Barstool Pizza Review - Papa's Pizza & Pasta (Milford, CT)

Dave's CT journey takes him to Papa's, the place he was most excited to try on the whole trip.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[abe-love]

I’m from New Haven and lived 30 secs away from this place in Milford, trust me this pizza is a solid 9.1!

And something special about their pizzas in my experience, was the longevity of the great taste. 30 mins, 2 hours, or cold this pizza maintained the same taste! Some pizzas taste like cardboard if you don’t eat it hot.

[reid]

I went to Papa's Pizza today because of your review, . It was the best I have ever had in 50 years of eating pizza. I think it's better than 8.1

[seanlefloch]

As a comparison, Dave gave ah-beetz in Delray Beach, FL an 8.4. There is no way a Florida pizza beats what he just had. Flabbergasted

[starkparker]

Dave's overselling and underscoring on this trip, everybody knows the rules.

[pluggyvids]

Dave should immediately open the box to let the pizza cool while he chats so he doesn’t burn his face off everyone knows the rules

[Jetvictor]

Man his scoring changed so much. This was a 8.4 minimum. Everything is either 7.9 or 8.1 now… unless it’s trash

[bobbyg]

The Foxon flavor Dave couldn't remember was Birch Beer.

[JimJamSandwich]

Only thing to look forward to on a Monday other than sleep. I know we all joke about Dave but the man knows how to make entertaining content, and is genuinely doing a lot of good for these small pizza joints.

[benvasilinda]

Dave is on his kick again of being to tough on the scores. Everyone knows the rules!

[nighthawk]

The way Dave talk about driving from NY to Boston, it's like he's on a mission to Mars.

[DurtyDoobey]

D’oh!! with the Prez assuming the dude is a ‘bit’ older 😂 at 2:18

[dgware]

The #8 from Papa's Pizza is pizza perfection to me. Russ and his crew never disappoint!

[nickmaynard]

That’s an 8.8 all day. Davey didn’t take his adderall today. 😂

[jordangroff]

That pizza looks 8.5+ to me, Dave's standards are bananas

[PawleyWalnuts]

The more pizza Prez reviews the more I realize he is completely lost in the sauce.

[MrJimmyboy]

I love how he still does the little step back and stare into the camera when he gives us an 8 like we don’t already know new haven is gonna be 8s default lol

[NeilAllesee]

my dad is papa pizza. thanks for this.

[aleckasper]

Been watching these damn reviews so long i call the scores on spot accurately more videos then you'd think.

[dtownEE]

"How long have you had this spot for?" .... Est. 1986 across his chest...gotta love Dave

[artrogue]

After all these reviews, Im going to have to visit New Haven.
Never been on my bucket list
but Dave twists my pizza arm.