Interstellar SPOILER talk

Interstellar has divided moviegoers and Nolan fans alike. Love it, hate it, like it, get completely confused by it; there are a lot of spoilers to talk about. Jeremy gives you his thoughts, and further explanations on what he liked, and what he didn't like about the movie in his "Interstellar SPOILER talk"!

[Muddasir]

Who came here to find that “Maybe you don’t know as much as you think you know” comment??

[Rickyroo]

I must be thick as fuck, I honestly didn't think twice about the ghost bit at the start, just thought it was a kid being a kid

[sashabakhshi]

The reason those waves were so big was because of the intense gravity. The wave wasn't coming towards them, the planet was rotating into the wave

[liammccarthy]

Honestly I don't see how the ghost was "in your face foreshadowing", or "obvious".  Going into this movie knowing nothing about it, idk how anyone could just assume the ghost was Cooper...

[luizfcavalcanti]

+JeremyJahns, I like your reviews, but yes, you didn't understand half the things in this movie. Let's talk about them:

1 - Tidal waves in the first planet:
How much our moon influences our oceans? A LOT. Now think about a planet orbiting a black hole. That's it. Those waves were caused by massive gravitational distortions that comes from the black hole. Why they didn't predicted that? Time displacement.

2 - He only docks with the Endurance due to the robots aid in the control of the ship.

3 - What changed Dr. Brand POV was her "handshake" with Cooper, well, she thought it was the "aliens". Also this concept of love is subjective, we are talking about other existences, 5th dimension existence, those beings, human evolution or not, see time as ordinary element of space, as part of their existence, in fact for them time is not linear, there is no now or then, before or after.

4 - If the wormhole was closer to Earth it's gravitational pull would take the moon out of orbit or worse effects. So yes, close to Saturn that is a giant planet with gravity enough to live with the black hole close by.

5 - The Aliens were mankind it self in my opinion, that's why they can't interfere to much, time paradox, like prime directive from Star Trek.

6 - The funny things is, there is no romance in this movie, maybe, just maybe something between Cooper and Dr. Brand, but nothing on focus, and I found that amazing.

7 - The thing is, as Europe, the moon of Jupiter, we could have a cold planet with a underground area worm enough to sustain life. Remember, Dr. Man faked data about it to attract their attention.

8 - NASA never lost funding, they just kept it top secret, not only to hide the apocalyptical scenario, but because as Dr. Brand(the old dude) said, is hard to justify funding to space exploration when people is starving.

9 - Robots would have trouble improvising to situations, remember even TARS states that. This is explained many times through the movie, from their arrival on NASA, to the sling shot around the black hole.

10 - They sent one scientist with one robot to each planet on that system to assertain it's situation. The problem is, no data was ever sent properly back to earth, that's why they sent a full crew this time, and also comes with Plan B on board(population bomb).

I hope you see my post not because I want to point fingers in you or shit, I like your reviews, your attitude, but in this movie you didn't get many things... and... the greatest problem of this movie was the ambition to require people to know basics of Relativity Theory and Quantum Mechanics. The Quantum Mechanics part is were most people lost it.

[donesitackacom]

Everyone could predict the ghost would be Matthew? Gosh looks like i'm just fucking stupid but oh well, I enjoyed it

[SDSK]

Nice video but here are some....interesting things to take into consideration:
1) There is a video where Neil deGrasse Tyson talks about Interstellar and says that the planet that has the water on it did make sense because the entire planet was one huge wave. They were not like tidal waves or anything. So it is plausible. 
2) When you asked how how NASA got funding, in the movie they hint that the tax money is not going to colleges. It happens when Coop went to the school at the beginning of the movie. It was funded secretly.
3) The movie is very highly based on science. One of the producers was a physicist and there were several journals published about the science in the movie. You said how they say love is quantifiable but they also say that gravity can move across dimensions. That is why in the 5th distention he used gravity to communicate with Murph. They say love because that is some of the liberty that the movie takes. You cannot make a movie entirely around science or people will not get drawn into it as much. :) 

[misterhoobomaster]

Pretty sure his son was dead at the time when he came back. ... Since he was older than her.

[tesfayetastic]

so basically if you didn't guess that cooper was the "ghost" like me, then you'll really really enjoy movie which I think most people who watched it did

[josh.]

I didn't think that at all! The foreshadowing (in my opinion) was very clever.

[leoperez]

I feel like a dumbass saying this but, am I the only one who didn't know cooper was gonna be the ghost?

[erodict]

The water wasn't gonna be 3 feet deep if it weren't for the black hole, , the water is 3 feet deep because it all collected in the wave -o-

[carecrow]

I feel kinda stupid for saying this and I'll probably get a lot of flak for it....but I thought the "ghost" in Murphy's room was gonna be an Alien...like when she said it was trying to communicate. Yeah...

[jeydoubleyew]

I didn't find it obvious that Mcconaughey was the ghost. It actually surprised me. 

[extendedtrailermusic]

Okay, _how in the actual heck_ do you get "Dad, stop knocking over books and using gravity to manipulate sand falling from the fifth dimension" from "Dad, there's a ghost in my room" without having known _a lot_ about the film beforehand?

[alski]

people always criticize movies for not being perfect, but I have never seen a perfect movie.

[GalacticAstroparticles]

- NASA funding = The money they talk about in the school scene (taxes not going to colleges)
- Huge Waves = were great AND SCIENTIFIC as an object like a black hole with HUGE gravitational consequences would have caused them, as the Moon causes the tides on Earth
- Apart from the speech of sentimental Dr Brand in the middle part of the movie i didn't get how "Love" was so overblown in this movie that would be bothersome. Yes, that scene was kind of disturbing (as she was quite irrational), but 5 minutes later she is like "You were right, i hope you keep being objective!"

-The science used in this movie was done VERY well. Relativity, Black Holes and their effects, wormholes and even the visualization of gravity as a dimension (the strings Cooper manipulated to send the messages) is simply beautiful. Those were some bold moves, doubling with forces like these for a Director and i admire his courage (and that he pulled it off).
I can't help but compare this movie to Gravity, which was a visual treat, but all the plot holes and WRONG SCIENCE/LOGIC in that movie killed most of the tension/suspense for me. If Gravity had a science adviser, half that movie would be cut out. Interstellar had a great theoretical physicist as an adviser and their movie is stronger, better and more accurate...

[asdasdasdasd]

ok jeremy hold up dude. The ghost could have been an alien. For most of the movie they sell that idea. I never thought that the being that planned all of that could be humans, that is just you being you, but it could have been aliens easily and i thought that for most of the movie.

But most importantly, the ending. Murph very clearly says "no father should see their children die" and Coop agrees with that. He saw her one last time, and after all they went through, to me its like maturing and finally letting go. Its done, the mission is over and the sacrifices have been made. They cannot change that, and to see her die would be the last drop i believe. Its not a happy ending, its a terrible situation and they deal with it the best way they can, and that was very intense to me, that after all Coop went through, after all the hurt of knowing what was happening with her daughter, he still cant be with her, she is gone, lost in time. Its a sad ending, dude

[fernandapereira]

I thought the water was 3ft deep because of the size of the wave. Like when the water on the beach starts going back because of a tsunami...

[elnino]

TO THE PEOPLE COMPLAINING ABOUT THE WATER PLANET, ITS A TIDAL WAVE NEAR A BLACK HOLE. YOU EXPECT IT TO BE SMALL?