Eli Manning or Aaron Rodgers: who’s career would you rather have? 🤔 | THE HERD #shorts

Colin Cowherd compares Eli Manning to Aaron Rodgers and explains he would rather have Eli’s career due to more Super Bowl victories.

#TheHerd #NFL #EliManning




About The Herd with Colin Cowherd:
The Herd with Colin Cowherd is a three-hour sports television and radio show on FS1 and iHeartRadio. Every day, Colin will give you his authentic, unfiltered opinion on the day’s biggest sports topics.

Eli Manning or Aaron Rodgers: who’s career would you rather have? 🤔 | THE HERD #shorts

The Herd with Colin Cowherd

[bensmith]

Definitely taking Nick Foles' career over Dan Marino's career

[HYPRZER]

“He’s got 1, he’s not even close to 2” You LITERALLY can not get closer to 2 😂😂😂

[awakenchildofgod]

If the media would stop acting like the QB is the only asset to winning a Superbowl we could have media with a legitimate perspective

[sitzdavid]

No body ever mentions Terry Bradshaw and he has 4 😢

[kingengine]

This is the kind of take a 5 year old would have.

[patrickjose]

I completely agree 💯% Aaron R. is extremely talented, Eli throws in both SuperBowls are "Highlight Reels". Beating an undefeated team & beating N.E. again. **UNREAL** Eli M. >>----TRUE INDEED---->>

[Kaisaccountt]

The quarterback with 4 regular season mvps.

[BIGGLOUPR]

Elway has 💍💍..back to back, Terry Bradshaw has FOUR 💍💍💍💍 Jim Plunkett has 💍💍Phil Sims has 💍💍and Troy Aikman has 💍💍💍of them....don't know how Colin left these 5 Cats out of that Class of 2 (💍💍)or more Super Bowl Wins🤷💯

[brodiebruce]

No brainier, I'd take Aaron's career every single time. Just look to TD to interception ratio. Remember when Aaron was benched because he sucked so bad?? Me either, that was Eli.
In the 230 contests in his career, Rodgers has been successful on 5, 001 of his 7, 660 attempts for 59, 055 yds. He is averaging 256.8 yds per contest through the air with a 103.9 quarterback rating. Rodgers has thrown 475 touchdowns while tossing 105 interceptions and the longest pass of his career went for 93 yds. He’s lost 3, 596 yards while being the victim of a quarterback sack 530 different times. His TD rate when attempting a pass is 6.2% and his interception percentage is 1.4%.

During the 236 contests in his career, Manning connected on 4, 895 of his 8, 119 attempts for 57, 023 yds. He totaled 241.6 yds per contest through the air with a 84.1 QB rating. Manning threw for 366 TD’s while tossing 244 picks and the longest pass of his career went for 99 yards. He lost a combined 2, 870 yds while being sacked 411 different times. His touchdown percentage on pass attempts was 4.5% and his interception rate was 3.0%.

[crush_]

Both of those Giants Superbowls was about that defense, Eli made a super clutch throw in each game but dude was average in every other season he played. Led the league in turnovers multiple times, whoever said Eli career is better smoke a lot of rocks

[VinnyC]

Christ, this guy has ALWAYS hated the Jets and now that Aaron Rogers is a Jet he’s unloaded all that hate towards him too, Hey Colin how’s Darnold look these days?

[josephwhitfield]

Anyone who says Eli clearly didn’t watch his career.

[matthewdorso]

This is hilarious. No doubt I would take Rodgers career over Eli. Rodgers is (conservatively) a top 10 QB of all time. Eli is somewhere between 25 and 50. Colin has a lot of hate for Rodgers and it’s baffling. Can’t take his Rodgers takes seriously. Also I was not aware that 1 was not close to 2. Noted!

[namenotavailable]

I'm taking the career that got the most lays. So give me Namath's.

[kylezarnowski]

Eli manning was carried to 2 super bowls by 2 amazing defenses. When in his career was he ever considered a top 5 qb lol

[sprintstothebathroomdaily]

Media have it out for aaron.

They give him a harder time than dudes with criminal charges.

If mike vick comes on your show you got no room for moral judgements of players

[ponderosa]

Rodgers went to 5 NFC championships. How is that not close to getting a 2nd SB ring.
Terrible argument.

[shaneclotiaux]

"He's not close to two". Wtf

[Chalk]

I’ve always said this about Eli Manning - would have loved consistency from him and the Giants, but years from now I’ll still remember going to the parade and enjoying those two Super Bowls.

One thing I’ll never understand from a fan’s perspective - who cares about individual awards if your team didn’t win the ultimate prize?

[marksgarage]

What about the bench warmers that have 2 or more