Judge Holden VS Evil characters (Who is more evil?) [Long version]

#luigisucnovaes
#edit

[LSNChannel-tn]

Ok, so before anything I would like to say that I don't think AM is THAT evil. Sure he is evil, and what he did was horrible, the thing is that all of his actions were made because of his hatred towards humanity. And in my opinion, hate ≠ evilness, sure hate can make a character more evil, but compared to Judge Holden who litteraly r-words children? Nah, I don't think AM went that far. Also for those who are confused why Black Hat and Nightmare Sans are that high on the list, is because they are the litteral concept of evil, even tho they didn't do things as fucked up as AM or the Judge did, they are still the embodiment of all the evilness in their universe. The only reason Nightmare is lower than Black Hat is because his good side is probably there, while Black Hat is 100% pure evil. This also applies to Zalgo and Scarlet King, who get stronger with the evilness in their verse, but since their verses are immense they are even more evil than Black Hat and Nightmare imo. But if you disagree with me, let me know in the comment section!

My dumbass also forgot to add Reverse Flash, sorry for that, btw he would probably be between Joker and Dio or a bit higher. I also wanted to add one, two and three from Hate Crime but I had to exclude them since there wasn't place enough. But they would probably be between The Scarlet King and the fascists from Salo.

Song used: Little Dark Age (Slowed + Reverb)

Any suggestions?

[captaintristan]

He makes the Batman who laughs look like a saint

[TheSFMWonderer]

It’s hard to really say how any of these people could be worse then Holden. Yes AM, Bill, Palpatine, Jonah, Joker, Afton, All For One, Muzan, Patrick Bateman, Micheal Myers, Dio, Homelander (Tv series), Val, Legion, Freddy, Alan, Freiza, Griffith/Femto, Sonic.Exe, and the Qu have all done so much horrible things, but Holden stands out for not only being based on a real life person, but also because unlike most of these other villains who have a tragedy, or a bit samey, Holden has none of it, he knows what he is, and loves every second of it. He’s a vile, disgusting, sadistic, evil monster.

[syawaaqillarendrafirmansya]

Even Johan Can't Stand A Chance To Defeat Judge Holden Domination💀

[OPMKingFan]

Bro dripped the most fucking badass Judge Holden edit 🔥

[Welcometoweirdmaggedon]

Alright, It’s About Time I Give *My* Takes On These. (Well, The Ones I’m Familiar Enough With At Least) (Keep In Mind This Is All My Opinion)

Holden Vs Cartman: Holden, Beyond No Concept Of Diff
Holden Vs Heisenberg: Holden, Beyond No Concept Of Diff
Holden Vs Jason: Holden, Beyond No Concept Of Diff
Holden Vs All For One: Holden, No Diff
Holden Vs Afton: Holden, Neg Diff
Holden Vs Bill Cipher: Bill, Extreme Diff (Not Only Is He Pretty Messed Up (Even If He Isnt Nearly As Messed Up As Holden, He Also Has The Bonus Of Being More Heinous. Holden Comes Close Tho Due To How Messed Up He Is)
Holden Vs Michael Myers: Holden, Beyond Neg Diff
Holden Vs Joker: Holden, Mid-High Diff
Holden Vs Dio: Holden, Extreme Diff
Holden Vs Valentino: Holden, No Diff
Holden Vs Freddy: Holden, No Diff
Holden Vs Alan Yates: Alan, Extreme Diff (Same Reasons As Bradley)
Holden Vs Frieza: Holden, Mid Diff
Holden Vs Griffith: Holden, High Diff
Holden Vs Johan: Holden, Beyond Neg Diff
Holden Vs Palpatine: Palpatine, Extreme Diff (Palpatine Had A Far Bigger Impact Due To All Of The Tragedies He Caused Across The Galaxy From His Descructive Actions. And He Once Stated That He Planned On Conquering The Universe When He Was Done With The Galaxy Which Makes Him Even Worse. W For Ranking Him As High As You Did Tho.)
Holden Vs Sonic.exe: Holden, No Diff
Holden Vs Black Hat: Holden, Low-Mid Diff
Holden Vs AM: Holden, Extremely Insane Diff
Holden Vs The Qu: Holden, Extremely Insane Diff
Holden Vs Zalgo: Holden, No Diff (Could Change)
Holden Vs Scarlet King: Scarlet King Extreme Diff
Holden Vs Peter Mountain: Holden, Extreme Diff
Holden Vs Vukmir: Vukmir, Extreme Diff
Holden Vs Labby: Labby, Extremely Insane Diff

[KimjohanJapon]

The guy who made serbian film: laughing in the corner

[alperon]

I think Sonic.exe is pretty close.
Like he's a narcissist creature who thinks that all humanity is his "toys" and wants to own all humanity and "play" with them forever (that "play" is basically what happens in first Creepypasta). He corrupted a programmer to make a bridge between our world and his own. He made a cult for himself. He did to multiple people which he did to Kyle. He tortured Tom so much he caused Tom taking his own life (He still take Tom's soul to play with him).
(If you want to learn more you can look his Pure Evil Wiki and other wikis)
(And if you wonder: Yes, this Creepypasta have a sequel. And a Remake)

[kaijukirby]

Bro makes Junko Enoshima look like a girl scout.

