Mac vs Windows in 2024: The Ultimate Comparison

M1 Max Macbook Pro
A conclusive comparison of the biggest rivalry in computers (Mac vs Windows) and why I switched after a lifetime of dedication. Features, quirks, benefits, products, and more.

Follow me on social media! (it's always just @mikeobrienn)

Please comment below with any questions you might have. Thank you all for watching! I appreciate you!

TIMESTAMPS:
0:00 The war between Windows and Mac
0:55 Windows is slipping
1:18 The Hardware
4:25 User Experience
8:25 Stability
8:55 Gestures
9:30 Software & Compatibility
10:20 The Ecosystem
12:40 Longevity & Security

Disclaimer: This video is purely based on my experiences, research, and opinions. You and only you are responsible for your actions. I made this channel to advise viewers and I truly hope to help you all out. I love making these videos and connecting with my viewers!
One or more of the products shown in this video may have been sent to me at no cost. This does not influence my opinions; I always cover both pros and cons.
This channel is monetized via YouTube ads as well as some affiliate links. If a purchase is made after clicking the link, I will receive a small commission at no extra charge to the buyer. Thank you all for watching!

[yomurita]

I use both. I don't mind using both. I bought a M1 Air for university and it's been a blast, while boasting a PC with good specs at home to program and game. Both do the job I bought em for, both work fine. The OS has never been a contention point for me.

[RayQiaoTW]

For quick split-screen multitasking:

Open your apps in full screen. When you swipe up with four fingers on the trackpad, your apps will appear at the top. You can drag one into the other and it gives you a split screen view

[BreakerBro]

For me it's definitely Windows because of the choice between different brands and the better interoperability between devices from differents brands (e. g. Android Phones)

[SAMSONICSCOMP]

I have been a windows user since 2004, when I was in university. I once tried macs, but I could not Get used to it and I switched back. I think it depends on what you are familiar with and what suits your needs. Windows offers many choices and customization options, which I like. Macs have a more closed ecosystem, which is one of the reasons I don't use them. For example, windows allow me to use different hardware and software combinations, while macs are more restricted and expensive.

[FAXIII]

I have used windows since ever but last week My cousin was traveling and he left his M1 MacBook air with me, this machine is incredible. the weight, the battery, the speed, it's just unbelievable

[pba]

I prefer Windows because every time I use macOS it feels like you're being forced to buy more Apple products to use it properly. Apple also actively blocks workarounds that create synergies between the Mac and a non-Apple product.

[jonesnyirenda]

i've been using windows for almost my whole life. i don't remember the last time i had a blue screen of death. Those things used to be an issue back then. In the last decade or so i don't expect a lot of people experiencing that unless you're running unsupported software on your machine. And the reason you see a lot of those on youtube is become there are a lot of people using PCs world wide compared to MACs hence the result.

[srsgonu]

Moved to windows recently (for work) after long time being mac user and am very happy with the move. Windows 11 in particular is very snappy and windows power tools makes it more powerful and productive. Being an Office 365 user, windows plays very nice and Android (Samsung Z Fold 3) integration is its finest. I have another laptop for the geek in me and it is running Linux (Mint). 🙂 Old hardware but Linux don't care. 😉

[IndefiniteGrain]

The user experience changes a lot when using Microsoft PowerToys on Windows 10 and 11, adding much of the same handy features that macOS has like spotlight (cmd+spacebar) and quick view. Working on both a MacBook Pro 16", a HP/Windows 13" laptop and Windows gaming PC I don't have to switch between getting used to the CMD and CTRL keys because of the many keyboards that support both and have a physical switch on them to switch between macOS, Windows or even Linux keyboard layout.

[beats]

Thank you very much for this clear analysis and for leaving out background music. I switched from PC to Mac a few years ago, mainly for the superior hardware. In the end I could no longer tolerate the fans of my Lenovo laptop constantly running. Never heard the fans on my MacBook Pro and no regrets on all other aspects.

[mol-lyn]

Smart advertisation while inducing fight between Windows and mac users

[MacTX]

If you're a gamer, there's really no choice, you're running Windows. A Windows PC is either your only computer or in addition to your Mac. Gaming on Mac has always been limited and continues to be.

[irmaslager]

This is the video I've been searching for! Mike defined the true user experience which is way better than many comparison videos

[MartinKrogh]

My work PC died and I wanted to try a Mac. Had it for 3 month and hated it. Had so many issues. Bluetooth wasn't working, many programs wasn't working right.... Came back to Windows and everything is good again!

[jzetterman]

I use Windows and recently Linux on my desktop and I have a Macbook Pro laptop. The one major thing that really kills me with the Mac is multi-window of a single application. With Windows, I can just hover over the icon in the taskbar and choose the window I want to bring up. On the Mac, I have to either Cmd+Tab through all of my open apps or open one window of the app, go up to the window menu, and choose the one I'm looking for from a text list, which is definitely not ideal. I do like both experiences overall though.

[lincolnliking]

I currently own two Macs, including a 14 inch M1 Macbook Pro. I prefer Windows and it's not even close.

[davidommanney]

I am still running a mid-2011 iMac. I have upgraded to a 1TB SSD and 32 GB of RAM. Sure, it's definitely getting a bit long in the tooth, but I can still run Word, Excel, PhotoShop just fine on it. Not too shabby for a 12-year old machine. My old iPhone 5 lasted 9 years (although I had to spend $20 on a new battery) before I had to upgrade for banking etc...

[dwaynestimpson]

I was a windows user, swore by it and refused to even think about a Mac.
In 2011 I needed a PC with macOS for work, and refusing to spend any money on a Mac I went down the Hackintosh path. It was....interesting...but so time consuming and constantly working on it. So...I figured if I am going to use a Mac, Im getting one I can play with and upgrade, in came the 2010 5, 1 Mac Pro....been on macOS since.

[aldo]

Something I really like with the trackpads on Windows - at least Surface trackpads (as far as I know) is that they are COMPLETELY customisable. On Mac you certainly have some control, but on Windows, you can make any three or four-finger gesture on a trackpad do ANYTHING - including ANY custom keyboard shortcut. I personally use ones below:

Three fingers:
- Tap: ALT + TAB (quickly switch between the last two apps)
- Swipe up: Windows + S (Search)
- Swipe down: Windows key (instant Windows menu shortcut - faster than pressing the windows key on a keyboard)
- Swipe left: Win + A: (opens Action Centre)
- Swipe right: "Switch apps" (shows and lets you swipe through all open windows)

Four fingers:
- Tap: ALT + F4 (closes apps)
- Swipe up: Win + E (opens File Explorer)
- Swipe down: "Backward navigation" (goes back in FE, web browser, many apps...)
- Swipe left: "Minimise a window"
- Swipe right: "Maximise a window"

I find these shortcuts SUPER helpful!

[JohnXionidis]

I'm loving these kind of alternative video subjects!