Did Jesus Turn Water Into Wine? | Dr. Shabir Ally

A viewer asks, "Does Islam accept the Biblical story of Jesus forcibly cleansing the temple in Jerusalem? Did he turn water into wine?

ONLY 13 DAYS LEFT!

Please SUBSCRIBE to SUPPORT the show!

[yosufmohmand]

I really like your videos. They answer my questions in a rational way. Love from Afghanistan.

[stefenski]

"Did he turn water into wine?"
Maybe they got that the wrong way around.

[phun]

Every time I have heard the wine explained the wedding celebration is said to have stretched over several days. They ran out of drinks after a day or two, it wasn't about prolonging a party late into the night.

[kitson]

Did hommamed really have a magic flying horse?

[Magic]

My Cardiology told me but he doesn't like to tell his patients who likes to drink what he did told me that a little glass of red wine it's good for the heart. and let's be real how many people don't want to drink but they smoke like crazy you know how much chemical a cigarette has. cigarette smoking it's not mentioned in the Quran and it's not even mentioned in the Bible but it is very harmful. Cigarette smoking is worse than having a glass of red wine did I tell you to go out there and drink until you can drink no more that's not what I'm saying what I'm saying is when you compare it to smoking smoking is very dangerous it destroys your temple the body your soul that you used to worship your creator

[fidelcatsro]

maybe they changed grape juice to wine to justify alcohol drinking in later writings

[YouTubecensored]

Why was the Koran written 600 years after The Bible? Seems to me its second place. 1st test

[zosmanovic]

00:43 the Christians were right..and I'm not even Christian...the whole Arabamahic shananigans needs to go back to Judaism I think

[xbooddf]

0:34 Quran know nothing about temple how can mention it!

[suki]

Shair Ally u just said peace the day i was born, the day i will die, the day i will rise. quran 19 v 33 That happen allready. Jesus is God. yr quran 19 v 19 say Jesus is holly son. What is Muhammad in quran?? Come to Christ He is coming. God bless

[alwinmathew]

That is what these guys do, they erase problematic stuff from their dictionary. And why do these guys when asked questions start speaking bla bla allah bulllah stuff.

[memewalisarkar]

at that point i consider jesus is fictional character.

[AKeyearea]

According to muslims we will be drinking wine in heaven and it wont get us drunk. Like water... burn

[gsworkhard]

Pls leave Islam and come to Jesus is the only way to the father and the ever lasting life.amen

[SiberianGravy]

Story is not mentioned In Quran coz Mohammad didnt hear about it .

[rafaelgabrielsantos]

If Jesus were to himself said that then it would probably true, paul must have put this to make it legit like pork eating to go against god command

[reginapendleton]

Whose to say, it may be that the water was truly only water but mirth and joy made it like wine.♡

[neoneherefrom]

This is a fable but an infant talking… now that’s credible.

[Eleidig]

I do enjoy this content but I feel he didn't really answer the question, he just said some Muslims find this problematic. So did isa as Turn water into wine? I'm still confused

[Amaaaaan]

Yes we enjoy watching your show and learn from it. I would like Dr Ally to do a detailed program on how the gospel evolved and how the bible stories and doctrines were changed by gospel writers.
He talks about this in his debates but just gives a couple of examples, probably bcuz of the time, but can he give comprehensive examples from the gospels?
It will be much appreciated!