Barstool Pizza Review - Cosimo & Johnny's Pizzeria (Eastchester, NY)

After realizing he lowballed the last pizza place, Dave tries another pizzeria in what could be shaping up to a Pizza Alley competitor.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[kekistanirogue]

The pizza score is helped exponentially by the number of beers and lines Dave has had in the hours up to the review.

[profoundwanderer]

At least Dave admitted what we were all complaining about.
Thought that last one was mid/ high 8's for sure.

[paullawson]

I'm starting to notice after like 3 years lol, that if he wants to like a pizza, he bends it in half like a taco to make it look firmer. If he doesn't like the pizza place, he holds it flat and lets it flop then points out the floppyness.

[jameslynch]

Man that determines the fate of every pizza establishment has no idea what different spices taste like.

[MatthewBHoth]

2nd video in a row where Prez went too low on a gorgeous pizza

[oskarmagnusson]

Dave once again destroying the pronunciation of the restaurant, everybody knows the rules

[richardoconnor_photography]

Dave calling semolina 'breadcrumbs'. Everybody knows the rules.

[michaelnugent]

Wow, that score threw me for a loop. That looked and sounded way better than a 7.4. Louie and Ernie’s was my daily after school pizza place every day when I was a kid. I went to PS 14 a few blocks away and my boy lived on the other side of the block from there. LOVED that place! Wish I was still in the BX or even NY for that matter. Nothing compares (yeah, yeah - New Haven style is awesome, but apples and oranges here)

[groobus]

8.4 correction on the previous pie is still a lowball outrage, and he knows it!

[michaelmercury]

I thought Dave was going to score it higher by his reaction.

[monkeygraborange]

*Prez is **_definately_** off his game!!*

[AliUSA]

Once he said it had a “kick” to it it’s never gonna get a great score. “Tang” or “kick” means 7.5 max.

[MegaAwesome]

i always get excited when i see u go to a local place i’m familiar with. eastchester is the home of my grandpa who recently passed away, he always loved supporting these businesses in eastchester

[machinediem]

Pizza has bite! Dave's favorite ingredient on and off the pizza is Oregano. Everybody knows the rules.

[Buddahmonk]

Has Dave been drunk the whole time since he got to this area?

[Roguy]

Dave changes the rules every video, everybody knows the rules.

[pdjhh]

“Breadcrumbs underneath” Pres knows nothing about pizzas everyone knows the rules.

[rg]

Not sure that Dave has ever gotten the name of the pizza place right!

[bigstew]

Looks amazing! Wish we had something like this around Colorado Springs...

[amazingnaturals]

Dave you have to go to Slice Of Scarsdale in the next town over from Eastchester. That is the best around by far. And also 30 minutes north of that to Baci Trattoria. They are the best!