Minerva McGonagall vs Severus Snape | battle (books) #shorts

#harrypotterfan #harrypotteredit #harrypotterbook #harrypotter
#warnerbros #wizardingworld #wizardingworldharrypotter #fantasticbeasts
#minervamcgonagall #severussnape #battle #гаррипоттер #северусснейп #хогвартс #слизерин #гриффиндор #slytherin #Gryffindor #vs #battle #ravenclaw #hufflepuff #halfbloodprince #halfblood #harrypotterfan #harrypotteredit #harrypotteredits #harrypottergame #dracomalfoy #ronweasley #hermionegranger #siriusblack #warnerbrospictures #spells #whoisstrongest#alanrickman

[strangeralex]

*Occlumency and Legilimency are taken as one point

[Anonymous-pcvq]

McGonagall was by far the most underrated one and deserved more screen-time

[Sumt-Chwdhury_]

We would love to watch a series based on prof Snape.

[LouisTravieon]

I've read the books more times than I can remember, and truthfully Snape wouldn't duel to kill Mcgonagall, as I do believe he cared for her as a friend and colleague, as well as his former professor, there definitely was respect there. However, if there was a duel to kill, nothing holding either back, each other's lives on the line, don't automatically assume Snape wins. Yes he is by far one of the most powerful wizards in that world, but Minerva is as well. I definitely think they'd both need to be at the very top of their game to out do one another.

[Tonycillian]

Let’s take a moment to realize that Book Voldemort beat Minerva, Shacklebolt, and Slughorn in a duel all three at the same time

[tenmrchicken]

Fr, McGonagall is my favourite character but she is not more agile in the books lol. Snape and Voldomort were the only ones who could fly

[WillOrWillNot]

I truly believe that if Snape could have lived to be as old enough as Dumbledore he could’ve easily been his equal in power if not stronger and I love the fact in his and McGonagalls actual duel he was not only holding back 😮 but also trying to protect students by deflecting her spells into the two death eaters behind him 😮😮😊

[BJenno]

I’ve never read the books; but in the video, Snape has stamina, right? So that means he’ll be able to last long against his opponent. Even though Minerva is older and more skilled, but Snape’s speed could overwhelm her with his spells. Not hating, just pointing out what I see in this clip. You saw Snape dodging those offensive spells from Minerva? So his defence is obviously good. But from what I heard is that Snape has crafted his own spells. To me, that means he’ll use different tactics and methods to best his opponent, making him a cunning duellist. Sometimes using old wand spells against your opponent is never a good strategy. So in my opinion, Snape would’ve defeated her in this case. But I’m more than happy to hear your opinions

[zerokun]

No matter how much Snape overpowers Minerva, with just how skilled and experienced she is, she would still win, power isn’t everything in a fight, especially with all of the spells in Harry Potter

[charlie]

Mcgonagall is my favorite character just because of her attitude, her loyalty to the school, the way that she instantly jumps to Harry's defence without saying a letter and because she knows what her opponent (Snape) is capable of

[TheLucAaASsS]

Nada tira da minha cabeça que o Snape se deixou morrer, pq cumpriu a sua missão, ele era apto a se defender dos ataques do Voldemort

[felixgaming]

Minerva<Snape
Reasons: Snape's durability is much higher, as we can see that McGonagall almost died from a few Stunning Spells. Snape created one of the most powerful Dark spells at a young age; Sectumsempra. Also, considering Snape uses Dark magic, it seems impossible for McGonagall to win, as Snape has a wider arsenal of spells than McGonagall. Snape also has a speed and stamina advantage, as he is younger than the old McGonagall. The only statistic Minerva beats Severus in; as Snape smashes her in Occlumeency and Legilimency; is duel experience. Obviously, she is older and has gone through many other fights. Overall, if a fight were to occur between the two, which would be very rare, as they cared for each other as colleagues, Severus would beat Minerva at 42.5% of his full power. For example, he would defeat Bellatrix with about 89.6% power, although losing to Voldemort at 100% while Riddle being at 91.3%.

[Navynixiy]

Snape loved Harry Potter and wanted to protect him that duel was It shows lord voldemort that he doesn't care about harry. In the last movie, Harry learns the truth about his father, but in the book, he finds out in the fifth year!When he died in the book but also in the movie I started to cry 😞 Harry lost many loved ones in that battle 😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭😭

[bruhmomentos]

Tell me if I’m wrong but she participated in a wizarding war and was actually involved in quite a bit of combat, and experience beats skill most times

[georgie]

Snake wins.
Their duel was a stalemate but Snape was still on the good side. He wasn’t trying to hurt her, so he was holding back.
And Minerva was going all out she was vexed. She was having an even battle against a Snape who’s holding back.
If both went all out-Snape wins

[RaccooniusIII]

Rowling wasnt talking about Snape v McGonagall 1 v 1. She was talking about the book scene where it was 3 v 1. Snape wins mid diff at hardest.

[AAhmood]

POV:the duel takes place

Minerva: *spells*
Snape:Avada kedavra *credits roll*

[nelsonreyes]

What's the song playing in the background

[ladyv]

I mean, it helped that Snape respected McGonagall and had no intention of harming her. If you watch carefully, it's clear that he is deliberately deflecting her shots and directing them towards the Death Eaters behind him.

[denizkenger]

Mate that interview keeps coming up but nobody ever sources it nor ever says exactly what she said. Please give source if you’re saying JKR said something.

I don’t accept she said that until I know for sure that she said it. Need at least the exact quote to search it myself, or the source.