Prehistoric Planet Trex Uses Jurassic Park Trex Roars

I'm sorry for making the video look messy, its to avoid copyright claims. this video is fair use because the clips are used in a different context and to make a point.

let me make this very clear, i do not have a problem with the sound designers using jp trex sounds, it might be used to reference jurassic park, a easter egg, maybe, i like the sounds. however, its a documentary about teaching people about real dinosaurs, they use the latest science to reconstruct these animals, so using jurassic park sounds goes against that. its like making a documentary about space with star wars sound effects.

as for the tiger growl, i dont mind it, but its too obvious its from a tiger.

by the way, i don't count the sped up clip, its just me going deep and looking for it. atleast they tried to hide the fact its a jp trex sound in the original speed.

[grumplysoapstudio]

Well out of the JP Rex’s sounds, those are the most accurate. They were raspy bellows instead of full on roars

[macabrevoid]

Honestly it’s hidden so well that I don’t mind. Also it’s fun lil homage and it doesn’t sound like a stock sound and fits the Rex.
Even after all these years, we can still never let go of that legendary trex sound

[deathsonggaming]

I got a prehistoric planet ad on this lol

But to be honest, as a Jurassic park fan and paleontology nerd, I didn’t even notice, and the noises sounded realistic enough to me. The noises BBC used for their animals sound accurate, and sound like crocodilians, grunts, hisses, growls, and bellows. We never get a full on awesomebro roar, all the noises seem to be done and pitched well. So I don’t mind this. The loudest or most roar like noises the animals make seem to be the limit, any louder and they would hurt themselves or be incapable of. And in the show, this limit is still lower than Jurassic parks loud ass big mammal roars. So I don’t mind this. I think they did it well. They still accurately depicted them, but I do wish we also got other sounds from them that have been suggested, like the low rumbling and the dinosaur vocalization study noises. Although similar noises to those were thrown in there, so that’s good.

[gandalfthewhite.]

I hope people realize that not everything in JP is inaccurate. A lot of it is, but the bellows and low sounds the dinosaurs make are not that far fetched. The roars are, but not the bellows.

[a_draw]

its so subtle its fine. Not everything in JP is inaccurate lmao.

[ProWalter]

Besides the obvious tiger roar, i really dont see anything wrong with it. The sounds are low enough mixed in with crocodile hisses and bellows thats its fairly accurate to what it could have sounded like. And its not like its roaring every 5 seconds to make sure everyone knows where it is.

[blckmmba]

It’s such a loved and big powerful animal that we can’t help but expect the same for its vocal noises.

[dinomation]

Interesting to see that the sound effects connect these two properties!

[melvinshine]

Nice use of the more low-key roars. Fits with the more "I'm here" or "I want you to leave" sort of behavior in the scenes shown, as opposed to a "let's do this shit right now" roar.

[gwit]

i can't believe they didn't record a real trex

[unaizilla]

this is the proof that you can use stock sounds for a documentary if you know how to use them

[FieryRed_BE]

they used lion roars and crocodile hisses. just like jurassic park. but mixed differently

[ZombieChicken]

Paleo Community vs JP Fans
"Yours is cringe!!!"

Prehistoric Planet 🤝🏼 JP

[channelgrantito]

Honestly it doesn't bother me at all that they chose to use *these* particular sounds. Trex is theorized to have an interesting vocal range that consists of reptilian hisses, rumbles and hums that could be "felt" instead of heard, so using this edited, low-pitched bellow is fairly representative of a sound it may have been able to produce. At least they didn't you a bombastic, trumpeting roar from the JP films, and picked a more accurate (all things considered) sound.

[megaofterror]

I don't really see problem with it, as long it is not the actual jp rex roar, this is fine

[mlgodzilla]

The definition for roar is so broad that this isn’t that bad

[omarbaba]

I like how the dinosaurs aren’t just constantly loudly roaring in this documentary for no reason, in reality they probably couldn’t roar at all

[Memeraptor]

0:08 that was the gorgosaurus sfx from the wwd movie

[oni-kaiju]

Didn't dinosaurs need a Larynx to make such sounds???

[Nasuto]

So what. The JP trex sounds get used literally everywhere. I dont blame Prehistoic Planet for using some of them. and even then, they only seem to have used the most accurate ones to what we believe trex soundend like.