Dr Khalil andani destroyed Jake the Muslim Metaphysician, Is allah God, God attributes, islam God

[Haqq]

You can’t be metaphysician and wahabi or anthropomorphist, I thought this guy was Sufi or ashari, turns out he’s some neosalafi, this is ridiculous, salafis don’t even believe in theology or metaphysics!

[justice-el]

Jake made it clear that we stick to Hadith irrespective of its metaphorical and literal interpretation.

[sherry-z]

Khalil Andani is an ismaili shia muslim. Still Islam is true. There are so many sects in islam. This debate is like sunni vs shia.
And the shia clearly won😊

[awalu]

Yes we can not know the kayfiya, Allah descent doesn't mean the a real descending like human descending, so Allah says (لا كمثله شيء و هو سميع بصير) So With this Dr Khalid did not prove anything because we can't use human terminology to qualify Allah's attributes.

[ReformedR]

Khalil is one of those rare muslims who actually have a brain lol

[AlsharifMohammed]

The Ashari Sunni position define descent means his mercy descents. None of the Salaf understood it how jake did, so sorry Islam is still the TRUTH.

[Logia]

ALLAH descends does not mean he physically or what his composed of comes on earth... but his has the knowledge and the awareness and of what's are on earth and in creation...
In the quran, it says that Allah is nearer than the jugular veins... that does not mean that he physically is near the believer or has entered the creation....

Such a weak understanding of Islam by these Christian bigots....

[andnowthis]

And just like that, Jake’s entire mission in life has come crashing down around him. You can actually see this at 3:32-3:35 when he starts chuckling because he realizes that he’s trapped.

[Lilliz]

Dr. Khalil wins my respect. Granted he is a doctor so of course he’s smart. He is a true Muslim critical to Muslims, atheists and Christian’s.

[realislam]

Lol, khalil can only destroy someone in dreams! According to him God is part of his creation. Ask him why he block jake if was able to answer intellectually, you like him because his beliefs are same as Christians, both khalil and trinity is false

[abucyrus]

As for God DESCENDING to the lowest heaven. Again, descend doesn't necessarily have to be physical either. you can DESCEND from monkeys. It doesn't mean you physically descend from something above. Or sadness can descend on you without any physical movement. So, God descending to the lowest heaven doesn't mean that God physically move from a higher physical space to a lower one. It means God is more merciful and more caring and more relenting.

[osmansaid]

This is the oldest debate in religion. Is god in his creation or outside his creation. These guys are debating two schools of the fourth school of thought of islam .Athari an mutazilite. There is only ashairite and maturidi. So this anti islam guy doesn't know all the four school are islamic

[Kimeikus]

Khalil clearly got destroyed. But when you care more about seeing Sunni Islam lose than the truth, you’ll say anything.

Ngl, I was confused at first but then I realized that the person who uploaded this video ain’t even Muslim.

[QuranicIslam]

Never saw (and won't watch) the debate, but this is a pretty nice example I suppose of why everyone says Khalil won, right?

[abucyrus]

Another stupid Christian argument.

Yes, we point up because of the hadith. So, God is up. However, it doesn't mean that God is PHYSICALLY up. UP doesn't have to be PHYSICAL. If you speak UP, you don't go up physically, you speak louder. If you shut UP, you don't shut something physically above you, you be silent. when the time is UP, the time didnt go any higher, it means there's no more time. so, saying God is UP, doesn't necessarily mean God is physically above you because God is not physical. God CREATES the physical world.

but in OUR language, we say God is up because God is BEYOND our reach, beyond our COMPREHENSIBILITY, beyond our GRASP. and when i say beyond our comprehensibility, i don't mean God is ILLOGICAL like the trinity, it's just that it's something too great to understand, not too stupid to understand.

if i say pi doesn't end and the number will go on and on and on until the end of time, would you be able to grasp that? of course not. no one could imagine something like that, but is it ILLOGICAL like the trinity? of course not. youre right, the trinity is very incomprehensible, but not because the trinity is too great to understand, but it's because it's too stupid to have any meaningful element. the trinity says 3 Gods is not three Gods but one God. What the hell is that? Islam however says God is beyond our comprehension. that's all the phrase "God is up" or "God is above" means.

[radirandom]

This is a debate between ashari and salafi aqeedah

[MJAli]

ALLAHS LIGHT DECENDS ON THE LOWEST HEAVEN LIKE A LIGHT BEAM FREQUENCY.

[-Ahmed]

Imam Nawawi rahimahullah: "Allah descends" means His mercy descends.

[trinitymatrix]

Can anybody under, above allahs throne plus earthly muselims come to find escape routine to Jake?

[housse]

You are making a fallacy which is categorical mistake.
The mechanisms of the descent of Allah is unknown, because the nature of Allah is unknown. This is rational and consistent. Allah describe His action with "nuzul", so we describe Him with what He describe himself.. who are we to say Allah is wrong.
But trinity is a whole different issue. Trinity is asking you to believe that three is one. That god died. That god is lacking in knowledge. That God can be limited. This is not a mechanistic question at All.