel and I seriously DO NOT understand why it is so underrated!!!! Your content, editing and efforts deserve WAY MUCH MORE attention 😭😭😭 please please please keep them up!

charlene

I never knew I needed butter wrapper ASMR until now. Your on camera skills are great, personable without any of that over the top YouTube'y vibes!

omaryousef

I bet the original loft house gets the layers from the way the dough is "poured" and then extruded in the factory. I agree it is unique. Def an interesting bake! I personally love these cookies, i just dont eat them often haha which is totally ok.

jess

I just made the NYT ones! That frosting is really genius, and I like the cream cheese/butter for flavor in the cookies.

toswingonastar

I found you from Instagram! Your production quality is amazing, I love it! Can’t wait for more recipes!!!

mei

Great video! Love how these overviews can direct me to the best recipe for my tastes!

jess

Considering the imense effort that was obviously put into this video- it should have way more likes and recognition than it does

kolbie

Thank You for taking the Time and Energy to find us a copycat recipe that actually looks and tastelike one, there's a lot out there that claim to be a lofthouse copycat but, how do we really know...

michaelromero

Great video! I still can't decide which recipe to try though. Based on your comparison, what would be the closest recipe for the cookie and also for the frosting?

jessomega

I was very disappointed to get to the end after all that and not hear which one was your favorite and why ☹️

ehyzkot

I found you thru my youtube sugestions and Im hooked!
Your video is impeccable and I can truly see the ammount of effort that is put thru the baking and making of this
Congrats!

jimbolico

I made the NYT recipe for Christmas. Used freeze dried strawberries instead of raspberries and still really great. I think you can use any freeze dried fruit and it will be delicious. They were a hit with the family.

geenagallegos

instead of a traditional birthday cake every year I'd have these instead they're so good and very aesthetically pleasing

fatimahanwaar

Preppy Kitchen has a recipe as well. Looks pretty good too.

WickedWordzz

Hi Erika. I have made the Brown eyed baker recipe for years and love them. I never make the frosting, we eat them just like that. I hate crème au beurre and I think American buttercream is probably very similar. I made them this night and made the Serious eats ones too to compare them. The SE are much sweeter and not as pillowy and soft as the BEB. They are much easier to make (scooping fresh dough VS refrigerating and rolling out) but I didn't like them. In the family 3 out of 4 prefer the BEB but my husband, who loves sweet cookies, prefers the SE's. Sorry for him but I'll stick to the Brown eyed baker ones.

____Ann____