How to Make Egg Custard Pie | Pie Recipes | Allrecipes.com

Watch how to make this sweet egg custard that's won Grandma a blue ribbon in the American Pie Council's National Pie Championship. A simple custard is whipped up and poured into a flaky pie shell. Just bake this up and garnish with some fresh fruit and ground nutmeg.

Allrecipes Magazine is now available!

Facebook

Twitter

@Allrecipes

[karlalton]

This is the best recipe on youtube as all the others use tin's of condensed milk instead of proper milk .
This is just how we used to have it in the UK thank you 🙏🙏

[karlbraun]

They don't show it in this video, but I have never found a 9" deep dish pie shell, that will work for this amount of mixture. I cut the recipe down to 1 and 1/2 cups milk ( I use half and half) just out of the carton (not scalded) 1/2 cup sugar instead of 3/4 cup, and I use 1/2 teaspoon of Cinnamon instead of the Nutmeg. It turns out great, and will fit in a 9" deep dish pie shell.

[billnroger]

Looks so easy and good! Gonna try this tomorrow! Thanks....

[jeffholifield]

Going to follow this recipe for Thanksgiving thank you for sharing

[GawoniiAustencao]

I followed this recipe to the letter, but My pie has been in the oven for over 45m. Still in liquid form as it was when I put it in the oven at the start

[elliemm]

Hard to find custard pies today, and when you do, it's a mini pie that costs 7 dollars.
Thank you. I will be making three of these this Autumn.

[petrab.-c.]

in Belgium we say to this pie....a flantaart (flan pie) i love this pie☺

[marendenison]

Your custard pie, sweet and nice... 🎶

[earlrodgers]

Would evaporated milk work in this recipe?

Put coconut into the custard mix before baking. Coconut custard pie is delicious!

[agusartii]

Looks yummy! Specially if you notice that seems like an onion-cheese pie with a raspberry and a blueberry on it. But i like anyway.

[bigpagla]

It feels so weird not cooking the bird this year. I'm compensating with pies. As a kid I remember eating homemade custard pies when we lived in the country. Only the elderly grammys made it and they made it well. I'm gonna make an extra one and hide it from my scavenging fam.

[radhasamoedj]

hmmmm thanks for this beautyfull recepi

[sarafernandez]

I have a question . do you have to have the crust un cooked ?? is it a must??

[safarafi]

can i use half and half instead of milk

[hazeleyezluv]

I'm here to see why my cheesecake turned into egg custard pie. 😭

[rinwalton]

so is the milk just hot? or is that a certain type of milk?

[LOZBRY]

going to make this what's 400 f sound very hot what is it in English

[tennesseegirl]

You said in the video that if using pasteurized milk did not need to be scalded. This is a failure, don't follow this recipe, I cooked for over an hour and it burned the crust edge. She says 30-35 minutes, if your going to do the recipe, you must scald the milk. 👎👎

[amAvenger]

I did not add hot milk :( Its in oven now.. took longer than 35 mins...So far 45..