Military Experts Rate 70 Military Battles In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? Marathon | Insider

Some of the top experts across the Army, Navy, Air Force, and Marines rate battle scenes in movies and television shows for realism.

Dakata Brodie flew for the US Coast Guard for 13 years as a search-and-rescue helicopter pilot and the US Army for eight years as a UH-60 Black Hawk helicopter pilot. He breaks down several Coast Guard rescues.

Former Royal Marines Commando Gareth Timmins dissects "Jarhead," "Sicario: Day of the Soldado," and other desert-warfare scenarios.

Nicholas Irving, a former special-operations sniper and an author, rates the realism of sniper shots from "The Last of Us," "Extraction," and more.

Former United States armor officer and tank historian Nicholas Moran discusses tank scenes in "All Quiet on the Western Front" and "Band of Brothers," among others.

Lamont Christian served in the US Army for 33 years as a combat infantryman and retired in 2018 as the command sergeant major of Fort Jackson, the Army's main training center for basic combat training. He looks at various drill sergeant scenes.

Retired US Army officer and researcher John Spencer analyzes tactics in "Black Hawk Down" and other urban-warfare clips.

Nicholas Moran
@TheChieftainsHatch
Nicholas Irving
@ToughShooter
Gareth Timmims
Lamont Christian
John Spencer

00:00:00 - Intro
00:00:40 - Drill Sergeant
00:20:21 - Tanks
00:41:09 - Sniper
1:01:53 - Bomb Disposal
1:23:37 - Coast Guard
1:40:17 - Urban Warfare
2:00:41 - Desert Warfare
2:18:15 - Credits

WATCH MORE HOW REAL IS IT VIDEOS:
Former NASA Astronaut Rates 9 More Space Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
Martial Art Masters Rate 76 Fight Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider
FBI Spy Rates 12 Spy Scenes In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider

------------------------------------------------------
#Military #HowRealIsIt #insider

Insider is great journalism about what passionate people actually want to know. That’s everything from news to food, celebrity to science, politics to sports and all the rest. It’s smart. It’s fearless. It’s fun. We push the boundaries of digital storytelling. Our mission is to inform and inspire.

Military Experts Rate 70 Military Battles In Movies And TV | How Real Is It? | Insider

[gurumagoo]

My dad said the scene from Forrest Gump, where they were grilling outside with the palm trees, and the Hueys were flying overhead in Vietnam gave him goosebumps. Whoever put that scene together was there too, and it was perfect.

[AddictedToJeepsCom]

Thank you for putting all these experts together into one video! Bravo!

[maxp]

I love how I was like 11 or 13 when Band of Brothers came out and it was immidietly my favorite Show for Years and Years and YEARS and that it still holds up so accurately after almost 20 years and always get's a NEAR perfect rating just goes to Show how much Love and Time went into that Show. Everything about it was great. The Warscenes, The dialogues, The Actors. All of it.

[ac]

A sniper known as 'the Reaper' and he says 'I'm scared of bugs'. Sir, you made my brother's day. He's retired military and was watching this with me, and the laugh he gave as he agreed with you was just precious. Thank you all experts for your service and sacrifice and just for your expertise. Movies should be hiring you guys to get their movies right.

[Toucansam]

The tank guy is just the best. I mean he just loves tanks so much it’s infectious

[haemmertime]

because you mentioned older fuses, in germany we even to this day run quite often into remains of WW2, the worst thing to encounter are bombs with chemical fuses. They use an acid to break membrane, however when this didn't happen on impact or as planned these bombs stay in the ground and could potentially go of every second, it's why they have to be exploded on the spot. To minimize damage they get covered in straw and rubber mats and the area gets isolated with shipping containers to prevent shrapnel and burning bales to fly to far of.

[oldsteve]

Captain Richard Flaherty, 'The Giant Killer', 4'9", 97lbs. Silver Star, 2 Bronze Stars, 2 Purple Hearts and yet wound up homeless. How does a country let that happen to it's heroes?

[Menuki]

I feel like R. Lee Ermey is pretty unassailable as a DI.

His behavior might not follow protocol or be of its day, but it was authentic considering it really was his job. He became the inspiration for so many.

