2024 Consumer Reports Top-10 for 2024 // Do you agree with this list?

This is a Motormouth couple car video showcasing Consumer Reports top-10 most reliable cars for 2024.

They include the Subaru Crosstrek with an overall score of 87/100. It gets a predicted reliability score of 99/100. That high predicted score is based on data from the 2024 model.
Toyota Prius and Prius Prime with an overall score of 80/100 for the Prius and 76/100 for the Prime. Prius gets a predicted reliability score of 84/100 and the Prime 62/100 which is based on data from 2021, 2022 and 2023 models.
Consumer Reports says, it’s always had a soft spot for the Prius. Over the past two decades it has offered practical transportation and impressive fuel economy. The Prius is now sportier offering more power and the addition of AWD. Consumer Reports feels it’s cooler looking and more engaging to drive than the outgoing model but the current model is much more difficult to see out of. Having two powertrain choices doubles its appeal.
Subaru Forester with an overall score of 88/100 and a predicted reliability score of 82/100.
It’s the last year before a redesign and it has made 11 appearances as a top pick with Consumer Reports. Consumer Reports says the winning formula includes a boxy design that maximizes interior space with great visibility. The vehicle has large doors making it easy to get in and out of the vehicle but also to load things in and out.
Mazda3 with an overall score of 78/100 and a predicted reliability score of 72/100.
Consumer Reports says the Mazda3 has always stood out as a sportier choice than compact rivals from Honda, Nissan and Toyota. Consumer Reports says it has an elegant and quiet interior with a refined ride.
Toyota Camry Hybrid with an overall score of 93/100 and a predicted reliability score of 87/100.
Consumer Reports says among mid-sized sedans, the Camry is distinguished by good fuel economy, a comfortable ride, intuitive controls and standard advanced safety systems.
Ford Maverick and Maverick Hybrid with an overall score of 78/100 for the gas model and 77/100 for the hybrid. Predicted reliability score for the gas model is 71/100 and the hybrid 60/100 which is based on data from 2022 and 2023 models.
Consumer Reports says it occupies an increasingly popular niche, it’s a small truck that can be bought on a budget. It has a civilized ride, easy access and good fuel economy. Consumer Reports says the Maverick outscores every pickup in its class other than the larger and more expensive Honda Ridgeline.
Toyota RAV4 Prime with an overall score of 89/100 and a predicted reliability score of 84/100.
Consumer Reports says this plug-in hybrid offers plenty of power, a comfortable ride and excellent fuel economy benefits. Consumer Reports thinks it’s a good option for buyers who are looking towards an EV but don’t want to worry about recharging the battery when on a long road trip.
Toyota Highlander Hybrid with an overall score of 85/100 and a predicted reliability score of 75/100.
Consumer Reports says the Highlander is a comfortable midsized SUV with great fuel economy, a compliant ride, accommodating seats, thoughtful cabin conveniences, abundant active safety features and commendable predicted reliability.
BMW X5 and X5 PHEV with an overall score of 92/100 for the gas model and 88/100 for the plug-in hybrid. The gas model gets a predicted reliability score of 82/100 and the PHEV 53/100, it doesn’t fair as well but it gets an overall score of 98/100 on the road test so it really brought up the overall score.
Consumer Reports says traveling in the X5 is a luxury experience with a quiet cabin. It has leather and wood, finished with cushioned surfaces and comfortable seats. The balanced suspension provides a supple ride and composed handling that holds its own on curvy roads. Consumer Reports says the X5 sets a high standard with its turbo inline-six in the gas model or plug-in hybrid.
Model Y with an overall score of 72/100 and a predicted reliability score of 41/100 which is based on data from 2021, 2022 and 2023 models. It had a high road test score of 88/100 bringing up its overall score.
Consumer Report says the Model Y is essentially an SUV version of the Model 3 sharing key underpinnings, equipment and features.

0:00 Intro
1:00 Subaru Crosstrek
2:26 Toyota Prius
3:42 Subaru Forester
4:37 Mazda3
5:21 Toyota Camry
5:53 Ford Maverick
6:57 Toyota RAV4 Prime
7:57 Toyota Highlander Hybrid
8:39 BMW X5
10:16 Tesla Model Y

[PaulStephenson-lfdw]

For over 30 years I have not purchased a vehicle without it being on Consumer Reports recommended list. Does not have to be their top choice, but has to be on their recommended list. Their recommendations have been quite accurate.

