Mulan (1998) vs. Mulan (2020) Shot for Shot Comparison

Take a look at scenes from the original #Mulan (1998) compared to the new Mulan (2020) and deep dive into #Disney animation vs. live action.

[papapapagio]

Animated version brought honor to us all.

[liuyifeifanclub]

Liu Yifei is amazing in Mulan! She’s so beautiful and talented! ❤

[zekion.]

0:38 this shot alone proves the animated is better. I genuinely dislike the new disney live action trend... Sucks out all the colors from the original and what made the original so great.

[herrlogan]

I saw both, the original is so much better.

[iamchristian]

If you guys want know the reasons for the changes, Mushu is a Phoenix due to cultural appropriation, there’s a shapeshifting witch because China have beliefs in shapeshifters, Mulan doesn’t cut her hair because, cutting someone’s hair was considered a punishment and would have been a sign of disgrace, the songs will be background music and reflection will be sung in the end credits by Liu Yifei and Christina Aguilera, and shang is separated into two characters because of the me too movement and the director thought it was weird that Mulan was dating and later married her own general

Also for the whole thing about the actress supporting the hk police, she didn't do anything wrong, she was forced to do it, in order to protect her family, a lot of Chinese celebrities had the do the same, in order to keep themselves and their families alive

It’s not their fault that HK is getting killed, I'm sure they want to save you but they can't since they have to follow order from their own country

[zirconviper]

Liu Yifei was more captivating than her cartoon counterpart.

No. I like 1998 original. This... new version. I doubt it is going to be any good.

[diannegracesyisla]

SOOO BEAUTIFUL! I was anticipating this movie since last year! And I can say it has really exceeded my expectations! Cinematography, acting, and action scenes were breathtaking! Mulan truly inspires me to be loyal, brave, and true. Too bad due to the pandemic I didn't get to watch this in the cinema. I hope Disney can still profit from this film. I'm now a fan of Yifei Liu and Yosan An! I love all the rising Asian actors in Hollywood!

For those who are complaining about the absence of Mushu and Shang, etc., I suggest you all go feed your nostalgia and rewatch the animated film. Although I did miss the songs from the animated film, this live action has its own magic and gives Mulan a new flavor! Love love love Mulan! This is my newest favorite action film! I'm glad to see Disney explore into other genres for movies!

[pencilchannel]

Hope Mulan will be screened in my country. I like this Disney princess.
I'm a big fan of Mushu of Mulan 1998 and I drew Mulan and Mushu last night.
Hope you guys like it.

[iamchristian]

Still excited for it, I don’t care about the changes or the controversy of the actress, I just want to see this girl being a total badass and fight

[titanstudios]

I really prefer the live action version the animated just completely pointless