How do Hasidic Jews earn a living? | Your questions answered here

This is an overview of how hasidic Jews, who often reject college and most secular education in childhood, earn a living. Join me for a bit of an overview of a very unique economy in the heart of New York City.

*Short bits of videos quoted from:*
Lipa Schmeltzer’s channel: Lipa Schmeltzer - YouTube
Beri Weber’s channel: Beri Weber - YouTube
Videos from Shiezoli:

Thanks for watching. Please subscribe and share to help me continue to produce videos.

Thanks to Steve Milligan @shootitsteve for editing.

[MindlessZombie]

You only briefly mention the fact the Hasidic economy in Williamsburg would not be viable without a massive infusion of public money. They receive a large percentage of Section 8 vouchers for Brooklyn, and are accommodated by Hasidic landlords (frequently through under-the-table surcharges). More than 50% of the population in this community receives some sort of public assistance, including Medicaid, SNAP, etc - but none of that money is returned to the people who pay the taxes to fund it, because the spending is kept inside.

[andreaf]

I’ve never heard such a clear explanation of the community’s economy. You answered many of my questions and clarified the misinformation I’ve read through the years. Yes, I’m still working my way through your content. 😊

[Bear_Arms]

Lets not forget about the many less observant Jews that help fund many of the major institutions inside Haredi communities. My family, while pretty secular, regularly donates to a local Yeshiva and Kollel. Judaism teaches that people who help fund the study of Torah get a share in the merit of that study. Shana Tova to all, may you all have a happy and healthy year!

[BrianBeauchamp]

I’m an ER physician in Chicago and I have 2 Hasidic colleagues in my group (MD’s). Excellent docs!

[maureenlarsson]

Frieda, Thank you. I have learned so much about Jewish orthodox life. Please keep them coming. God Bless, Maureen from Florida originally from Brooklyn

[agoldberger]

Wow! This was such an informative and measured assessment of a very complicated and somewhat sensitive topic. Thank you Frida!

[Sams]

Another point that I think was missed here is they’re never really distracted by modern day technology till it’s absolutely necessary and I think that plays a huge role.

[anonymousanonymous-qxmv]

Freeda, I know you left the community and as much as it hurts...I still wanna commend you on a fair view of our life. You dont mix your personal animus, if any...with the truth and for that I tip my hat to you. I watched your interview with Peri Engelman, a relative of mine and it gave me great joy to see how respectful you were and how fair and unbiased you were and simply asked the relevant questions in a neutral way to educate the public. Thank you for your fair unbiased portrayal of your people, in spite of your personal choices to live life apart from it. Blessings for a sweet year and enlightenment to the truth of Torah and mitzvos! G' mar Chasima Tova.

[sparker]

I'm glad you mentioned State Aid. I worked several years with NYC's social services division, and became aware of many Hasidic families receiving SNAP benefits (more commonly known as food stamps). I've always been curious about the Hasidic culture, and am enjoying these videos.

[stevecraig-ugec]

Ms. Vizel, im very impressed with your unbiased coverage of the that special community. I know many hassidims and they are wonderful and hard working people. I don't know why you left the community, but you are beautiful in that you still recognize how special they are - unlikesome who've defected in a bitter way. You have special roots, and i hope you are at peace.

[yoelhalb]

Very well put.

A few additions though:
1) The Kosher food industry also reaches way beyond the Hasidic community, not just to more mainstream Jews but also there are non jews that prefer Kosher food for safety reasons.

2) Unlike in the secular world where rich people move away into rich gated communities, and spend their money on yachts and expensive cars or rolex watches, Hasidic rich people stay in the community and rather spend their money to help their brethren

[MsDanceDiva]

My family owned businesses in Williamburg and the Hasidic community is very close to our own. Although we are not Jewish, a lot of the food and influence extends beyond the inside community. Thank you for this video. It was very eye opening.

[mp]

Amazing video! Glad to see someone cover Hasidism without bashing them. Keep it up!

[juliachildress]

Thank you, Frieda. I'm new to your channel but in just a few videos I have learned a lot. I am not Jewish and I have family members who live in Boro Park. Whenever we visit, I like to stay for several days and observe the rhythm and activities of the different days. The children playing, husbands and wives walking together with their little ones, the quiet of the Sabbath, the noise and activity of Sunday, when everyone seems to be out and about and some of the shops overflow onto the sidewalk. I always feel welcome and sometimes get to talk with some of the moms about their day. I hope to take your tour one day.

[samsprague]

I was sent to a kindergarten that was at a Jewish temple for practical reasons. I really felt the sense of community and cohesiveness, it was very enjoyable to be part of it for that one school year. Afterward, when I attended public school I slowly realized that compared to the previous environment public school sucked.

[RBDawg]

Can you speak specifically regarding the perception that Hasidic are disproportionally using public services?

[deborah]

Awesome video, Frieda. You do a great service to the Hasidic community, and to the Jewish community at large. So glad to see the segment on B&H, which is the best place to buy a camera in New York. They really know their merchandise and are extremely helpful.

[yoinhemotzhe]

Frieda, we are so thankful to Hashem for creating you so talented and so intelligent with kindness to it, as nobody has so far spread this word about the Hasidic Jewish community in-house business trading in such a genuine and authentic way with such a positive vision about them,
On a side note, I strongly believe that now after your video came out, a lot of Hasidic Jews who have not made it yet to the top of the ladder will now get inspired by you and roll up their sleeves and try to climb up the success ladder, 📈📈📊📊

[richardarrow]

My heart goes out to all the secular teachers in Williamsburg. I tried it. Difficult, but rewarding. Great job reporting on Williamsburg. The best part of America!

[ChristianPhilosemite]

Wonderful. I love the emphasis on community and putting the priority on your fellows instead of branching away to get a cheaper deal or cut corners.