[AndyCColeman]

Thanks for another great video. I really like the list by consumer reports. I have a 2023 Model Y. It has been really good albeit only 7 months of driving. I agree the suspension is very tight. My daughters 2013 Prius is still going strong. She still gets incredible gas mileage. Really happy the Prius was mentioned. Gas is low right now and has no place to go but up. So I was very happy to see so many hybrids on the list. While they aren't as good for the environment as my Model Y and my son's Model 3 - it is absolutely a step in the right direction. Our next vehicle will probably be hybrid. A very large SUV - like the TX with a hybrid engine. But that won't be until next year and hoping for increased hybrid choices. Thanks for continuing to do fantastic videos

[lancemontes]

Very informative. Questions, Coffee & Cars still one of the best!

[timphillips]

Lovely to see you again and with this analysis of the consumer report reliable score data list top 10! 🎉

[Jorge_Magallon]

Great video as always.

CRs lists don’t really change my buying habits. I do find them interesting though. I do really dig into to the data once I have already settled on a car to know what I am getting into.

[harrahphotoman]

We purchased a Forester Touring in March ‘21. It is a beautiful smaller SUV but is perfect for us. We have owned a number of new cars over the years but the fit and finish of the Forester was the best of any brand (mostly GM, VW models). Visibility is great, the design maximizes space, it fits my 6’4” frame very well and we love the saddle leather interior. I’m looking at upgrading my VW Jetta sedan (2014 model) with the Crosstrek. My daughter and granddaughter both own Crosstrek and have had great luck with them. I appreciate that Subaru isn’t into the trendy design fads that sacrifice functionality and comfort for the latest trendy styles.

[bbdarling]

Just upgraded to a 2019 Subaru Crosstrek from a 2009 PT Cruiser ( mostly trouble free). Had a pre sale inspection done by our mechanic and his opinion as well as reviews such as yours sold us on the vehicle. So far we are impressed with mpg. Still learning all gadgets. Thanks for reviews and a few laughs

[Daniel-xpor]

Thanks Guys !!, enjoying your report and wishing a happy Saturday to all the component as well, have a great day.

[JimAllder]

This went great with my Whataburger. Thanks, guys. 🥂

[blairbelch]

I've been reading Consumer Reports for decades, but sometimes, their recommendations seem out of touch with reality. For example, Toyota and Honda are the most reliable vehicles over time, and mechanics would agree with that. BMWs are great cars when they're new, but as they age and are no longer under warranty, they are very expensive to own. The same applies to Volkswagen and Audi. Consumer Reports also loves Tesla and gives them high road test ratings, but their build quality is far below what it should be for how much they cost. As for Subaru, they are great values, but they've cut some corners in recent years, and their turbo engines have long-term durability issues. I would take CRs recommendations with a grain of salt. If several sources, including this awesome channel, recommend a car, then I would feel more confident.

[thehesam]

Best Canadian team with their best informative videos

[spmk]

The best video reviews are from Motormouth! We have two PHEVs, a Porsche Panamera 4S e-hybrid and a ‘24 BMW X5 50e. Both are fabulous — agree completely with CR’s conclusion on the BMW. In the U.S., given the limited actual range of EVs, especially in cold weather, and the very inadequate charging infrastructure here for long trips, PHEVs are at present the best choice.

[blake]

Over the years, I have owned new Dodge, Toyota, VW, BMW, Audi, Jeep, Subaru, Mazda (probably forget a few in there somewhere) and I have NEVER been contacted for follow up by ANY of the manufacturers or any 3rd party ranking service. One of the things that always bothered me is you know after driving a car for 6 months or so you find little quirks about cars that could be addressed by manufacturers to make their cars or their driving experience a little better and again I've never been asked. Seems like companies are missing out on that information.

[quercus]

Have a 24 Crosstrek convenience with 2.0 liter it, the 2.0 is peppy never mind what they say, I’ve had an Outback, and a Forester premium
both with the 2.5 liter a little thirstier then 2.0, yes I like Subaru’s I’ve had three, this basic convenience is fun and practical, and cheap. Go for it, it has everything you need no frills and it has key ignition comes with eye a gem.

[SJ_P]

Good video, quick cuts, lots of info in a short time

[Subie-Driver]

It’s nice that you covered consumer reports most reliable. I always take a look at CR when purchasing bigger items…cars, snowblowers, appliances, etc. Not the final word but I do appreciate the predicted reliability ratings as well. I’d like to see auto journalists do some shows on some used cars looking at the long term reliability. Hint, hint. 😉

[icecastle]

I like the Subaru Cross trek myself! Might buy one this summer! I'm also looking at the new Chevy Trax as well!!!

[qupdfug]

Looks like the Forester for us! The long journey in researching and test driving has been arduous... your videos and reviews have helped enormously!🇨🇦

[Das_Germaican]

I didn’t buy my Forester or Crosstrek because of the looks. That being said, I’m glad I waited for the ‘24 Crosstrek as I like the subtle changes. They are both extremely reliable and the Subaru owners that I know love their vehicles.

[mindbuilder]

Nice video. Could you provide prices on these vehicles in the future? Thanks.