[skyler]

Nah cause AM hated humans so bad that he killed everyone brutally except for 5 people, whom he turned immortal and tortured for eternity. His methods of torture were horrible as well. They included constant burning, stabbing, raping, etc. He even turned one guy into a disgusting slug-like creature that couldn't eat, sleep, or do anything except feel pain. Keep in mind that AM presumably kept these people alive until the end of time. Just non-stop being assaulted in every single way, shape, or form, for an infinite amount of time.

[bradleyhauertheedtruncanfa]

My version (with villains I'm familiar enough with and feel fit here. Oh, and NOTE: THIS IS ALL JUST MY SILLY PERSONAL OPINION.):
Cartman, Alastor, Jimmy Crystal, Scarlet Overkill, and Maleficent? Holden, beyond concept of diff (added them to teach everyone I've seen that meatrides these 5 a lesson).
Gustavo Fring? Holden, beyond concept of diff.
Dr. Eggman (Games & IDW)? Holden, beyond concept of diff.
Scar? Holden, no definition of diff.
AFO? Holden, mid diff.
William Afton? Holden, neg diff.
Anton Chigurh? Holden, no definition of diff.
Patrick Bateman? Holden, neg diff.
Alex DeLarge? Holden, neg diff.
Lord Voldemort & Emperor Belos? Holden, beyond neg diff.
Michael Myers? Holden, beyond neg diff (cry about it, meatriders).
Comics Joker & DIO? Holden, extreme diff.
Homelander? Holden, beyond concept of diff.
Sonic.exe? Holden, beyond neg diff.
Johan Liebert? Holden, beyond neg diff.
Black Hat? Holden, beyond neg diff.
Freddy Krueger (original)? Holden, low diff.
Big Jack Horner? Holden, no diff.
Audrey 2? Holden, low diff.
Lennart Bedrager? Holden, low diff.
Bertram (Family Guy)? Holden, low diff.
Slightly Younger Tiny Tippy Tinkletrousers (Captain Underpants Book 10)? Holden, low diff.
Frieza? Holden, mid diff.
Rick Prime? Holden, mid diff.
Valentino (HH)? Holden, high-extreme diff.
Femto/Griffith? Holden, extreme-insane diff.
Mrs. Agatha Trunchbull (Matilda)? Holden, insane diff.
Aku? Holden, insane diff.
High Evolutionary? Holden, insane diff..
Porky Minch? Holden, insane diff.
Diesel 10 & P.T. Boomer (TATMR)? Holden, insane diff.
The Qu? Holden, impossible diff.
Darkseid? Holden, impossible diff.
AM? Holden, impossible diff.
Labby? Holden, impossible diff.
*Vukmir, Rasa, Palpatine, Alan Yates, Willy Wonka (AvocadoAnimations), Dimentio, Mephiles the Dark, Bill Cipher, Nyarlathotep, Infinity Ultron, Emperor Nefarious, Vitiate from Star Wars Legends, Thragg from the Invincible Comics, The Lich (only the PrimeWorld version in the original show, the one in Fionna and Cake doesn't count as that version is a different Lich than the one in the original show), The End from Sonic Frontiers, Mort from The Theorizer's "Mort Theory", & Kefka Palazzo are the only villains that beat Holden in terms of evilness in my opinion as of right now.*

[bradleyhauertheedtruncanfa]

W takes.
Only things I think that you don’t are that Bill Cipher, Alan Yates, Palpatine are more evil than Holden, AFO, DIO, Valentino and a few others like Griffith close come to Holden, Sonic.exe and Black Hat being low diff and high diff isn’t the case at all as it should be beyond concept of diff, Scarlet King doesn’t beat Holden (but only barely) and Labby comes close to Holden.
Also massive W for adding Vukmir at the end. He will always be the most evil character in fictional history to me.

[Головач-Лена]

Song name pls!!! By the way, gods from the HP Lovecraft universe would fit perfectly here!

