The Witcher 3 Next Gen vs Red Dead Redemption 2 - Physics and Details Comparison

In this video I show a full comparison of textures, physics and details The Witcher 3 Next Gen Version vs Red Dead Redemption 2 Video completely filmed and edited by me (GameBest) I show which of the game best

Timing:
0:00 - Snow Deformation
0:37 - Horse Details
2:25 - Water Physics
2:47 - Textures
3:41 - Swimming
4:23 - Fire Propagation
5:15 - Archery (Do the arrows stay in the tree?)
6:06 - Boating (Boat Details)
7:28 - Climbing ladder

The Witcher 3 vs RDR2
#rdr2 #thewitcher3 #reddeadredemtion2

[TheJdumoulin]

I love Witcher 3 with all my heart, but nothing can compare to RDR2's physics and details.

[gauthamumamageshwaran]

Both are masterpieces
Witcher 3 is like a beautiful painting which is narrated
RDR2 is life.. You learn a lot from Arthur

[performancecore]

Rdr 2 is a gem .Rockstar has thrown everything in this game graphics story emotion everything

[SultanPlayz_]

Two of the greatest games of this generation (possibly of all time)

The Witcher 3 with its outstanding Storytelling, Worldbuilding, and Characters.

And RDR2 with its technical marvel, realistic-ness, uncomparable NPC AI, and an awesome story aswell.

[tytytut]

nothing beats rdr2 details in physics but something about Witcher 3 colors when you looks at a distant scenery is just so special, it's like you can breath the air, especially in Toussaint

[RYBWorld]

Rdr2 is realistic, but I love how the world looks in the witcher with colorful weather and trees swinging around in the wind with abandoned forts in the distance

[moyst]

two games that will outlive many generations of upcoming titles, one because of its legendary storyline/gameplay and the other for its technical marvels/incredibly detailed world

[Zenxfreth]

Top 2 games of a generation. Both of them are unforgettable.

But we have to give SOME special credit to CD Projekt Red for being able to make a same callibre game with Rockstar, with much less budget and experience. And the release date of TW3 is 3 years earlier. Props to them!

[harounzizou]

Don't forget that witcher released on begining of 2015 and Rd2 on late 2018

[emmanuel]

The Witcher 3's crossbow was an absolute afterthought that was apparently added just so you could have a way to bring down flying enemies and attack underwater ones -- that's why the projectiles aren't even rendered beyond a white line and have no collision unless you hit something that takes damage. The aard sign has water collision, though.

[xXSilentAgentXx]

Fun fact: You could dive in water in RDR2, but that feature was left cut out of the game. Voicelines still exist in gamefiles.

[coolamericano]

RD2 learned a lot from the Witcher to begin with. Witcher 3 was mind-blowing when it came out and it still looks great.

[ZarkiGaming]

Rdr2 the best most realistic game ever made

[supreme]

I feel like these two games are so different yet so alike, both of them with great open worlds, missions, and both have a little something to add to the greatness like gwent or the 90 challenges in rdr, i played both for over 150 hours and i only can only thank the developers for experiences that i’ll never enjoy any time soon!!

[mariosstylianou]

My 2 favorite games so far, I can't put the one above the other. Both are masterpieces and unique in their own way. I hope developers take examples and make more games like those 2 in the future.

[kaidi_p]

witcher 3 has its own charm, a different world of its own, its graphics doesn't have to be like RDR2
my opinion

[oceanedetotes]

1:14 You should watch it at 0*25 : You can see all the horses muscles but also all the movement of the horse is perfectly accurate with Arthur Morgan and reciprocally. Exactly what happened in real life when you ride a horse. This is astonishing

[Ztrawbz]

I spent hours in rdr2 exploring and soaking up the landscape, riding my horse through the mountains, incredible, such a beautiful serene experience. Unfortunately when i came back to civilisation and started playing the main story I just got bored after a short while. The shootouts get seriously repetitive for one.
The Witcher may not look as good but it just sucks you in at every turn of the narrative wheel, the story takes you on a kaleidoscopic journey.

[jessetoland]

The Witcher Wild Hunt was ahead of its time in graphics and everything it brought to the gaming world. Besides RDR2 not many games can hold a match to it as of today.

[schpeidermann]

"In both games the horse comes after the whistle" - yes, but Roach gets teleported from anywhere immediately. Sometimes lands on a rooftop...
Your horse in RDR2 only comes if you stay within it's "hearing" range. If not, you can whistle all day long and nothing happens.