[P-J-W-]

My father was a Marine who served in Vietnam told me a lot about his experience at basic and their reception when they got home but wouldn’t go any further than that. Unfortunately he passed away due to pancreatic cancer a few years ago rather quickly and I never got the chance to talk to him about it anymore. He did say boot in the Marines was brutal back then. They took a young boy and turned you into a Man. He spoke about a big guy in boot who was a mouthy bully to some of the guys. One day he was called away and returned later a different person. Later they found out he had been beaten pretty badly when they noticed all the bruising to his body but the only thing he would ever admit is that it was a training accident. But everyone knew.
My Uncle served in WW2 in the 101st Airborne 501G He’s been in several books and even received several additional medals years later during his funeral issued by then President Clinton. He never talked about his experiences either but I was young at the time and didn’t understand. A few years after his passing I got to read his memoirs which some were included into published books as well as watched some interviews with historians and such for movies, other books and so on. He was even asked to be a part of the making of Band of Brothers but declined. He came home after the war became a farmer and lived the rest of his life in peace. He was an amazing man and gentle but he wasn’t to trifled with either.

[jeffsanders]

You're bringing back memories... When I was in basic, we had one D I almost everybody looked up to, maxed out every PT test. Well, he had a distinctive voice that I could mimic, I probably don't have to go further. But one of my buddies had glasses like his, we stole his brown round and I went room to room imitating him for morale, we had a rough week or so. I get to the last group of guys to prank, walk in the room, everyone that saw me, at ease, I went into my spill, got a laugh, and heard, at ease, stop stop, I said, we've done that already. After lookin at the fear, mostly for me, on all of their faces, my heart fell to my feet. Needless to say, I got a workout of a lifetime. In that process, he told me how he felt about me putting my grubby lil private hands on his brown round. He also told me, he respected why I did it, afterwards

[Unseengenie]

When I went through boot camp at Paris island, the Drill Instructors were some of the funniest people I ever met. But you couldn’t laugh other wise they’d haze the soul out of our bodies.

[josephclark]

I really enjoy Nicholas Irving’s analysis and stories. Not taking anything away from the rest of the folks. I just find the sniper analysis fascinating and I’ve heard other stories from Irving before. He does a great job! These videos are great and I enjoyed everyone’s analysis! Thanks for putting this together. Happy New Year and God bless…

[dagnrl]

You can thank USMC Captain Dale Dye for so many of these movies and shows scenes historical and realistic accuracy that he was a technical advisor on. He was the baddest of the bad, three tours in ‘Nam, a Bronze Star w/ Combat V recipient, multiple Purple Hearts.

[reds]

My only criticism is the ripsaw tank is actually as sick as it looks and can do what he was saying it couldn't on ice. They are made in my state and ive seen it in action personally and its nuts!

[shawnhuff]

For the bomb defusal with the stethoscope, it's entirely accurate. I work on vehicles and diagnose problems. And sometimes in order to determine what is going wrong, such as a clicking noise or a mechanical failure, we have a form of a stethoscope that we can use to find what part(s) are clicking, rubbing, or just mechanically functioning incorrectly. So I'm glad that it was talked about, as well as it being shown in MASH even though in the film was shown as a gag.

[sublimesubaru]

This is why I love YouTube premiums, almost 2 and a half hours of good ad free content. Don't need Netflix or the hundreds of other sites anymore, at least for myself.

[runfoo]

To Mr. Moran While training at NTC back in the early 80s we did indeed attach grappling hooks /w rope to our tracks(M-113 type). The plan was to drive up to the wire toss the grapple over the wire drive back taking the wire with us opening up a gap for the rest of the company.

[sophiaisabelle]

They're the best at expressing their own insights. They always got something informative to say.

[michaelm]

Yes! More reviews with multiple operators! This is good

[Apillis]

57:38 My dad, who was a Master Gunnery Sergeant often said it was typically easier to teach and train women to shoot at the range than it was guys, because typically women would listen more carefully to what they're being told/taught and were more patient about taking their shots. Furthermore, he said the criticism that women tending to second-guess themselves more than men is an asset for women in regards to accurate shooting, because if you think you can do a better shot than what you're dialed in at at that time, you should absolutely reassess rather than just going for it, and sharpshooters, snipers, what-have-you are experts at doing that--obviously far more than your typical person who knows how to shoot a firearm.