Barstool Pizza Review - Gino's (Williston Park, NY)

Dave continues his Long Island trip on Gino's, and his opinion of the areas pizza has not changed.




Follow Barstool Sports here:

[michaelfaircloth]

This is Thomas' second favorite pizza place. It's usually an 8.3 but not today it's too loose.

[EatonPoosay]

Loving the Walgreens manager look, Dave!

[ifryday]

That’s that Ninja Turtle pizza! We all want that!

[johnnyisahermit]

bro the lack of flop was INSANE for how heavy that shit looks

[sambourgjason]

We need the Thomas's score now ! Dave mights soften a bit

[gsgbm]

‘It is heavy, it’s good it’s just heavy’.
15 seconds later ‘it’s actually pretty good, plus it’s light.’

[MakesSenseKnowledge]

"whats the score?" You can literally hear him talking about the pizza and seeing him eat it guy.. give him a minute.
When did people become so clueless?

[Biscotti]

This is my families go to Pizza joint when in Long Island. Best pizza I've ever had

[jaykay]

Wow, didn't think it was going to break 7.1 based on how it looked. I think he has a tendency to underrate that style of pie, when you're in the mood for that style they can be
very satisfying. As good as New Haven style is, once in a while I like an "ooeey-gooey", heavy pie.

[scottmcwave]

Why do they interrupt Dave in the middle of the review? Everybody knows the rules!

[dezbro]

I'm from LI NY. That pie looks delicious lol. One man's 7.4 is anothers 8.2.

[scottulrich]

Dave looking like a goombah at the horse races in the 70's. fits right in.

[jaysharp]

I’m from Brooklyn, but I drive truck through Long Island every day for decades. So I stop at pizzerias across the entire island. I know them all. And I don’t know what he’s talking about, as far as Long Island having “thick crust pizza? I mean sure, some are thicker than others, but the traditional Long Island slices actually very thin. In some cases, it’s actually too thin to where it doesn’t hold up. But I don’t think there’s a real stereotype for Long Island pizza. Each Pizzeria’s different.. kinda has all styles, really. I can name dozens of Long Island pizzerias with great thin crispy crust

[soulkin]

I rarely remark, grateful for these reviews. Some of my favorite stuff is guessing the score before Dave's delivery. I nailed this one at 7.4 and secretly celebrated it until I shared it here! Keep up the good work and continue to support local businesses. Thank you, Dave!

[Ggggggggggh-]

That plastic cup on top added lots of flavour

[alanealonzo]

As soon as he said "it's good...but it's heavy" I knew it was a 7.4

[gavincusick]

“This is a wintery football pizza” 😂😂😂 sounded like Michael Scott describing wine “has sort of an oaky afterbirth”

[BryantMartinez]

At this point we are stuck on the mid 7’s it’s been soo long since an 8+

[generalfrosty]

Carmelas, On Hempstead TPKE, Long Island New York! best slice you will ever have

[samryan]

That's 100% an 8.0+ all day. 👍
Not the burnt Melba toast you grew-up on. 😝