Paul Atreides 'Silence' Dune (1984) - Dune: Part Two (2024) SPOILER WARNING!

#timotheechalamet #dune #duneparttwo #paulatreides #kylemaclachlan

Who says "Silence" better? Dune (1984) - Dune: Part Two (2024)

Kyle MacLachlan or Timothée Chalamet?

This video may contain spoilers if anyone has not seen Dune: Part Two

Please like and subscribe and leave a comments down below!

[margarethmichelina]

Reverend Mother in 2024: *Visibly Shocked*

Reverend Mother in 1984: *Cat noises*

[simplyeason]

the 2024 one shook the entire cinema with its bass. i truly felt the power behind paul’s ‘silence’

[RafitoOoO]

Honestly I feel bad for the people who won't see this movie on the cinema. The amount of bass produced was out of this world, the TVs simply can't compare lol.

[jeebsy]

I LOVE how Jessica's eyebrow moves like a fraction of a millimeter but it conveys so much

[kaykayfn]

It's been two weeks since I saw Dune Part 2 in cinema and I still have that SILENCE in my head.

[monimejia]

The 1984 version sounded like a command that demostrated his superiority and the 2024 sounded with rage showing he will not tolerate anything else from the ones that pretend to control him. Both were great.

[elgavion]

2024 is really good but the line "I remember your Gom Jobber. Now you will remember mine." Is such a great line.

[theashman]

Every hair on my body stood up when he said “SILENCE!”, chiiils

[Josh-uhio]

That “silence” scene on IMAX was worth the price of admission. It was an experience that I’d pay again and again to see

[ALX_.]

1984: *Dad*
2024: *that one friend who had enough*

[SoapNugget]

Saw Dune 2 in theaters 3 times (Twice in IMAX and once in Dolby) and this scene just gives me goosebumps all over!

[RGNRK-rmeq]

Nothing like the cinema, that scene still gives me chills

[jessea]

The original version of this part is iconic, but the 2024 version is impactful. I do like the echo effect from the original, however. Without being in an auditorium with LOUD bass, I can tell how loud this must be because of the effect. With the new version, unless you have some nice surround sound with a lot of bass, it doesn't have the same effect watching it on another device different from the theater.

[sample.text.]

If you didn't see this in iMax or theaters, you have no idea how heavy that "SILENCE" was.

[ArchSpawn]

kinda wierd how she was able to speak after having the voice used on her to remain silent....

[milkwater]

I was waiting for that "I remember your Gom Jabbar" line in the theatre, but the scene was well made regardless.

[johnnybobonny]

2024 had a better silence. But that “try looking” line goes hard.

[IrisCorven]

I think everyone cracking jokes about the "lul cat noises" in the original misses something that makes that version more effective: it works in the 1984 version. In the 2024 version, he shouts and she recoils, then says "Abomination". In the 1984 version, those "cat noises"? Are frustrations of an angry Reverend Mother who can't make a verbal rebuttal, even when resisting.

As much as I loved both movies, and as much as I enjoyed getting the chance to see both in cinemas, the original still stands out to me. In the 2024 version, the "SILENCE" BOOMS in the theater, but still sounds like an angry child. And that effect is only worsened on a home rewatch. In the 1984 version, it feels ethereal and authoritative, still booms through the speakers, and features that reverb, but that same feeling is felt in a home rewatch even without the bass the cinema would provide.

So for me, the 1984 version still wins out. Not only for it's iconicness and its transition to home media, but due to the fact it actually *works* against the Reverend Mother.

[bastyman]

The 1984 one had some golden lines, they should have used more of them.

[Moviesrlife]

Dune (1984) Kyle MacLachlan 0:06

Dune: Part Two (2024) Timothée Chalamet 0:22