Was the Quran Ever Changed? - Dr. Shabir Ally

[tetsaiga]

Beautifully stated. For those confused he is not saying that the Quran has been changed. He is simply adding how pronouncation was an issue, that why vowels were used to make sure the Holy Quran is read properly.

[alr.]

The Qur'an is complete because Allah says it has been preserved. The missing Suras and Ayats were simply abrogated by Allah, the way Allah abrogated them was by Muslims forgetting them or being eaten by Aisha's sheep.

[bowrudder]

In this video he says that all Muslims use the same Quran. But in a different video he says that different Muslims use different versions (the Hafs, the Warsh, etc.).

[jacobahmed]

Koran changed or not does not make it perfect. There are many books and stories which are not changed. Message of the book qualifies it is word of God or not.

[aidaabdur-rashid]

The Qur'an is preserved not only in writing-but also in recitation. Alhamdulillah !

[S]

Can someone explain the Alef, Lam, Mim of quran ? Let us say Alef is one and Lam is 12, then Mim is 13. Now, we can write: Mim = Alef + Lam. For this reason, the 13th floor is written 12+1 floor. How did Muhammad know this 1400 years ago?

[MrXxhamoodxx]

there are no different Qurans because u could go to Uk and recite the Quran in Arabic and then u could go to India and recite the same thing and no one would say u are wrong because my version say this and this and this

[thereisnogod]

They copied from that copie and send those copies to the important cities
If they copied from the original like he is telling here, WHY did they have to burn the originals ????
Something very strange

[Noor-fxbb]

Do you know where is the oldest Quran with all 114 chapters and when was it written?

[cervezaway]

Allah is great, but Allah cannot ensure that his word is accurately recorded and transmitted- 37 different Arabic qurans to date 🤔

[rahmathidayatd]

Anyone can show me different verse of quran???? Can u find deleted or added verses??? SHOW ME!!!

[MixtapeKilla]

More CHANGES IN THE QURAN


All Muslim scholars concur—such as Al-Bukhari (part 6, page 225), Suyuti in "The Itqan" (part 1, page 170), and Ibn Kathir in "The Beginning and the End" (part 7, page 218) in which he remarks, "’Uthman burned the rest of the copies which were in the hands of the people because they disagreed on the (correct) reading and they fought among themselves. When they came to take ibn Mas’ud’s copy to bum it, he told them, ‘I know more than Zayd ibn Thabit (whom ’Uthman ordered to collect the copies of the Qur’an).’ ’Uthman wrote to ibn Mas’ud asking him to submit his copy for burning."


On page 41, he adds:



"Ibn Qutayba says that the differences between the recitations of the various Qur’anic copies may include the meaning also."



Also on page 109, he says:



"When Abu Bakr and ’Umar assigned Zayd ibn Thabit to compile the Qur’an, there was a previous compilation of the Qur’an made by a group of the greatest companions such as ’Ali ibn Abi Talib, ibn Mas’ud and ibn ’Abbas and others."

[fshs]

I have seen one converted Muslim showing 26 different qurans. No one could not give explanation. You have Quran. And hadith. Which came first?

[internetmail]

The issue is how is the meaning of the verse about Allah's Religion being preserved to be understood. You only need to change one word in a translation of the meaning of quran to change a sentences complete meaning. Without knowing classical arabic you have to keep an open mind. It could mean that tmrw someone will dig up an original Quran (or forged quran) or it could mean the Quran is already preserved. Or it could mean something else. There's enough evidence in Quran to know it's the truth regardless of how you translate the meaning of that verse. I doubt people who are fluent in classical arabic can even agree on translating the meaning of some words.

[stevenvee]

Petros Christoffel

There are two things, Ahruf meaning letter or dialect, and Qira'at meaning reading. There are seven ahruf and 10 qira'at. Muhammad recited the Qu'ran in seven ahruf or dialects though this was only changes in the sound and not the content or the words at all. Like Tuda Set said, it was a change from long A's to short A's for example. When the Qu'ran was compiled together, one Ahruf was kept and that was the accent of the Quraysh because that was the most important one as this was the dialect of Muhammad and the majority of his companions.

The 10 Qira'at or recitations has different sounds and slight variations of words but not content. In the first chapter for example, one recitation says "King of the Day of Judgement" and another says "Possessor of the Day of Judgement". In both cases, the letters stay the same as Arabic like other semitic languages has consonants so both read M-L-K. The consonants never change. There are only very minor differences like this in the recitation and in no case does it change any meaning. This is significant because the Qu'ran even has a specific way of pronunciation and this is kept from the time of the Prophet without change.

[telangusan]

Is there any original copy of the original quran to this day? Can anybody tell me where to find the original quran?

[kudzuking]

You can go to any bookstore and find several different translations of the Quran...

[amrutha]

The Quran that is in the Turkey museum said to be the Quran used by Caliph Uthman, the researchers have found out that there are more 2100 differences when compared to today's Quran. Not just in the consonants but in the entire meaning of the verse. Some of the verses are completely opposite to what the older version has said.

[adnanadill]

Why Quran is the Book of Allah, the creator, the planner, the programmer, then maintainer, the Originator of entire universe?
Because Allah SWT Himself designed Quran, in such a way that Prooves it authenticity, and it depends on your education, how much you can communicate with Quran.
It answers all the Question of people who doubts its authenticity, in any period of time.
You Question it, and Quran will answer it, but you should know, how to search your answer in Quran.
Or ask a person that is well versed in Arabic and who is perfect in Quran.
In translation, you won’t find your answer up to perfection.

Quran means a book that inculcates to discover / explore itself.
I will explain you, my analysis, why I take Quran as authentic ?
First Proof, Creation / initiation of Arabic language in a small, remote village, and its selection for purpose of Quran, then universalization of it and keeping it alive and intact for all times.
Why selection of small remote and illiterate people, not connected to remaining World ?
Before this think, why creation of desert land in center of Planet Earth ?
It was under the plan and Program of Allah SWT of thousands of years.
If you analyses formation of Planet earth and the civilizations history and connect the dots, you will find a great program going on unnoticed since, creation of planet earth.
Then analyses, why sending of Ibrahim AS and his family in center of hot desert and starting of water fountain.
Second Proof, termination of all the previous languages in which Holy Scriptures was revealed, or Holy people use to communicate with their people.
It was not by chance or negligence but on well planned purpose, to make room for Arabic language as only holy language to survive
till end of times.
You will find, all the communication of Allah SWT before creation of man, was in Arabic language.
Every language belongs to God, but he specially designed Arabic language to fill the purpose.
Every word of Arabic language is a library in itself, in comparison to our living languages, the word “Allah” itself requires volumes of Explanations to understand to perfection.
Third proof, challenges in Quran to prove itself wrong.
Fourth proof, explanation of great phenomena of modern sciences / discoveries, which we discovered by created great instrument and Probes with trillion dollar projects of scientists like NASA, ISRO, EMBL, CERN talked by illiterate of Arab that too 1500 years back.
Analyses this methodology of Allah SWT and connect the dots, you will find God created humans with skills of sciences and communication and He Himself waiting at other end to reply and expose himself to those who reached Him by His designed way of sciences and communication.

[nathanoosterhuis]

So the quran is clearly not clear. Written in vague words. So that people will forever debate the interpretation... What about all the different versions. Allah is the worst communicator.