Scientific Errors In The Quran? | Hamza Tzortzis @HamzaTzortzisOfficial

In this video, Hamza Tzortzis delves into the fascinating discussion around the Quran’s verses about human creation—particularly the phrase 'between the backbone and the ribs.' Does this verse present a scientific error, or is it misunderstood due to linguistic and interpretative nuances? Join us as we explore the multi-layered meanings of these verses and how classical Arabic provide deeper insights. We address key questions around potential misconceptions about science and the Quran, illustrating why this ancient text remains relevant across time and cultures.

Presented with clarity and nuance, this video aims to shift the conversation from superficial scientific critiques toward a more profound exploration of the Quran's timeless message.

Full Video -
The Timeless Quran | Scientific Error Or Miracle? | @HamzaTzortzisOfficial

Article on between the backbone and the ribs -

[bumbaclaat]

As a graduate in biological sciences I find that none of these ‘refutations’ do nothing but to increase me in faith and gratitude. It’s true what brother Hamza said. When you reflect on these ayat with sincerity it is amazing how Allah settles your heart.

[jaihindcollegegraduationmu]

They don’t know the Arabic or the Science

[barawizza]

“The phrase ‘from between the backbone and ribs’ in Surah At-Tariq (86:7) beautifully reflects the origin and unique pathway of the testicles. The testes develop near the kidneys, precisely between the backbone and ribs, before descending. Remarkably, their blood supply and lymphatic drainage remain connected to this exact region, unlike any other part of the body. This unique connection—originating specifically from this area and descending—is a precise and profound insight into human creation, aligning perfectly with the verse.”

[odeebob]

I love you brothers for the sake of Allah

[mfvohra]

Between the back bones and ribs is a figurative speech it just means body!
For example in surah mumtehna it says gaurd what is between your hands and feet referring to private parts !

[sparephone]

Without not disrespecting Hamza, I do think Dr Maurice Bucaillle did explain this in his book forty years ago. 'sulb' clearly refers to the male sexual area, while 't'araib' refers to female anatomy, specifically the pelvic arch. The verse is clearly referring to the sexual union of a man and a woman, and once gain stresses the small quantity of sperm [nutafah] that is required for life to start.

[philosopherkyng]

The real question is would you let preachers of other religions do this amount of mental gymnastics to prove their scriptures??

[BrightStar-su]

Embryology : original site of development of the Gonads is in the upper abdomen on either side of the spine , then testis descends into scrotum , ( if undescended intraabdominal testis, then susceptible to neoplastic, malignant changes )

[salmansheikh]

Amazing. When the quran is wrong it means something else every time.

[zarazara]

👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇👇This is the correct answer: this verse talks about a very beautiful scientific miracle when it attributes the origin of the baby to its embryological life because both the tests and ovaries were created for the very first moment in the space between the lower ribs and back bones near the kidneys then they descend down to their known places (scrotum and above the uterus) that is why still they get their blood supply and nerve supply from the space between the lower ribs and back bones, that is why it’s as if the sperms and ovum are still creating from that space because still they are getting their blood supply from that space

[ismailfeham]

Great content. Not sure about the AI-generated Quran at 0:39, the letters seem completely off and distorted. I would recommend removing the image.

[bili]

The resume is : Allah made verses that are scientifically « universally true » with all the 3 meanings that are correct by the precise placement of words

[atefalsharif]

Allah (swt) might be subtly eluding to the embryologic location of the testicles, which originate between the ribs and the backbone. During embryonic development, the testicles are located in the lower belly, near the kidneys, on the posterior abdominal wall. During the last months of pregnancy, the testicles descend into the scrotum through the inguinal canal, a tubelike passage in the groin. They are suspended from the abdomen by the spermatic cord, which is made up of nerves, vessels, and ducts that supply the testes. All u have to do is follow those blood vessels and ducts that feed the testicles and they will lead u to the place of origin between the ribs and backbone.

[derdadermenzi]

❤❤❤❤❤
Dear Brothers,
I hope you see with this kind of Tafsir, that the ayats of theQuran actually has a 3 dimensional and multilayered Tafsir through the knowlegdes of Arabic, like Ishtiqaq, Balaghat, Bayan, Nahv, etc, and also Abjad numerals.

ALLAHU AKBAR !!!!❤❤❤

[yousufhashimi]

The point for me was that these people don't do the exegesis they do eisegesis

[chairmanrosethewisegentleman]

If you study more about embryology and the origin of gonads testes and ovary. You will know that the pairs of gonads coke from those area in beetween. Male baby have their testes in to the scrotum after few weeks of birth. In their early stage of development, that organs come from tissue of that area.

[UpdownMath-jodl]

You as you think about the Surah Night comer (86)
The Almighty Lord not talking about man
Alllah said
So let man observe what he was created
Isn't talking about man it's talking about observing about the subject on the topics of the Surah

[pappapappi]

I mean, if it is a topic for Arabic knowledgeable Experts, why don't you show similar constructions throughout the Q which would clarify the question of multi layer meanings and the usage of certain expressions in different nuances. That would really have been more helpful than mentioning previous Q commentators' opinions which mostly do not align with the level of science today.
As it is indeed a matter of Arabic semantics you can not get further around this course.

I mean no offense, but I don't find the eloquent fluently speaking scientist in such a matter.. you have to dig deep into different aspects of the statement.😊

[fazalrahman]

What Allah is telling us the baby comes out.
The third ayat refers to the human and not the sperms.

[doctorofpharmacologytoxico]

This guy doesn't know biology either. The verse points to the germ cells (sperms and ova) which in the developmental stage of an embryo are localised between backbone and chest. It later descends to testis or ovaries. I got this explanation from my late brother who had embryonic germ cell tumor in his chest. He was a doctor and a muslim. Overrelaince on hadiths have destroyed muslims.