[PolishGod]

Novel Bateman gives Judge a serious run for his money. Bateman in the book is viscious

[godzillavskongfan]

Alright here’s my opinion. I also added some new villains

Judge Holden vs Alastor: Holden No Concept of Diff
Judge Holden vs Eric Cartman: Holden No Concept of Diff
Judge Holden vs Heisenberg: Holden No Concept of Diff
Judge Holden vs Jason Voorhees: Holden No Concept of Diff
Judge Holden vs Bendy:
Holden No Concept of Diff
Judge Holden vs Boiled One:
Holden Neg-No Diff
Judge Holden vs Homelander:
Holden No Diff
Judge Holden vs Bill Cipher:
Holden No Diff
Judge Holden vs Aizen:
Holden No Diff
Judge Holden vs Dio:
Holden No Diff
Judge Holden vs Micheal Myers:
Holden No Diff
Judge Holden vs Anton Chigurh:
Holden No Diff
Judge Holden vs Valentino:
Holden No Diff
Judge Holden vs Frieza:
Holden No-Low Diff
Judge Holden vs Griffith:
Holden No-Low Diff
Judge Holden vs Johan Liebert:
Holden Low Diff
Judge Holden vs Joker:
Holden Low Diff
Judge Holden vs Gabriel (Mandela Catalogue):
Holden Low-Mid Diff
Judge Holden vs Sonic Exe:
Holden Low-Mid Diff
Judge Holden vs Utrom Shredder:
Holden Mid Diff
Judge Holden vs Aku:
Holden Mid Diff
Judge Holden vs Palpatine:
Holden Mid Diff
Judge Holden vs Lord X:
Holden Mid-High Diff
Judge Holden vs Black Hat:
Holden Mid-High Diff
Judge Holden vs The Lich:
Holden Mid-High Diff
Judge Holden vs Zalgo:
Holden High Diff
Judge Holden vs Scarlet King:
Holden High Diff
Judge Holden vs AM:
Holden High Diff
Judge Holden vs Brauth:
Holden High-Extreme Diff
Judge Holden vs The Qu:
Holden Extreme Diff
Judge Holden vs Vukmir:
Holden Insane Diff
Judge Holden vs Labby:
Labby Mid Diff

[alperon]

William Afton shouldn't be that low.

A sadistic, Sociopath, ruthless, remorseless Serial Killer who seeks immortality.

Afton takes great pride and pleasure in taking the lives of innocent people (mainly children), so much so he cracks a wide, sadistic smile during his machinations, and to make him even more terrifying, he barely raises his voice and maintains his calm, poetic composure, treating his horrific actions as disturbingly casual. Afton even enjoys toying with his victims and gets off on tormenting them to the point he even exaggerates that he is sustained by fear. It’s implied that William’s bloodlust is so great that it overcomes his rational thinking and causes him to take unnecessary risks to satiate it, like going to Freddy’s Fazbear’s Pizza Place just to kill a few more kids even though it was likely a trap, and even unnecessarily staying in Fazbear Fright just to kill the night guard. Afton is also shown to be arrogant and egotistical, bragging about his construct Circus Baby and her many advanced features, as well as believing nothing can truly stop him by boasting that he "Always Comes Back.”

He's manipulative too. He said to Susie that her dog is alive so he can lure her to death. He also tricked a little boy named Rory, whom he was experimenting on, into staying in his controlled environment by claiming he wouldn’t be able to function in the outside world after being trapped for ten years. He even pretended that all he wanted was Rory’s best interest by keeping him safe and cared for, but of course, this was a huge lie. It’s also implied that he even tricked his business partner Henry into thinking he was a good person, as it took him years before he finally understood William’s utter depravity.

Also, William is nothing more than a pathetic coward who is afraid of facing the same dread and pain he inflicts on others.

He murdered around eleven children, and probably even more than that, at numerous Freddy Fazbear's Pizza locations throughout the 1980s without remorse, causing them to possess both the original and Toy animatronics. One of them was his best friend and business partner's daughter, Charlotte Emily, who became the Puppet.

He was perfectly willing to use personal lives for his own gain, lying to a girl named Susie that her dead dog is actually alive just to lure her into getting killed.

It's possible he was even the killer of Susie's dog, although it could have been by accident.

Depending on what one believes about the Midnight Motorist minigame, he was either abusive to one of his own children or lured a child out of his abusive home just so he could experiment on or kill him.

His actions have led to countless night guards being hunted and/or killed by the animatronics due to them mistaking the night guards for William, including his own son Michael. One of these night guards was the Phone Guy, who was killed by one of them during his last week.

He directly neglected his youngest son and the fact that he was being bullied by his older brother Michael, which makes him indirectly responsible for his death/the Bite of '83. He also forced him to have his birthday at Fredbear's Family Diner, despite the boy's obvious fear of the place.

