The Crucifixion Dilemma That DESTROYS Islam

This video dives into why the Quran says Jesus wasn’t crucified, even though historical evidence suggests otherwise. It also looks at the idea in Islam that someone else took Jesus’ place on the cross and what that means for how reliable the Quran is compared to what the disciples said. Islam has a choice to make: either Jesus wasn’t a prophet like Muhammad said he was, or the Quran got this part wrong. Either way, Islam is wrong.

Join this channel to get access to perks:

[TestifyApologetics]

"But Testify, you can't just assume the New Testament is reliable. Muslims say it's corrupted!"

A.) I didn't just assume anything. I gave solid reasons to trust that Jesus really predicted his death and resurrection accurately.

B.) Guys, my channel is like one big, ongoing series. Every video builds on the last. I've got a ton of reasons why you can trust the text. Check out my playlists on undesigned coincidences and how history backs the Bible to get all the details.

EDIT: Here's my response to Farhan Ahmed Zia who clearly speeds past pinned comments

[youravantgarde]

Jesus would never ask someone to be killed in his place.

[pgpython]

Christians: Jesus died by crucification
Jews: he died by crucification but wasn't God
Romans: we crucified him under pontius pilate
Muslims over 600 years later: some overly elaborate conspiracy theory that makes no sense

[Theophoruz]

Islam is definitely the biggest "Trust me bro" in history when it comes to this

[Truck_Kun_Driver]

I'm an atheist. I don't believe in both religions, but if you looking at this event as a historical story, why would you trust some random dude in arab lands 600 years later when there are literally eye witnesses of said event?

[jarlbalgruuf]

I remember the bible warning to beware of false prophets

[darkwolf]

The denial of the historical crucifixion is one of the main reasons why I reject Islam. It's indefensible.

[Jojoseph]

proff jesus wasnt muslim: he drank wine-

[garrettobrien]

Islam makes no sense to me because hypothetically...

Someone is found murdered in the middle of the road, who would you as the detective ask to figure out what happened, the eye witnesses, or some guy 600 years in the future?

[galaxyn]

Why should anyone believe Allah when the Quran calls him "the best of deceivers" multiple times?

[portsidedyldo]

Notice how in the 10 commandments it says to not bear false witness? Which is an interesting way to say to not lie but the “Jesus was replaced on the cross” is the literal definition of false witnessing

[kaybee]

I love how Jesus ascended through a hole in the roof

[Anaken]

Well, the disciples all pretty much died in terrible, horrible ways, after years of persecution. Why would they go through all of that if they knew Jesus didn’t die on the cross?

[ajmartinez-hq]

Jesus wasn’t Christian or Muslim. He is the Christ that us as Christians worship as our savior.

[freekillgaming]

I'm about to convert to Islam and bruh, I'm so thankful that you made this video, I'll be returning to church now, this is my greatest doubt

[dzigayu]

Mohammed: "Jesus wasn't crucified"
Everyone: "Source?"
Mohammed: "It came to me in a dream"
Everyone: "Ok, I believe you"

[MrJonny]

This would mean Allah invented Christianity and didn’t fix his mistake until 600 years later

[davcaslop]

It’s always fascinating that people believe a document 500 years later of the act before a contemporary eyewitness account

[lelouch]

John-Jesus was crucified, I was there to see it.
Mohammed-Nah he wasn’t, trust me bro

[thethemperoroftheholybri]

Christians: "source, the men who followed Jesus"
Islam: "source, trust me bro"