We Were WRONG About Old Man Consequences! | FNAF Theory

This idea made SO MUCH SENSE when I first read it in the email submission form. And the more I looked into it, the more evidence I uncovered. Five Nights at Freddy's is kinda like that though, the more you dig the more you find. So maybe I've just fully gone crazy, or MAYBE, this was a banger FNAF theory
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Wanna get me something?
Thumbnail art and HW2 Protag Art by BarBADroid
Here are all my socials and ways to support the channel!
Join our growing community on discord!
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Timestamps:
00:00 Preheating the Oven
00:45 What do we know about Old Man Consequences?
04:07 Is the Old Man from Princess Quest OMC?
10:08 Is Henry Old Man Consequences?
10:56 What if Michael is Old Man Consequences?
12:10 What is the sprite of OMC supposed to be?
13:54 Where is the lake of Old Man Consequences?
16:07 Who enters and exits the OMC lake?
16:30 Additional Evidence for Old Man Consequences
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
The style of this video is similar to Fuhnaff, Pastra, FusionZGamer, and uhyeah. A large influence on this channel has been Wendigoon, Game Theory, Markiplier, and Dawko.
-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
#fnaf #fivenightsatfreddys #fnafsecuritybreach

[Zammypig]

Another connection between Mike and OMC (more specifically lakes) might be the Fazbear Frights story Step Closer. A jerk older brother who is associated with Foxy goes fishing at a lake with his dad. He also almost loses his eye to a fishing hook as a “consequence” for bullying his brother and disturbing Foxy. Some more potential evidence!

[StrawHatZethy]

So old man consequences isn't a Crocodile but Mike as Foxy wearing a fishing hat. Epic.

[CodeOmega]

"You are won." is DEFINITELY a double entendre for 'You are one' before saying 'and YOU remain'. It feels like if the Princess is actually Golden Freddy, OMC might be saying how only one spirit remains in that body. (After the fire or Happiest Day? My mental timeline is borked.)

[morphstarchangeling]

One thing I always believed with Old Man Consequences is that entering the lake is basically moving on. He says you can't go back once you go too deep because there's no back, you can choose to stay and rest forever or you can move on to the next world which is the afterlife. In FNAF world the drowned ending ends the game properly because you can move on while it crashes the game in ultimate custom night because the vengeful spirit refuses to move on from Afton.

[oakthespringwing]

I’ve been headcanoning that Mike was OMC for about 3 years now. I never really expected for there to be actual evidence for it. What a crazy coincidence fyxfjtddghjvddgh

[valdenay]

Interestingly enough, that would make the Foxy vs Freddy anime clips in UCN make sense as well.

Vengeful child & Mike fighting over what to do with William

Edit/ 1k? Holy cow! That's cool

[zacks.]

The "Mike Consequences" pun is interesting, because I believe I discovered a similar instance. (I don't know if this has been brought somewhere else.) We have all thought that Emily is a weird last name, but I believe it is for a pun. Charlotte Emily, goes by Charlie in the books. Charlie can be short for Charlotte or Charles. Another nickname for Charles is Chuck.
Charlie Emily -> Chuck E. ... Cheese.

Edit: Just realized, the 3 Emily family members are Charlotte Emily (C. E.), Sammy Emily, (S. E.), and Henry Emily (H. E.). Their initials have the letters to spell C. H. E. E. S. E.

[diverwerk]

a purple mike fishing would be very fun to see. he’s just hollow with purple skin and he’s like “woah look at that biggen”

[vamprascare]

I like the idea that is Mike in the Old Man Consequences. It would make sense because everyone can hear William Afton in the Minigame screaming for Mike to help him, giving us that hint in UCN, the whole time. And the story about Mike from the Fazbear's Fright trilogy talking a boy going fishing, chewing gum, has a little brother that is told to stay away from Foxy and other Animatronics.

[wakaitsu]

Also name would make sense in that regard too. Old Man Consequences. Like, consequences of what? Player going too deep into the code? And this character that was clearly not born from the program, just decided to stay in the area nosy players end up in to poke fun of them? Yeah, sure.
But in Old Mike case that "consequences" part makes perfect sense - him being there is the consequence of his actions as a kid bully. His entire existence is the direct consequence of his actions. Therefore it makes sense to call his older self that - "I am an Old Man made by Consequences of my younger self actions"

[enrike]

He really likes the brush 😊 from the beginning

[deltarosa]

Not to mention the mushroom cave lake appears RED, similar to how the lake is coloured in FW/UCN

[HawkstaBeard]

I kinda just think that Old Man Consequences… is just Old Man Consequences. If Nighmare/Nightmarionne is the giver of death, and the Puppet is the giver of life, then I think that Old Man Consequences is the “Giver” of Purgatory.

[inventivefrog]

Mike could also be wearing the foxy mask since he knows that the spirits associate his face with William.

[PureHydro]

I thought this was a good episode!! It made me think of those pictures Mike drew in the survival logbook. Where he wants a speed boat and water skis. Also it's funny if OMC is Mike, because OMC also means original main character. Mike used to be main character

[happyfellowship]

Mike as OMC make so much sense, it's the perfect end to his character arc: from an angry teen whose rash actions led to tragedy and pain, to a judge-like figure who warns others not to continue in violence.
Also Michael enjoying binging TV and fishing is so funny, he's such a dad.

[MrWahoo]

Everybody focusing on the Theory's but not a Soul has Brought up how happy lil bro is while being Brushed every Upload, he must be a Joy to be around

[TheAmethystWitchGames]

If we assume jrs is where the sink hole that became the FNAF6 location is.. then the Mega Pizzaplex would be built on top.. being that it's the same location from midnight motorist we know that's a large open area of land next to what seems to be a busy major highway so that would make sense to build the Pizza Plex there.

[Syrup_Squid]

I can stop laughing at his seriousness while he brushes his cat who can’t get enough attention 😭

[robinblack]

HOLY I AM SO HONORED !

Loved the Mikes face overlay *chefs kiss

You did a great job! You the first fnaf creator to have me doing double takes on the series multiple red lakes