Jeet Kune Do Guy vs Karate, Kickboxing, and MMA

We have three matches from a very promising Jeet Kune Do guy named Huang Haoyou. In the first one, he takes on a Karateka named Nishio Takesh. In the second one, he takes on a kickboxer (王瑋翰), and in the third one, he takes on an modern MMA guy (莊荃勝). Let's see what we can learn from all this! Let us know if JKD deserves a new name!

Watch the original for more context, especially if you speak Chinese:

Join this channel to get access to perks:

#fight #commentary #breakdowns #kungfu #wingchun #muaythai #JKD #jeetkunedo

Timecodes:
0:00 JKD vs Karate
3:17 Cameo by neighbor
3:26 Match Round 2
6:30 Hilarious typo
6:38 Match Round 3
9:39 JKD vs Kickboxing
14:22 JKD vs MMA
15:13 Thoughts on JKD guy
15:57 Question about JKD to audience

[FightCommentary]

Any other JKD people, please send me your footage. No demo please! Pressure tested JKD.

[redrenegade]

Dude, you're taking acting classes? That's awesome. I've been doing martial arts for almost as long as I've been doing theatre. Got my degree and my black belt about the same time. Keep trying new things!

[WeaponsRemorse]

style ves style we need more of this like OG UFC 1

[lcb]

I’ve sparred both Original JKD and JKD Concepts guys and there is a stark difference between the two. Concepts guys tend to be overall better fighters while Original guys tend to be good at technical basics. But Original guys are limited in their strategy and tactics compared to Concepts. From personal experience, the Concepts groups spar more often than Original groups.

[martialgeeks]

Jkd is so fascinating, it's so many different things all at once haha, and not only in the sense of being a mixed art, but that it has so many different schools and people who look like they train totally different arts from eachother...idm it's interesting

[fardhidthetiger]

劍拳之道: the way of the fencing fist, alternative name for jeet kune do, in cantonese though. cuz jeet kune do is cantonese an bruce lee spoke cantonese

[Vidyut_Gore]

JKD has the better stance. Very stable. Perhaps he doesn't mind the kicks. Karate guy's stance is a lot more flimsy. Fast legs, but not that stable a stance. Comes close to shuffling with legs very close. If JKD had gone for his legs, lots of stuff could've happened.

JKD is here for boxing.

Also unclear why these guys are waiting for each other to complete their kicks before making their move. They're fine moving their hands when the other is punching, but not feet.

[kobet]

The karate guy putting his hands behind his back is saying “come and get me” XD

[keitumetsebembe-ughd]

It's not about the style. It's about the fighter.

[jmurrayathletics]

Great compilation! Enjoyed watching these

[sunn]

This guy is not doing "JKD".

Why? Because real JKD is not for sport.., there is no "my turn, now your turn", it's in all the way until it's finished.

Neither is it sparring ( play fighting).

JKD came about as JunFan was found lacking, trying to make modified Wing Chun work, which it doesn't in street fighting, even with Bruce's reflexes & attributes, he kept getting hit.

What Bruce taught versus what he trained were two separate things, for he didn't want to teach people to beat him, but at the last minute, decided to redo The Fighting Method books but departed before he got started.. source: Shannon Lee.

He only showed 2-4 people what he was really doing.

JKD main targets are eyes, groin & knee caps, secondary are throat, rib, solar plexus or ankle break..., not for play fighting but Warfare.

Dan Lee, Jesse Glover and Ted Wong are pretty much did not exploit their friend Lee by teaching stuff he either DIDN'T teach or old stuff he threw out "CALLING" it JKD.

Documented fact that Bruce Lee called his Seattle school, his Oakland school and his Lis Angeles school and told Dan Lee, Taky Kimura and James Lee that Chi Sao was out.

Movie martial arts and War Field warfare are solar systems away from each other.

Nunchakus are not JKD, Three Sectional Staff is not JKD, Kali sticks is not JKD and neither is Lee jumping 10 feet into a tree branch in Enter The Dragon is not JKD.

Neither is it a mix of 700 martial arts.

There is no JKD grappling and wrestling.., "IF" a person got that close, in the first place, because of an f**k up, rip out his eyes, tear/rip/crush his throat, bite off his lips, ears, nose, bite off or break off his fingers, rip his gonads off.

JKD is not for sport or play, it is serious Warfare.

[biochemicks]

Ok fine I'll like for lucy but she'd better be in the next video too

[charlesstar]

Jkd is not for sport, the things that are illegal to do in mma or sport, is 70% of jkd training!

[PerunaMuayThai]

Response to your final question: You might also say JKD person uses "Jun Fan Gung Fu" if they only practiced that specific art. The school where I started was JKD but had 4 arts from the get go with Jun Fan, Muay Thai, Silat, and Kali classes all in the curriculum. More arts get added like Sayoc Kali when you got deeper but I didn't get to that level before I moved.

It's possible our main character today only trained Jun Fan because he emphasized certain techniques and he was right foot lead. Even if that's the case I have a lot of criticisms from even my 6 total months in Jun Fan.

[individeo]

The fighting game is always evolving. Before Bjj would win 8 out of 10 fights against any other martial in an MMA fight, but then thr other styles begun to learn hor to nullify BJJ, not beat it but nullify and then gicus on their own style snd peopke lije Tartakov, Chuck Lidell or Sakuraba showed that it is not sbout what you train it is about how you train and what you are training for, in those times fights were just brawls, and fighters would leave the octogon completely messed up . Later came the golden era of stylists, Guys Like Anderson Silva, GSP, Aldo, Machida or Bones who came up with s different approach: they fid not want to get hit as much and the stances and footwork became more similar to karate footwork than Muay Thai footwork, more like fencing, in and out. Almost like point fighting... ironic how things turn around

[BoxerKyokushin]

The problem with JKD is they tend to fight with one hand ( lead hand), but when that one hand (lead hand) get tired, they don't have the hand to fight anymore.

[marcosyy]

Very nice. Did you see Chinzo Machida fighting? I like his style, he throws a lot of kick-punch combos

[rustyshackelford]

Lucy looks pretty tough; I bet she could take some of those ancient Kung Fu masters to town

[allafleche]

wasn't a groin shot, it was a nice kick to the belly

[MLaws-tu]

I don't know what you're looking at what stylistic differences do you see?They're both using the same techniques.