Percy Jackson readers listen up 🙌😅 #books #booktok

preview_player
Показать описание

Рекомендации по теме
Комментарии
Автор

ALSO I just wanted to say this is my two cents as a language fan and Percy Jackson nerd, explaining why a show about Greek gods would use a Greek pronunciation. HOWEVER, names are SO nuanced and arguably the trickiest part of languages. THEREFORE, if your friend or someone you know pronounces THEIR OWN NAME as "Tallia", RESPECT THEIR NAME and pronounce it however THEY want it pronounced. This is just some fun reader discourse, don't be a brat in real life.

beckleavesley
Автор

The “th” does not exist in French, so when I first read it and if I’m talking in French, it’s “Talia”. But during my re-read in English, I read “Thalia”, cause that’s the way you do in English for th

jeannefostergoriot
Автор

i think part of the problem is the audiobooks pronounce it “Talia” (if i recall correctly)

katheodusvods
Автор

as a person who is greek and speaks the language fluently i am extremely glad to see someone bringing this up

our_weird_obsessions
Автор

FINALLY SOMEONE SAID IT
being greek and reading percy jackson is an experience

cabin_
Автор

I pronounce it Tall-ia because that’s how the only person I know with that name pronounced it. So that’s how I say it. Tbh, how you pronounce a name depends on the person whose name it is. Of course there are original pronunciations, but there can be correct pronunciation that aren’t how it is originally pronounced in its language or origin.

knee_has_a_ligament
Автор

Couldn’t focus on anything but how ENCHANTING HER EYES ARE OMG

fionamulder
Автор

Yes ma’am, I won’t make the same mistake twice🫡 (I pronounce it Thalia anyway)

TheBookishMK
Автор

This validated and healed me calling her that since i was a child thank you lol

gannonic
Автор

Though curiously enough while this is seemingly true in the more modern Greek (I haven't studied it) I was taught that in the ancient Attic pronunciation, Theta was an aspirated consonant so would have been pronounced as a hard T - so would have been pronounced Talia then.

maxbotten
Автор

I can not express how grateful I am for someone to FINALY point this out

RedSkyFantasy
Автор

THANK YOU! i always here people say tall-ia and i dont have the courage to correct them

karenwitt
Автор

Þ
This is thorn [þ] it was originally used in old English as the 'th' sound but eventually was removed, to replaced [þ] the added a 'y' instead that's why you see 'ye old tavern' instead of 'the old tavern' it's because 'ye' was originally writing like this þe
Thank you for reading :>
Also, correct me on any incorrect facts I didn't recheck to see if i got anything wrong.
Edit: changed yee to ye

day_vee_girl
Автор

Thank you for this i have been wondering if its pronounced "t" or "th" for years. Thank you so much for clearing it up

MyLoveFor_Elijah
Автор

Thats not even how names work. When they hit other languages or exist for extended time, they shift and develop new sounds. Talia is a perfectly acceptable name, unless your planning on calling every José, Ivan and Giovanni John.

davestrider
Автор

Honestly I was pronouncing Chiron wrong for the whole first book (I have learned since then) so please do correct me

MCcreations
Автор

I used to say Thalia but while I was reading TTC I saw a Movie Flame video and he said Thalia (with a TH) and talked about how everyone said Tahlia. After that I always pronounced it with a TH and told anyone who said it wrong what it actually was, I never pressed them to change, just informed them what it was actually

Poseidons_Daughter_Sienna
Автор

I am so tired today that every time you said thalia, my brain just refused to listen and the first part of her name just dissolved into white noise 😢. i’ve listened to this like three times now 😭

kaylamoerman
Автор

I'm Italian and in the Italian version of the pjo books it's spelled "Talia" but anyway I've been pronouncing that right since the beginning somehow :D


Also I felt that inside me when you said it😔✨️

MiriamSolace
Автор

But your forgetting one key part: the author thought it was Talia, and therefore thats how the name should be pronounced for this specific character, because that was what the author INTENDED her name to sound like

ceephii