Teen Mom Missing– 14 Years Later Her Sister Gets DM “She’s Alive” | The Case of Sherry Leighty

"I promised dad I will find her"

13 years after her little sister disappeared, online detective Shelly Nagle receives a notification from an anymous Facebook account, with a disturbing message reading “she’s still alive, but you’ll never see her again”. When the police refuse to investigate, Shelly knows it’s up to her to find her sister and the man responsible for her disappearance: a killer who is now watching her every move.

Thanks to Riyandi Kusuma for the music in the opening: "Happy Birthday Piano - Horror Version (2019)"
-
-
-
Follow us on social media:
Uncover what true crime documentaries don’t show you: real cases and real people, but with a new twist. This is Unseen.
-
-
-
********************
BACKGROUND MUSIC by Fearless Motivation Instrumentals:

Content ID: Identifyy
MusicBed: MB01RPUZ9DCT3OH
PRO BMI ASSET ID: # 1113983

[unseentruecrime]

Thank you for listening to Shelly & Sherry's story ❤

[shellymarie]

Thank you for keeping my sister's story alive and by helping to get more signatures on our petition since I'll be meeting again with the parole board this December, to continue the fight to keep this monster in prison!!

[twilight]

Once again, the police completely failed a murder victim. The fact that they never bothered to investigate Ryan, the person she supposedly ran off with, is just insane. That should've been the first step in verifying that she left of her own free will. Not to mention the fact that Sherry had an established history of constant contact with her sister and the rest of her family, and she suddenly drops off the face of the earth and never speaks to them again, and her husband and father-in-law show up saying strange things at her family gathering. Just...a million red flags. And they didn't even confirm her husband's alibi of being at work! That was the BARE MINIMUM of investigation. Just infuriating. That entire police department can rot in hell for this.

[rogueredshirt]

The officials in this case are corrupt. The fact that they can show their faces in interviews despite their shameful behavior is astounding.

[jadonnagle]

This is my family. My mom was a warrior in finding the truth. And I’m glad that we finally got some sort of closure, although we continue to mourn my aunts absence. I appreciate the comments of support towards the failed police department. I can only hope that with more awareness we can work to change how the police investigate missing persons. No family should have to endure the unknown as we did for so long.

[seldomseen_outdoors]

This is my moms story. I love and miss her so much. I just learned about this episode from a comment on facebook on here so i came over to watch it. 😭💔 Thank you so much for putting this episode out here for people to see.

[rejay]

How DARE that detective come on this interview and act as though he's in the right. He should be FIRED for how he handled this.

[TheGamingAnimator.]

It sickens me how Shelly’s kids grandfather can just take her kids camping right next to her own body and the grandfather just, doesn’t feel any guilt, hell the kids could’ve been running over where he buried her and they wouldn’t know

[truthhurts]

All the cops had to do was ask Kennths employers about his work schedule and that would have started it all. Took what, 12 years? Completely ridiculous. 🤬

[Sherrilynn]

12 years and the family are the ones who brought the perpetrator in and then the 'authorities ' only put in 5 days? This is disgusting beyond words.
Much love and healing to this family ❤

[donnaroberts]

If this girl had been daughter or sister of a police officer I wonder how different this investigation would have been handled. RIP Sherry & much love to all her family who never gave up cos you are the true heroes here. Hugs from Australia XXX

[Areniapixie]

I’m sorry but it’s absolutely disgusting when they go ahead and offer a deal without consulting the family of the victim. That should NEVER be an option 🤬

[caitolent]

So you're telling me that a man who attempted to sexually assault his own wife's sister has been taking his grandchildren "camping" in the woods? He needs to be investigated for more than murder. I'm so glad that she never gave up.

[Mr.Tea_]

I can’t believe the DA and Sgt. can so easily show their faces with all their evil negligence, inaction and purposeful miscarriage of justice for a man that took TWO beautiful lives from the world. If there’s two lessons to be taken from this it’s the sanctity of family/foster your familial relationships with love and respect AND to remember all the faces of those given power who rather chose not to use it and allow evil fester so that they can at the least be reminded of their injustice.

[jdsguam]

The DA should have already resigned or been fired for incompetence.

[normawingo]

I can’t even fathom, in my worst nightmare, the utter incompetence and refusal of this criminally negligent police department. I hope you sued them for millions of dollars, especially on behalf of her children! What an incredible sister you are.

[chrisgomez]

That DA is a dbag. He's acting like he's a freaking hero in this tragedy. No, you make a deal with a monster and don't bother to talk with the family of the victim YOU have been failing for years??? Infuriating!! That POS should NEVER leave a prison cell and hopefully there's a seat in hell reserved for the waste.

[ashlipope]

My nephew was missing for over a year in the Denver Co area. The police refused to help and even trashed his vehicle and belongings when they were found in a ravine in the mountains. Finally someone on FB came forward 2 months ago. He had been murdered by his best friend and buried in concrete in their crawl space. The let the girlfriend off for her testimony and he's in jail on a million dollars bond. Although it wasn't as long.. I feel her sisters pain and pray for healing .

[anonymouse]

The audacity of the DA and the police to act like they did anything right in this case is maddening, but the deal the DA made without even consulting the family is beyond cruel. It's so wrong to make a deal like that, forcing Shelly to relive her trauma every single year just to keep her sisters killer where he belongs... how do those idiots sleep at night?

[Yub]

Those cops were horribly negligent! They didn’t even confirm his alibi until so many years later! Someone needs to lose their pension over this disgraceful investigation (or lack of)!