Assuming he was the Fredbear Plush at some point, then he knew full well how bad his youngest son was being bullied and didn't do anything to stop it whatsoever, only giving him false hope that 'tomorrow is another day'. He also possibly manipulated and gaslight his son, telling him that Michael hates him, and that the animatronics he is afraid of will do something bad to him if he gets caught by them.

Assuming he is the Orange Guy from Midnight Motorist, then he's both a physically and verbally abusive father, banging on his son's door, shouting at him for not listening to him, and ultimately threatening him when he discovers that he has run off.

He built an underground chamber to kidnap and torture kids in (which most likely included Michael) as part of an experiment, and designed automated puppets called the Nightmare animatronics that appear 'alive' when his victims are exposed to hallucinogenic gas. At least one of his victims, Rory, was trapped there for ten years and left with barely any food, essentially clinging to life and likely on the brink of starvation.

He constructed the Funtime animatronics and designed them specifically to kill children, one of the victims being his own daughter Elizabeth (although her death was, as far as we know, purely accidental).

It's also heavily implied that he put the missing children's remnants from their suits into the Funtime animatronics, making him responsible for the events of Sister Location and their actions as Molten Freddy in Pizzeria Simulator until their destruction in the latter game.

While it looks like Elizabeth's death was accidental, it's also possible he used reverse psychology to get her killed as, according to Elizabeth, he claimed that he made Baby "just for her" and watched her play with other children, but didn't allow her to do it, tricking her into sneaking off to play with Baby when he wasn't looking. That said, this was never confirmed.

He used electric shocks to torture Circus Baby, Ballora, Funtime Foxy, and possibly Funtime Freddy into obedience in an underground location for his experiments. This would lead to the many injuries and deaths of workers at the facility.

Additionally, William was fully aware that Baby was possessed by Elizabeth, yet he didn't stop his employees from shocking her and even ordered them to do so.

He destroyed the original four animatronics with the presumed help of Shadow Freddy.

After putting on the Spring Bonnie suit, he laughed at the souls for no reason other than to mock them. Then you know what happened to him.

Prior to his death, he sent his son, Michael Afton, to the underground Circus Baby's Entertainment and Rental to release his sister, knowing there is a chance he will die.
While Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria Simulator would reveal he presumably didn't intend for Ennard's creation, he has no remorse for it and outright calls it "fascinating".

After becoming Springtrap, he tried to kill the security guard of Fazbear's Fright (who is heavily implied to be Michael) for no reason other than pure bloodlust.

It's implied that he was responsible for deterring the Fazbear's Fright guard with the Phantom animatronics by creating them.

Additionally, it's possible that he murdered the Phone Dude the night he was brought to Fazbear's Fright, which would explain why we never hear from again later during the week.

He attempted to continue his killing spree in Freddy Fazbear's Pizza Place. It's worth noting that Afton was fully aware of the place being a trap, but went there anyways as he couldn't pass up the opportunity of killing a few more kids.

He tried to kill his own son, Michael, in Freddy Fazbear's Pizza Place.

In Freddy Fazbear's Pizzeria Simulator, it is revealed that Baby wanted to kill children so her father can be proud of her, implying that William was neglectful towards her, and didn't give her enough love and attention when she was alive. It might also explain why William unknowingly allowed Elizabeth to run and see Circus Baby.

His actions have lead a massive impact in the series. An animatronic endoskeleton known as the Mimic created by a Fazbear Entertainment engineer in the 80's saw Afton's murders and became obsessed with replicating him, eventually becoming a digital virus known as Glitchtrap after being scanned into a VR video game. As a result, dozens of people would be endangered (possibly even killed) by the Fazbear Funtime Service animatronics, Vanessa would be painfully brainwashed into becoming Vanny and go on a killing spree in Freddy Fazbear's Mega Pizzaplex like Afton did in the 80's, claiming nine victims, and Gregory would be forced to betray and presumably kill his friend Cassie to prevent the Mimic from hurting him, among others.

[diegojimenez]

Honestly i disagree with michael myers...bro has no reason whatsover or sad backstory or any sort of disability. From the moment he was born that kid was the definition of pure evil...

He kills people just for the sake of killing and he gets nothing in return...

Altough at the same time he's not a sadist or anything like that...he just kills you....brutally.

Something more kind that what the judge would do

[TheDarkKnighttt]

Fire edit dude this is a underrated gem glad the qu was included but i personally think frieza and palpatine should be higher

[ARunning]

What about Auditor (madness combat), lich (adventure time), aku (samurai jack), cyn with absolute solver (murder drones), Agent Smith (matrix), vilgax (Ben 10), malware (ben 10), Albedo (Ben 10), SCP 3999 (SCP foundation) ?

[godzillavskongfan]

What about Utrom Shredder from teenage mutant ninja turtles 2003?