2024 BMW X5 VS Porsche Cayenne VS Range Rover Sport || Which Luxury SUV Is Best?

2024 BMW X5 VS Porsche Cayenne VS Range Rover Sport Review. We review and test drive the 2024 BMW X5, 2024 Porsche Cayenne, and 2024 Range Rover Sport to find out which is the best luxury SUV to buy. We also compare the plug in hybrid versions, 2024 BMW X5 xDrive50e, Porsche Cayenne E-Hybrid, and Range Rover Sport P440e. If you are buying a luxury SUV, make sure to watch this comparison review.

SUBSCRIBE TO CHANNEL:

TikTok: @shariprymak

My Favorite Undercoating / Rust Protection:

ABOUT ME

With over a decade of experience as a professional car buyer and auto consultant, Shari Prymak has helped thousands of consumers with their car buying needs. Car Help Corner provides honest, objective, consumer advice with all aspects of car buying and car ownership. For more professional advice, check out Car Help Canada, become a member, and subscribe!

[pepito]

For me X5 I had three of them great excellent, no issues super powerful car.

[petermacgregor]

I sold my Range Rover Sport SDV8 and purchased a Porsche Cayenne GTS Coupe 2023. I opted for the 18 Way seats so the comfort level is on a par with the Rangie. I've had the Cayenne since the beginning of March this year and so far haven't had to take it back to the dealer. The Range Rover was back 3 times in the first 6 months of ownership.

[kentwang]

I have a 2016 Cayenne for for 6 years it is excellent SUV no any issues or problems and now waiting for my 2024 Cayenne Hybrid

[roberttalkachov]

I own a Range Rover sport it is more luxurious and comfortable with beautiful high class interior features .

[thamarmontanez]

Best review I’ve seen so far. I had a Mercedes ML350 and it worked great. After that I tried Land Rover, Jaguar and Maserati. I ended with the Maserati. But after few years and spending so much money in gas I ended up with the X5 50e.

[paulk.]

Excellent review! I personally went with the 2024 Cayenne...and the BMW was the other potential option...but the Porsche was clearly better suited for our driving needs.

[marchhares]

I've got an X5 with the comfort seats and it is incredibly comfortable, I did try the Porsche Cayenne and the Range Rover, but they were not as good as the X5. But the Porsche and the Range Rover are very nice cars. As always its down to preference. Thanks for the great review.

[ronydagher]

I have owned all three SUVs over the last 5 years or saw
The most reliable has been the Range Rover sport with porsche Cayenne gts next and the BMW x5 last
It is about time for the Range Rover to shake off the bad reputation for reliability

[RC-bxjo]

thanks for the review, i can say after having had 3 BMW for about 12 years total, i have had one issue, on the older one: a cam shaft sensor fixed for 100$. anything in the past 10 years, nothing.

[barrybirchmore]

I have just changed my BMW45e for a new X Drive 50e in the UK I am regally getting 58-62 miles on a full charge. I don't know if the spec in the USA is different to be only getting 40 miles on a full charge !!

[pgpogo]

Have a 2023 x5 and never regretted it for a minute

[nguyentai]

Your range for Cayenne EHybrid is incorrect.

[trevorconway]

I’m on my 5th Range Rover in 15 years and I’ve never had a fault, that’s why I buy them

[leobrown]

Test drove all these last week .and the porsche is just better. The bmw is ok, but looks are mmm the range rover was nice, but i would worry every time i took it on a trip .so i ordered the cayenne with every extra cant wait

[jonbiasetti]

Great, practical and informative review, as always. I always buy Cayennes, after having driven the BMW and Land Rover options. BMW looks pedestrian to me and I am not a fan of their design. Range Rover Sport is a nice vehicle but I already own a full size Range Rover so do not want two cars from the same family. By the way, I have had three Range Rovers, no major problems, frankly, maybe I got lucky. Nothing steers and handles like a Porsche, so, if you like, as you said, to drive, Cayenne is it, if you want to cruise, the other two are fine options.

[amirveyseh]

Great informative, honest and consices reviews! Super helpful!

[mayormsuthu]

The BMW X5 is the best choice of the three no debate about it 🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉🎉❤

[DumbDogIsDumb]

Great video. I love that you give an honest assessment, warts and all. Too many reviewers sugar coat problems and it’s not doing consumers a favor.

Just got the X5 and love it. The Porsche was very nice too, but the BMW was a little more comfortable with the merino leather and the excellent 20 way multi-contour seats.

I have no Illusions about cost of ownership or resale. Got the full extended maintenance plan and platinum warranty for as long as they sell them because I don’t want hassles. Any maintenance or problems, it gets dropped off at the dealer and they can deal with it.

As far as resale, it’s paid for so no worries about being upside down and all cars are highly depreciating assets, so I consider them lost money. Anything I might get for trading it in 7 to ten years from now will just be a nice surprise.

None of these cars are sound financial decisions. They’re super comfortable, performant, safe and enjoyable. Sometimes that’s worth more than money.
If cost of ownership was a concern, I’d drive a Honda or Toyota.

[tpmdvideo]

Tried all 3. Went with the x5. Love the performance and design with one major exception the split tailgate. I run and cycle. Immediately after a workout I rest sitting in the cargo area. The salesperson could not tell me how much weight lowered gate could support. He researched and reported 500 lbs. I have my doubts about that. Another issue with the gate….When placing something in the cargo area, you must lift higher over the lower tailgate like it’s a pickup truck. BMW ……. Forget the split tailgate.
My last complaint is for $72, 000 you don’t get real leather but a interior synthetic material. 😢

[RC-bxjo]

i also have a 911 and despite being a porsche customer, I would get the X5: i love the 911 for the driving feel, but the infotainment and dashboard layout is...funky at best (map hidden behind the wheel, really porsche?). Not to mention rattling. I'd go X5 because it's the most obvious, easy to use interface, and because frankly nothing justifies the extra price on the cayenne. I'd rather have a BMW straight 6, a legendary engine, than an audi V6 that one can get on an A4. regarding reliability, no one should buy a car like that off warranty IMO. Lease them, buy them out, sell immediatly, lease an other. Or extend the warranty.