Is the Trinity logically coherent?

Resources:

[trevorlunn]

Me, myself and I think the answer is no.

DGH, you kindly referred me to a range of sources re Trinity theories recently, for which I thanked you and did pursue. I should have waited for this video (which you flagged) and saved myself a lot of time to achieve more comprehension than I got from my reading.

"I left out a lot of other models of the Trinity that I think people will find less plausible..."

*LESS PLAUSIBLE* ??? Brilliant, this is difficult to type since I'm still laughing.

[tawdryhepburn]

This is fascinating, but isn’t it more like the “My Grandfather’s Axe” thought game? My grandfather had an axe. He gave it to my father, who replaced the handle. My father gave it to me. I replaced the head. But it is still my grandfather’s axe.

[JohnM-cdou]

Craig's Cerberus analogy makes no sense as one head of Cerberus could not be said to be "fully Cerberus" as each of the parts of trinity are considered to be fully God

[joop]

I mean the idea that the mental states of the three persons are qualitatively identical isnt heretical is it?

[harryalexander]

You mind linking your resources for this video? Not a christian myself [Panendeist], but I'm willing to get into some Christian Ontology just to read how far Christians reach to explain their 3=1 beliefs.

Also the last statement: "So that means God's Mind is actually the Laws of Logic."

Does that mean This Statement is False?

[guillatra]

philosophy of identity can be used to bash something else than physicalism? Mind blowing!

[ScCat]

Sniff... ACHOOOooo!.... Hummm, sry. The smell of polytheism is strong here. But don´t worry, lets just rationalize all this into monotheism and everything will be alright, mkay?

[metatron]

What do you think of the thomistic argument that the persons are just relations?

[SteveMcRae]

Sure I use a computer voice for a few videos and people are all over me, you use one and you're beloved and almost worshiped as a god...of course would mean those atheist who do are no longer atheist but theist, that is if you ask Gman.

[TheLoobis]

2:30 Jesus, enough of this! The trinity is dumb! Explaining it is dumber! THERE!

[jeffposey]

I would include logical coherency as being among the characteristics of the Trinity. In the military, soldiers are often refereed to only by last name. If God, the only begotten Son, and Holy Spirit have the same last name guessing what it is be might be foolish. It might be safer to simply say it's, " God ". Also, letters of the alphabet, regardless of which one, are of the same family called letters. Jesus is refered to as the " only begotten " due to him being the only son of God whom had an immaculate conception. The rest of us are sons and daughters of man ( Adam & Eve ) but also potentially adoptable as children of God.