trombones are still never animated correctly...

this is the best video I've ever made.

#bandkids #concertband #music

[kc]

He moved the slide so much just for one note 😭😭😭

[christinashelby]

So that's how the French horn was invented!

[spacecakes]

I have never felt such pain, as watching that trombone go into, and be crushed by a vice.

[aidanh]

I love how when he smashes the trombone it turns into a baritone then it goes blurry then when he pulls it off it turns into a French horn

[russellmattesich]

i play trombone in beggining band your so good!

[FrostbearPlushies]

It’s astonishingly simple to animate brass, it’s a total of 7 or more place holders. I did it myself.

[brianjungen]

Hey at least they’ve got the right hand on the slide. I’m a clarinetist and cry every time I see the right hand on top……🙄🤦‍♂️😢

[Autohagiographer]

This has been a huge objection of mine regarding actors pretending to play guitar. I once watched someone, during a big dance number, play a great part, on an unplugged strat, all from the comfort of a second fret A7.

[CarelessCritter]

As a trombone player it pained me so much when he held the trombone upside down

[That-Music-Girl-]

As a loyal trombonist, I feel traumatized and will never see this duck the same way again

[godzilla]

Bro had an invisible tuning slide being able to move the playing slide and play the same note

[FukiMakai]

Rare from Disney studios to un notice that

[lethalweaboo]

I like how he managed to turn 7 feet of tubing to 13ish feet of tubing by compressing it.

[spderweb]

As an animator and musician, I always make sure to make it work as an instrument would. That said, if we were to use the exact fingering or position, sometimes the instrument wouldn't change frame to frame. It's fine for realism, but for animation, it will look like it wasn't animated. I play trumpet. And last trumpet bit i worked on only used open and first finger, back and forth, or held on one of them (I even played it myself in order to get the notes right). I had to add in fingerings to give it variety. Annoying from our musical perspective, but otherwise, the animation looks dead.

[jdraven]

The most unrealistic thing is that he knew how to hold it correctly

[daffers]

Yeah, they never animate them correctly or have the right notes at the right position. They even did it in a Gumby episode. (I also don't like Donald's wanton destruction of that poor trombone, but it's only a Disney cartoon) XD

[ethanali]

0:17 who noticed the Thomas the tank engine in the background?
Edit: Yay I’m famous
Edit 2: thank you for liking this comment and plus I don’t even wanna beg in my comments for likes like little 5 year old

[SamWickens]

Jesus, I was scared for a second you'd show what it sounds like to put a trombone in a pneumatic press or something.

[brianeisemann]

I saw an episode of the Simpsons where Lisa was playing the trombone. The slide positions were animated correctly, along with the required positions for the notes on the soundtrack. (i have perfect pitch). It was amazing!

Edit: I just tried finding it and couldn't. Didn't look hard. I know that Homer also plays Greensleeves and they even animate the High D in 4th because it is closer to the adjacent E-flats. The Simpsons have some amazing animators and attention to detail when it comes to music.

[BenjaminElijah]

0:14 that’s a perfect way to get a French horn 😂