Hitler's Island [Thought Experiment]

Doug Husak asks why we punish people when no good will come of it.

[The_Noticer.]

10 reactions, only 4 visible. Muh halls of debate amirite?

[niceforkinmove]

Could it be important to the person that believes in retribution that Hitler knows he is being punished for his crimes?

[nathanperry]

Hmm, heres an adjustment to make it more realistic: Lets add button that turns the island into fourth reich. Let's call it straw hat nationalism this time around.

[sunnyinvladivostok]

what about hitler? will any moral advancements or degradations in his own being come from his suffering?

[robertsaget]

Is there a video this is a clip from on the horizon or did I miss it somewhere on your channel?